Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Scruffy8642]

I only read a few chapters of Illegal Rare, but from what I did it seemed way more interesting than most of the stuff that goes through Jump, I could hardly believe it got cancelled so early. Maybe it went to shit later on, or I just have shit taste, I certainly hope that won't happen here. I mean, with just Tamura and Fujimaki's comedy alone they should be able to make decent success id imagine. Both their latest one shots were bloody hilarious so I'm happy they're both back. Although the Japs don't seem to appreciate the masterpiece that is Saiki, so maybe not?

 

[ElJin]

Wow, 6 new series is insane. From what I remember, I never saw so many mangas starting from once.

The last time a big amount of series started together like this was in Kagamigami, Black Clover, UBS and Roggy's batch, wasn't it?

 

[G_I_A]

Tamura and Shiibashi are very comparable, their series went pretty much the exact same way in terms of popularity.

In the day of judgement you shall be no excused by that sin.

Beelzebub is beyond better than Nurarihyon no Mago.

 

[Mammo]

Guys why is anyone making any predictions whatsoever as to what series is going to be good before the preview page is uploaded and we can see which one has the best boys?
Maybe I've just come to expect too much.

If you think people won't start guessing which manga will be good based on the preview page you're giving people too much credit

 

[vampire killer]

Beelzebub volumes couldn't even sell 200k per weak. The manga survived o long only cos jump would end newer series. In the end no one care for it in japan.

 

[Mammo]

gag and comedy manga don't usually sell a lot

it ran for 6 years and got a long running anime

it was a success and a notable series in the magazine recent history

 

[Leoat12]

Guys why is anyone making any predictions whatsoever as to what series is going to be good before the preview page is uploaded and we can see which one has the best boys?
Maybe I've just come to expect too much.

I was about to put some sense into people's minds again here, but I was too late. XD

Normally it doesn't make much sense to make predictions early, but in this case most of the new series are from artist that have either already obtain some success or have a decent collection of work. I think this time it's actually justified to guess which series will be the successes. Plus, it's always fun when new series come around, but this time we have more than usual

The fact that they had previous successes doesn't mean anything. We know that. The newbie can make a series and make success and a veteran don't. We have many examples.

Sorry Leoat, but battle manga is more my thing xD Anyway, we already have Ghost Tits, and I really don't want another Nisekoi.

You will not be forgiven of this heresy.

 

[Mammo]

Does anyone read Origin? Does it look like it's ending?

I don't see how Boichi can draw 2 ongoing weekly manga in the same time

 

[Swavey]

An anime adaptation of Hinomaru Zumou by Kyoto Animation could dethrone One Piece

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

An anime adaptation of Hinomaru Zumou by Kyoto Animation could dethrone One Piece

Implying that One Piece is in a throne.

 

[Swavey]

Implying that One Piece is in a throne.

There is no debating numbers it holds the Jump throne

 

[Mammo]

>all these new people trying to be sharkbait instead of adding to the conversation

come on people you're better than this

 

[SharkBait]

I feel like Black Clover will slowly get pushed out of the consistent top 3 ranks this year

Impossible, as long as he keeps doing what he's been doing it should consistently stay high. Everyone is in this for the long haul and there is nothing, absolutely nothing, that will cannibalize its popularity in 2017.

 

[Mammo]

forget the top 3, It was out of the top 5 twice this arc

 

[SharkBait]

>all these new people trying to be sharkbait instead of adding to the conversation

come on people you're better than this

Hi.

 

[Mammo]

hello.

I'm just saying you're often imitated but never duplicated

 

[SharkBait]

forget the top 3, It was out of the top 5 twice this arc

I think it was first place those weeks. Like World Trigger the editors put it in a lower place to give visibility to series that desperately needed the popularity. Itd be unfair to keep a popular series in the lead without giving the opportunity to other authors. You shouldnt always believe in the lower placement of an accomplished series.

 

[Mammo]

It's weird how editors' mind games never affect OP and BnHA

 

[G_I_A]

Does anyone read Origin? Does it look like it's ending?

I don't see how Boichi can draw 2 ongoing weekly manga in the same time

I translate the series. It's nowhere near it's ending and it's very popular and good.

Implying that One Piece is in a throne.

Really? The most sold manga of all damn time is not in a "throne". Yeah people... You can do better than this.

And omg, Beelzebub is REALLY good. It sold a lot even here in Brazil, the anime had consistent numbers and the manga despite not selling like battle shounen does, was fine by gag ratings.

And again, it IS better than Nurarihyon no Mago.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 25, 2017, Original Post Date: Jan 25, 2017 ---

I was about to put some sense into people's minds again here, but I was too late. XD


The fact that they had previous successes doesn't mean anything. We know that. The newbie can make a series and make success and a veteran don't. We have many examples.

You will not be forgiven of this heresy.

Indeed. Even so it's way easier for veteran mangaka to do better cause they already have a fandom behind it. Check the most recent successes: Ansatsu, Boku no Hero Academia and even Black Clover. All made by veteran mangaka.

Promised Neverland is one of a kind manga.

 

[SharkBait]

Indeed. Even so it's way easier for veteran mangaka to do better cause they already have a fandom behind it. Check the most recent successes: Ansatsu, Boku no Hero Academia and even Black Clover. All made by veteran mangaka.

I dont understand, do you really think there were THAT many Barrage readers who enabled Hirokoshi to have an EASIER chance of being successful?