Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Tamil]

What are your guys' favourite anime adaptation of a WSJ series? I think mine is Gintama.

#1 is Jojo, #2 is HxH 2011 and #3 is YYH or the other HxH adaptation.

 

[G_I_A]

If BONES produces Season 3 of MHA and throw all of their money on it, I have no doubt it will be the best WSJ adaptation ever.

loool...

It's amazing how overhyped this series is.

MHA is not One Piece... Hunter x Hunter or Naruto... Just give up... It's a seasoned anime based on an "ok" series. One bound to be forgotten in a couple of years.

BTW: Shingeki is the anime of this year. So bad for My failure academia.

 

[Nakura]

MHA is not One Piece... Hunter x Hunter or Naruto... Just give up... It's a seasoned anime based on an "ok" series. One bound to be forgotten in a couple of years.

What does that have to do with him liking the idea of a well adapted 3rd season of MHA though?

 

[G_I_A]

What does that have to do with him liking the idea of a well adapted 3rd season of MHA though?

Well adapted is WAY different than "best adaptation ever".

 

[Tamil]

Any studios you think that may animate HZ at this point?

 

[Nakura]

Well adapted is WAY different than "best adaptation ever".

And you think the One Piece and Naruto anime are?

 

[G_I_A]

And you think the One Piece and Naruto anime are?

Of course not and I already replied to that.

 

[TyVip]

To Love Ru best animu ever.

More recent one would be Bakuman, Knb and Haikyuu and Food War season 2.

There are too many to narrownit down :/

 

[WyldViolet]

I thought the Bakuman adaptation was a horribly boring butch job of such an exciting manga.

 

[G_I_A]

I thought the Bakuman adaptation was a horribly boring butch job of such an exciting manga.

And it is. No panty flash fighting is just unforgivable.

 

[KageTrigger]

HxH 2011 is my favorite adaptation, second would be Yu Yu Hakusho, and third Yu-Gi-Oh!

 

[Leoat12]

Haikyuu was the best anime in the recent years, I think there is no better adaptation in terms of animation quality and faithfulness with the original material, which are both the most important things to me in any anime adapting a manga.

 

[Nakura]

Definitely. In recent years I think Haikyu is unrivalled. I really love the vibe of the show as well.

 

[G_I_A]

Agreed, recently Haikyuu is indeed the best by far. The sountrack is particularly awesome.

 

[savethecat]

loool...

It's amazing how overhyped this series is.

MHA is not One Piece... Hunter x Hunter or Naruto... Just give up... It's a seasoned anime based on an "ok" series. One bound to be forgotten in a couple of years.

BTW: Shingeki is the anime of this year. So bad for My failure academia.

Jesus Christ, why are you such a hater

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 1, 2017, Original Post Date: Apr 1, 2017 ---

Haikyuu was the best anime in the recent years, I think there is no better adaptation in terms of animation quality and faithfulness with the original material, which are both the most important things to me in any anime adapting a manga.

I agree Haikyuu is one of the best. Although personally I feel like some anime should deviate and make improvements to the source material sometime. I don't think any manga is perfect, so I believe an anime is the perfect chance to make small change it and patch up some of its flaws

 

[Avok]

Jesus Christ, why are you such a hater

As much as I don't want to acknowledge it, he is right.
"Best WSJ adaptation ever", come on.

 

[savethecat]

As much as I don't want to acknowledge it, he is right.
"Best WSJ adaptation ever", come on.

Not that I agree, but this if that's the guys opinion that's perfectly fine.
But this response is more so directed to wards his "this is not One Piece. This is not Naruto. My Fail Academia will be forgotten in 2 years" part of his message

 

[Shinji Hirako]

Haikyu, Hunter x Hunter 1999 and Bleach are my favourite adaptations.

Haikyu has amazing animation and the atmosphere during matches is so realistic. Hunter x Hunter 1999 fits the dark vibe the series gives off. Honestly the Yorknew city arc adaptation is in my top 5 anime arcs of all time and by the way that's my favourite arc in the series. Bleach may have a lot of filler but in my opinion the filler arcs are way more enjoyable than Naruto's for example. The combination of Noriyuki Abe as director and Shiro Sagisu working on the amazing ost makes Bleach easily one of the best adapted long running shonen series in Jump.

 

[Mammo]

As much as I don't want to acknowledge it, he is right.
"Best WSJ adaptation ever", come on.

sorry, but he's right about what exactly? I reread his post multiple times and there's zero argument in it

he mentioned that BnHA is not Op, Naruto and HxH all of which have nothing to do with the post

then mentioned AoT which is not even a WSJ manga adaptation and have nothing to do with Newkerzy's post

and stitched and filled his post with insults because why not? the mods seems to not mind it

where is the criticism? where's the argument?

or are you agreeing with his statement that AoT will be the anime of the year? because that's just as an empty of an assumption as the "Best WSJ adaptation ever" assumption

 

[Tamil]

If BONES produces Season 3 of MHA and throw all of their money on it, I have no doubt it will be the best WSJ adaptation ever.

Bones has some of the best animators so no worries there. Just worry if they will adapt it right.