Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[TyVip]

Thank you , 37.3% in average, so 62.7% these two are what I was looking for.

 

[Kave]

Might as well post estimated sales again

30 days (Oricon + Weekly POS):

380,385　Shokugeki no Souma 21
266,763　Gintama 67
227,593　Toriko 43
145,121　World's End Harem 2
123,463　Saiki Kusuo no Ψ-nan 19
*45,747　Karadasagashi 11
*39,755　ēlDLIVE 7

59 days:

792,417　Haikyuu!! 24
338,622　Boruto: Naruto Next Generations 2
337,536　World Trigger 17
229,815　Toriko 42
176,456　Black Clover 9
143,084　Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san 4
104,276　Yakusoku no Neverland 1
*68,620　Kimetsu no Yaiba 4

 

[Leoat12]

They have to have some stock, they cannot print exactly the number they think it will sell. Also, print in bulk is cheaper as well, so to avoid having to reprint too often they have to print spare copies. It is obvious that they don't do this to inflate and make it look good, they will be losing money.

 

[SoldadoInvernal]

When Shoseki ranking update?

 

[Tamil]

Shouldn't we have gotten like the top 200 volume list for 2016 by now? And top 50 series list for 2016?

 

[Heiji]

In march

 

[dark123]

When Fallen Angel's was translating MHA, they made a commitment to only translate the manga on Mondays after the Viz release for people that couldn't get Viz. It pissed some people off because the raws were out and they had to wait 4 days for a translated chapter. IMO it allowed Mangastream to steal their readers, and really until recently they began translating it early again. Imo they should've just kept sticking to what they were doing on Mondays since it makes them seem more honorable (ironic I know)

You are wrong bro. Our translator prefer to release earlier because he wants more people to read better translation than that one coming from manga stream. Now that we can again release earlier it is possible but of course later after official release in Japan we release HQ version. So we do double work for future readers to give them best quality and we are doing it for free because it is our hobby unlike MS. For a long time we simply couldn't release earlier because all raw providers except those from MS were arrested so it almost killed all Edited Manga teams.

 

[OMEYG]

For all you WSJ ToC rankings aficionados out there, I have made an interactive chart which tracks how well all of the popular series have been doing using the past 2 years of rankings data. Please read the Explanatory Notes if you want to know how I got the graphs that I did.

 

[ShenGao]

Chapter 1 of "We can't study".

 

[G_I_A]

I liked the characters, the girls (hope the short haired one wins, but oh well...) the plot seems fine too but... I don't know... Maybe if this series started it's serialization within a bunch of rookies only, it could last...

But I just can't see it beating Tamura, Inagaki+Boichi and Tadatoshi...

 

[Mammo]

there could be as many girls in the harem as there are classes and subjects

I see what you did mr mangaka

 

[Doughboy]

I liked the first chapter alot, it was funnier than I thought it would be. Both girls look good so it's not a matter of picking best girl, cause both are. I'll follow this for sure

 

[savethecat]

Enjoyed chapter 1 a lot more than I thought I would

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

I don't even know if there's a way to pick one of these two, because this chapter had almost no exposure for the girls.

 

[HIGAN0]

I really enjoy this chapter......but I hope series to stay away from the "harem" genre.....

 

[Nakura]

I thought it was fine. The art was really good, but I don't have much feelings towards the girls. Also, the fan service at the end of the chapter felt super out of place.

 

[Swavey]

I thought it was fine. The art was really good, but I don't have much feelings towards the girls. Also, the fan service at the end of the chapter felt super out of place.

Every vote counts

 

[SkerllyFC]

You know, the Kyubi/4thGear/Getsuga Tenshou/Adult Gon thing would have work in Black Clover if it was established early on in the story, like in other shounen series. It´s obvious this manga is made up on the run. Well, at least Pierrot will see the potential. Or what, Am I not allowed to state an opinion?

 

[Doughboy]

Fanservice = $$$. I have been wondering though on this topic for a little, it's starting to seem like more and more manga/animes nowadays use more fanservice compared to when we grew up with milder animes. At the same time, a few years back I watched DBZ Uncut which is the uncensored version... I never realized how many fanservice scenes occurred with Bulma and Android 18. I don't have a problem w/ fanservice usually unless it's smacked in serious scenes

 

[Newkerzy]

You know, the Kyubi/4thGear/Getsuga Tenshou/Adult Gon thing would have work in Black Clover if it was established early on in the story, like in other shounen series. It´s obvious this manga is made up on the run. Well, at least Pierrot will see the potential. Or what, Am I not allowed to state an opinion?

Funny thing is, I was hoping and expecting for Deku to go through something like this pre-Kamino if All Might dies. It wouldn't be some kind of hidden power awakened per se, but just a Deku that's been driven to the edge and utterly snapped using 100% OFA unconsconciously and miraculously, is not suffering the backlash/or the backlash reduced. And even, it'd still lead to development for his character.