Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[void data]

Wow, the bottom part is cluttered with comedy series. It feels like the votes became divided and damage their rank.

Gintama
Saiki Kusuo no Sainan
Boku-tachi wa Benkyou ga Dekinai
Samon-kun wa Summoner
Harapeko no Marie
Poro no Ryuugaku-ki
U19

 

[Mammo]

I totally forgot about Saiki's anniversary, nice surprise

Asou draws pretty boring cp but whatever, I'm still hyped

 

[justsomeguy]

If OP isn't absent, we got 16 series ranking next week. That hasn't happened since, what? 2013?

 

[Mammo]

What are some of the best examples of comedy manga in the magazine then?

Gintama is praised a lot but what else? I still have to finish watching bobobobo. I feel Seikimatsu Leader Den Takeshi will be a great comedy series but I'll wait till it's fully translated.

the pic in my avatar is judging you silently

> Yuragi and Kimetsu start one issue apart
> Kimetsu has a cover.
> Kimetsu has 1 more volume than Yuragi

Being a ghost is tough I suppose.

not including the first chapter covers

Kimetsu = 2 covers
Yunna = 0 covers

I honestly don't get why Dr. Stone is so well received. It has good art? Outside of that, I don't see the appeal. I think it's a mess, but whatever.

nice art and nice world aesthetics, interesting premise, fun, educational without being too boring

the characters are one dimensional but it could be overlooked for now as we are just in the first volume, they will have to flesh them out sometime (I hope)

 

[TyVip]

not including the first chapter covers

Kimetsu = 2 covers
Yunna = 0 covers

Not 1, but 2? Someone at Jump is getting fired today.

Oh well, at least Yuuna had back to back colour pages and first place on TOC once .

 

[Mammo]

and full color chapters and full color volumes

 

[Reigen]

I genuinely won't be surprised if he comes back to do one chapter to finish the volume off before disappearing for another year or two. Unless they plan on making the volume release shorter than it is? If I recall correctly, Volume 34 is one or two chapters short from being a finished volume.

There's 10 chapters and its enough for Volume 34

 

[Doughboy]

That Dr. Stone chapter was arguably the best one that got ranked, I didn't start getting bored till like chp 5 or 6 too.

WNL seems to be a middle of pack-er, which has been where Yuragi has settled in at, cool with me.

@giathuan2707 Tengu needs the cover for herself in the worst way... I like her

 

[Lumilleon]

Dr. Stone was got me out, i thought the ranking would sunk soon since the recent chapter way too chaotic.
i actually kinda feel bad if this manga get axe too quickly, Boichi was too happy to joined jump given his happy comment from wsj authors comment. so yeah, good grief for him.
And too bad for Hungry marie i enjoyed this manga more than i am enjoyed Benkyou and Yuuna but readers has different favors here.

 

[ChocoBar9]

1851770 1862800 One Piece 85
*496699 *497195 Haikyuu 25
*226262 *226262 Souma 24
*185959 *185959 Boruto 3
*107704 *107704 Black Clover 11
**65937 **65937 Kimetsu 6
**28551 *449478 Heroaca 13
**26311 **26311 Karada Sagashi
**25479 2582133 One Piece 84
**21682 **21682 Samon 9

 

[Nakura]

**28551 *449478 Heroaca 13

Volume 12(31 Days)- *20,435 *440,536

 

[Mammo]

come on kimetsu! let's go kimetsu!

it's weird how the last volume sold 65k before dropping out of oricon top 50

 

[DyanSon]

Volume 12(31 Days)- *20,435 *440,536

Does it say how much the backlog BnHA got this week? And I thought 5 old volumes of BnHA is on top 50 right now why only vol. 13 is shown in this list?

 

[Mammo]

these are last week sales 1 May to 7 May

 

[DyanSon]

these are last week sales 1 May to 7 May

Oh is that so. Thanks

 

[Heiji]

Confirmation for Hxh 34.
http://7net.omni7.jp/detail/1106773973

 

[Tamil]

80k+ for KnY here we come!

--- Double Post Merged, May 10, 2017, Original Post Date: May 10, 2017 ---

One Piece/DB IP sales

 

[vampire killer]

Fake. I dont see BHA there so it must be some guys just doing stuff on his own. And Gundam first is impisiburu. The last good gundam was in 2007, I dont count Unicorn.

 

[Mammo]

seeing the toys sales makes me wonder when will get the next YugiOh or will its phenomenon ever happen again

I seen some oneshots with some interesting concepts that could develop into some cool traditional gaming franchises

that's if Jump and the fans gave them a chance

 

[ruggia]

Fake. I dont see BHA there so it must be some guys just doing stuff on his own. And Gundam first is impisiburu. The last good gundam was in 2007, I dont count Unicorn.

it's from official earnings disclosure of Bandai Namco