Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Drmke]

I dunno, it seems extremely plausible that Bleach could get another anime. It was/is a very popular franchise. Far more unlikely things have happened. Hedging bets against it is strange.

 

[SkerllyFC]

How come the moderators don´t erase people coming to force opinions on other like GIA? We can´t have toxic discussion like those he starts. There has to be moderation here. I understand he has his opinions about any manga here, but he´s forcing his opinon on us. If we don´t agree with him that Ungry Marie is good, or the rookies are going to be cancelled, we are stupid apparently. We´re stating our opinions. There should be more ethic here please.

 

[G_I_A]

How come the moderators don´t erase people coming to force opinions on other like GIA? We can´t have toxic discussion like those he starts. There has to be moderation here. I understand he has his opinions about any manga here, but he´s forcing his opinon on us. If we don´t agree with him that Ungry Marie is good, or the rookies are going to be cancelled, we are stupid apparently. We´re stating our opinions. There should be more ethic here please.

You don't need to agree dude and it does not matter. It will receive a color page before it's even ranked.

(I can't remember of this... What was the last time this happened?)

And it does not matter if I want or not the rookies to be canceled (they are being canceled anyway XD)

 

[jagman1x3]

How come the moderators don´t erase people coming to force opinions on other like GIA? We can´t have toxic discussion like those he starts. There has to be moderation here. I understand he has his opinions about any manga here, but he´s forcing his opinon on us. If we don´t agree with him that Ungry Marie is good, or the rookies are going to be cancelled, we are stupid apparently. We´re stating our opinions. There should be more ethic here please.

If it gets to actual insults then I do, otherwise just remember that (sadly) having shit taste isn't against the rules.
Also it's usually really late for me when the ToC comes out so I tend to just be asleep when there's a ton of discussion.

That said, consider this a PSA to everyone, not naming names but even I have my limits and at some point if I see enough crap I don't like when I wake up then I'm just going to skip deletion and go straight to reporting people to someone with significantly more power than I have.

 

[G_I_A]

If it gets to actual insults then I do, otherwise just remember that (sadly) having shit taste isn't against the rules.
Also it's usually really late for me when the ToC comes out so I tend to just be asleep when there's a ton of discussion.

To consider others to have a bad taste could also be a bad taste...

To me you guys are just upset because I was plain right xD

 

[TyVip]

You don't need to agree dude and it does not matter. It will receive a color page before it's even ranked.

(I can't remember of this... What was the last time this happened?)

Last year with Yuragi. It received a colour page in chapter 7.

edit Also, Kimetsu no Yaiba, colour page in chapter 7

 

[G_I_A]

I dunno, it seems extremely plausible that Bleach could get another anime. It was/is a very popular
franchise. Far more unlikely things have happened. Hedging bets against it is strange.

Indeed but the shitstorm will be immeasurable.

Last year with Yuragi. It received a colour page in chapter 7.

Thank you (I ALWAYS laugh mixing your info with koro avatar HAHA)

So not canceled it is. Come on guys. Venerate veterans already... It's simple.

 

[xAsum0x]

I'm quite disappointed in this batch of new series honestly, I dont think any of them stand out significantly aside from Dr. Stones art by Boichi, but even with its great art, the story is lacking so far imo with any good and interesting progression. I might be the only person here feeling like this but it's just how I'm feeling. I do think that the most successful series out of this bunch will be RxL.

 

[G_I_A]

I'm quite disappointed in this batch of new series honestly, I dont think any of them stand out significantly aside from Dr. Stones art by Boichi, but even with its great art, the story is lacking so far imo with any good and interesting progression. I might be the only person here feeling like this but it's just how I'm feeling. I do think that the most successful series out of this bunch will be RxL.

Actually I agree with you. Even Black Clover stands out more than all the 6 series. It's a shame to see JUMP trying so hard to innovate and failing.

But this is what we have so... Venerate veterans it is.

 

[jagman1x3]

To consider others to have a bad taste could also be a bad taste...

To me you guys are just upset because I was plain right xD

I'm aware everyone think their opinions are right, but come on, you're trying to argue you have outstanding taste in a thread about Jump here. The difference is I just don't say what I think about other people, you might want to try that.

 

[xAsum0x]

Actually I agree with you. Even Black Clover stands out more than all the 6 series. It's a shame to see JUMP trying so hard to innovate and failing.

But this is what we have so... Venerate veterans it is.

Black Clover had great art on top of at least some good world building and an interesting setting. So I could understand why people who find the manga interesting. Nothing like that jumps out among these new starts.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Well Poro is likely another flop I guess. Not really surprising, the series itself just felt kinda empty.
Also interesting Marie gets a colour page on its first ranking (pushing back its ranking by a week). Its actually happened quite a bit before and doesnt necessarily mean anything though.
Can we expect a Yaiba cover after HQ?

HZ with the color page, how's the final match so far? the last battle yet?

Colours dont really mean anything for HZ, it just gets them every few chapters regardless. The 2nd of the 5matches in the final just ended. Although the mangaka has set up a short final arc after that, whether it gets there or not is another story. Pacing is slow af right now though :/.

 

[G_I_A]

I'm aware everyone think their opinions are right, but come on, you're trying to argue you have outstanding taste in a thread about Jump here. The difference is I just don't say what I think about other people, you might want to try that.

But I never said what I actually think about other people, only their comments and preferences... That makes a forum, a forum... And I also never said my opinions are right... But (so far) I tend to be right toc-wise =)

Nvm... Yes, KnY should receive a cover.

 

[Mammo]

Seeing SP#1 above KnY triggers me way more than it should

Poro flopping is disheartening, I didn't really like it but I don't mind it either

 

[Scruffy8642]

I'm quite disappointed in this batch of new series honestly, I dont think any of them stand out significantly aside from Dr. Stones art by Boichi, but even with its great art, the story is lacking so far imo with any good and interesting progression. I might be the only person here feeling like this but it's just how I'm feeling. I do think that the most successful series out of this bunch will be RxL.

Actually I agree with you. Even Black Clover stands out more than all the 6 series. It's a shame to see JUMP trying so hard to innovate and failing.

Honestly I have to agree. BCs start, as much of a copy as it was, was more solid than anything here (besides maybe RxL). Dr Stone had an amazing premise with great potential and has so far fallen completely flat, and the events since the second chapter havent been interesting. At this point I have to say I actually prefer Marie over it, and even WNL... RxL is by far the most solid of this batch though. Its had a relatively slow start, but chapter 3 started hyping it up and im really looking forward to ch 4.

 

[Swavey]

Why would Jump torture themselves by placing SW1 so high?

How are they torturing themselves?
If it isn't getting votes then it wouldn't be here.

Also... I'm already predicting Dr. Stone in third. It won't be first because we will have Black Clover and One Piece.

I'm also hoping MHA to be out of top 5. It would be a dream.

Dr.Stone can be first, One Piece could get a color page, Black Clover's chapter wasn't good enough and don't forget Academia was absent that week.

 

[Nemesis]

Huh, Poro in the bottom was expect for me. Another good position for Neverland, with is great.

 

[Leoat12]

Since I started to read in Japanese I'm immersing myself more and more in the unknown and it has been good... With this round I'm starting to think that I'm too underground for Jump... There are a lot of good reasons to read things nobody knows and one of them is if nobody knows, nobody will be bickering about that. XD
It's like drink a refreshing juice in a dessert island.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

How are they torturing themselves?
If it isn't getting votes then it wouldn't be here.


Dr.Stone can be first, One Piece could get a color page, Black Clover's chapter wasn't good enough and don't forget Academia was absent that week.

It can't sell volumes, brah. I've seen stuff from comics Xenon sell higher. It doesn't belong in Jump. And Shueisha needs to not fall for the allure of apathy or the charm of complacency. It's time to make some money.

 

[Tanzo]

Decent ranks for series I like and a Neverland color page next week. Pretty good.
Hungry Marie getting a color page early probably means it's doing well in reception or Jump is promoting the veterans a bit.
There's a double issue coming up soon so Kimetsu might not get it's 1st anniversary color pages until after that.