Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Bigivelfhq]

You have no idea how rating works.

Then enlighten me, how they work?

 

[savethecat]

Any raws for the cycling one shot? Peaked my interest too

 

[vampire killer]

Then enlighten me, how they work?

Not in the way you think mate. I knoow you hate BHA but chill men. Get some wasabi.

 

[Bigivelfhq]

I wasn't comparing anything. Though it doesn't matter since the "remastered" series got better ratings than the new one.

Time Bokan, Space Brothers, and Ace Attorney did not average 6, infact they barely scrapped by 3-4%


Ultimate Otaku averaged 2-3% and only a few episodes got a 3% tally despite its 6.7% start (which was because of Magic Kaito). So Case Files S1 and Magic Kaito were the only shows that got a 6% in ratings while everything else was between a 3-4%. Funny thing about Space Brothers is that it had lower premiere ratings than MHA yet here you are saying it did very good. Make up your mind.

People who post weekly rating updates and know more about that shit than me or you. Kai not doing well isn't really something people can deny at this point. It got canned despite having an average rating of 9.4%, Toriko got canned despite having an average rating of 6.2% nowadays shows outside of Sazae-san and Shin-chan dream of getting those ratings and even they have fallen off themselves.

It shows that you dont know what you're talking about when is noticeable that you think Space Brothers always aired in that timeslot. It only starter in that timeslot by around episode 52. What is 1st episode did rating wise means nothing here, just Luke the 1st episode of MHA Aldo doesnt.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Apr 6, 2017 ---

Not in the way you think mate. I knoow you hate BHA but chill men. Get some wasabi.

LOL, I hate MHA? That is news, even for me.

 

[Kadir0]

Robo is too OP, the games won't be fun if the author plans to continue like this. Kuroko was a better main character imo, at least he let his side characters shine.

 

[ChocoBar9]

It shows that you dont know what you're talking about when is noticeable that you think Space Brothers always aired in that timeslot. It only starter in that timeslot by around episode 52. What is 1st episode did rating wise means nothing here, just Luke the 1st episode of MHA Aldo doesnt.

Even if you were right (you're not btw) it doesn't matter since the ratings didn't rise above 3-4% average

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Apr 6, 2017 ---

Oh, do you know one of the people that posted weekly rating updates? Me!

Honey there's lots of people who posts weekly ratings updates and you are neither the most well-known or even the most proficient one so don't flatter yourself and I'll seldom trust anyone's word who believes that Nichigo was a highly rated timeslot with the highest show average was a 4%.but we'll see what crap you spout during MHA run on NTV.

 

[James Rye]

Robo is too OP, the games won't be fun if the author plans to continue like this. Kuroko was a better main character imo, at least he let his side characters shine.

If he becomes the Saitama of Golf, it could be very fun to watch while the side characters might still shine. I have a feeling Roboto will lose this match with the next two holes lost by one or several balls each. Maybe actually losing might make him want to get better at Golf to not lose again?

 

[Bigivelfhq]

Even if you were right 2(you're not btw) it doesn't matter since the ratings didn't rise above 3-4% average

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Apr 6, 2017 ---

Honey there's lots of people who posts weekly ratings updates and you are neither the most well-known or even the most proficient one so don't flatter yourself and I'll seldom trust anyone's word who believes that Nichigo was a highly rated timeslot with the highest show average was a 4%.but we'll see what crap you spout during MHA run on NTV.

Sweetheart, what with the evasion tactics, can't you even keep a consistent train of thought?

 

[DyanSon]

Hori just do the same thing Tabata did in this chapter of MHA and the difference is pretty big. Maybe Tabata need to learn some writing lesson to Horikoshi.

 

[Koi Kage]

MHA's chapter this week, to me, felt slower paced then it needed to be. It was a good chapter just slow paced.

Dr. Stone this chapter show that the author is making this series with nothing but a bunch of big reveals and very little actual story telling. I'll give this series until it's ranked and depending on how well it's first ranking is will be if I drop it.

 

[Nakura]

Yeah, I think I'm done with Dr. Stone to be honest. It's not really compelling me to read anymore. I don't think it's bad, but I'm so disinterested in the situation.

 

[ChocoBar9]

Sweetheart, what with the evasion tactics, can't you even keep a consistent train of thought?

As much as you can't stop lying about everything because you're clueless about how things work and don't want to admit it. There's a difference between getting stuff off of 2ch and claiming you know what you're talking about and actually...well....knowing what you're talking about.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Apr 6, 2017 ---

Yeah, I think I'm done with Dr. Stone to be honest. It's not really compelling me to read anymore. I don't think it's bad, but I'm so disinterested in the situation.

I've kinda fallen off the Dr. Stone bandwagon myself. Maybe its just one of those series you have to wait and see how things develop where the setting finds some sort of ground before you invest in it much like YYH. At this point I'm just waiting to see how readers respond to it. RxL has been a pleasant surprise though, I'm still very much engaged with it.

 

[jagman1x3]

Okay, this "discussion" (and let's be honest, it's generous to even call it that) on ratings is either going to continue somewhere else or be deleted. It's not even remotely on topic anymore.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Dr Stone is losing steam fast. RxL is gaining it fast.

 

[Doughboy]

Didn't even know he's an anime fan lol I like his music, he got really popular in 2015-2016. OP getting dropped from Toonami still is surprising, but I have heard before Tokyo Ghoul is really popular in the west, guess it's true

 

[Kefka]

I've been here for a while, but never saw this thread. I like it, and will try to participate more.

To be honest, I didn't even get past the first chapter of Dr. Stone. I mean, the dude kept his consciousness for... how many years, again? I don't really remember. Anyway he kept it for all this time because of that girl we know literally nothing about? It felt kinda forced to me, as did Mr. Know-it-all. I feel like the author could've spent the first chapters flashing out the characters' relationship for me as the reader to sort of connect to them.

The premise of everyone turning into stone was interesting, but the way it, and the characters, were presented, not so much.

 

[SkerllyFC]

Did Shokugeki changed pace? It seems that it went back to cooking business

 

[Newkerzy]

MHA's chapter this week, to me, felt slower paced then it needed to be. It was a good chapter just slow paced.

Dr. Stone this chapter show that the author is making this series with nothing but a bunch of big reveals and very little actual story telling. I'll give this series until it's ranked and depending on how well it's first ranking is will be if I drop it.

Funny enough, a main complaint (if you could call it that) of MHA is that it's too fast sometimes. I don't mind going at a slower pace as long as Horikoshi plans it out well enough.

 

[Koi Kage]

Funny enough, a main complaint (if you could call it that) of MHA is that it's too fast sometimes. I don't mind going at a slower pace as long as Horikoshi plans it out well enough.

I didn't really find the pace it use to go as a bad thing here recently though I have a bit of a problem with, this series to me isn't suited for slow pacing.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Yup and it's been rising in the rankings as a result now that it seems like Azami and his bs shenanigans are over. We are in the first stage of the final battle it seems.

On the topic of Dr. Stone, it definitely was one of the bigger let downs of the 6 new series. Study-koi and Robot were pleasant surprises, and the one I had the most hope for turned out to be really disappointing. Inagaki should have tried writing a battle shounen series with science elements like I believe Hungry Joker was trying to be. I'll still continue to read it because I'm not losing much by doing so, but I won't miss it if it's axed. Hungry Marie is in the same boat as well.