Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[SharkBait]

isnt the first page of the volume the whole art without the title?

 

[cody]

Here's the CM for the Oh My Jump! Shounen Jump ga Chikyuu wo Sukuu" live-action TV drama.


Oh mai Jampu!

 

[Caiops]

Going by Shoseki ranking of November, RxL#2 sold at least 9k in November.

Go Go Fujimaki.

 

[OfficialHxH]

Do you guys know when we will see the next set of volume covers of manga coming out in Japan?

I want to know when we will see the cover for hxh vol. 35 lol

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Dec 23, 2017 ---

Fixed

 

[Franz]

Speaking of Toriko, I just noticed something interesting. Both Toriko and Katekyo Hitman Reborn! seem to have almost identical run times looking at when they started and finished and both had very similar runs in the magazine in general. Both never really managed to take off to the next level and stagnated sales wise and popularity wise after a while, they were both really successful, but maybe not enough for WSJ to keep them running for over 9 years. Toriko has 43 volumes and Reborn has 42, I just thought this was interesting.

In reality there is a change in the way of working at Jump, compared to the period at the turn of the year 2000. Once the former Big 3 and some other manga that exceed 40 volumes have become rare motorcycles. When you get closer to that figure, it is likely that they are pressuring to close, even though they may still like it enough. As for the manga with a good but not exceptional popularity, the figure is reduced to about twenty numbers. Clearly in all this there are the due exceptions. Just to give some examples:

Reborn - very successful manga - 42 volumes with a more than hasty final saga
Psyren - manga of moderate success - 16 volumes
Toriko - very successful manga - 43 volumes
Bakuman - successful manga - 20 volumes
Haikyuu !! - very successful manga - 29 volumes in progress
My Hero Academia - very successful manga - 16 volumes in progress

As you can see the successful manga born after 2000, they all stop at the twentieth number, little more or less, while the manga that have had a great success as Reborn or Toriko arrive at forty and little more. I would say that once One Piece, Detective Conan and Gintama are finished we will hardly see other manga reaching over fifty numbers.

 

[susanoo13]

Bakuman sold a bit more than reborn and toriko per volume IIRC, it wasn't under any pressure to end yet Ohba finished telling his story and ended it willingly. 40 Volumes for a manga was always rare even for the most successful manga.

 

[Franz]

No after One Piece..

 

[101nemesis]

In reality there is a change in the way of working at Jump, compared to the period at the turn of the year 2000. Once the former Big 3 and some other manga that exceed 40 volumes have become rare motorcycles. When you get closer to that figure, it is likely that they are pressuring to close, even though they may still like it enough. As for the manga with a good but not exceptional popularity, the figure is reduced to about twenty numbers. Clearly in all this there are the due exceptions. Just to give some examples:

Reborn - very successful manga - 42 volumes with a more than hasty final saga
Psyren - manga of moderate success - 16 volumes
Toriko - very successful manga - 43 volumes
Bakuman - successful manga - 20 volumes
Haikyuu !! - very successful manga - 29 volumes in progress
My Hero Academia - very successful manga - 16 volumes in progress

As you can see the successful manga born after 2000, they all stop at the twentieth number, little more or less, while the manga that have had a great success as Reborn or Toriko arrive at forty and little more. I would say that once One Piece, Detective Conan and Gintama are finished we will hardly see other manga reaching over fifty numbers.

I don't think there is any change. Just solely depends on how popular a manga gets and how many it's volumes sell aside from the obvious fact of how much the mangaka wanted to actually write. If MHA can keep up the ratings n stuff, it'll be able to go on for however long it wants. That's always been the case at WSJ. It's just that there haven't been many manga that could keep ratings and sales up for that long in the last 10 years or their stories would just not be that long. KnB would've kept selling and being ranked well if the premise gave it more options to grow. Assassination classroom's setting was always very short but it'd have definitely survived 10 years with the sales it had.

 

[Tanzo]

First anime visual released earlier at Jump Festa for Akuma no Memumemu-chan (Jump+) By Shaft
This is actually an acrylic holder, but still the first visual for the anime released

 

[Tamil]

In reality there is a change in the way of working at Jump, compared to the period at the turn of the year 2000. Once the former Big 3 and some other manga that exceed 40 volumes have become rare motorcycles. When you get closer to that figure, it is likely that they are pressuring to close, even though they may still like it enough. As for the manga with a good but not exceptional popularity, the figure is reduced to about twenty numbers. Clearly in all this there are the due exceptions. Just to give some examples:

Reborn - very successful manga - 42 volumes with a more than hasty final saga
Psyren - manga of moderate success - 16 volumes
Toriko - very successful manga - 43 volumes
Bakuman - successful manga - 20 volumes
Haikyuu !! - very successful manga - 29 volumes in progress
My Hero Academia - very successful manga - 16 volumes in progress

As you can see the successful manga born after 2000, they all stop at the twentieth number, little more or less, while the manga that have had a great success as Reborn or Toriko arrive at forty and little more. I would say that once One Piece, Detective Conan and Gintama are finished we will hardly see other manga reaching over fifty numbers.

That's an awful ranking. Toriko isn't as successful as Reborn/MHA/Bakuman and especially Haikyuu!!. Psyren is a flop. Bakuman is more successful than Toriko by a large margin, Toriko couldn't break the 500k mark but Bakuman at one point passed the 600k mark.

 

[SharkBait]

How do you make a distinction between successful and very successful?

 

[WyldViolet]

Speaking of that...

Lemme share this updated piece of shit only cause I've been doing it for years now.

Year Jump Success/Failures


Put this together awhile ago because I was bored and continue updating it every year. Thought I’d share.

I started this list at 1997 since that was the debut of One Piece and began the era of modern Jump.


These aren’t the perfect criteria to judge success by, but it’s the one I’m using.

Huge Success= Became a defining series for Jump.

Notable Success= 3 Or More Years

Quasi Success= Ran for 1-2 Years (with exceptions for short series who received anime)


For 2014+ these are tentative guesses on success.


1997

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (One Piece)

3 Notable Success (Hanasaka Tenshi Tenten-kun, I’’s, Leader Den Takeshi)

1 Quasi Success (Meiryotei Gotoseijuro)

1 Mini-series (Cowa!)

7 Failures (Watashi no Kaeru-sama, Butsu Zone, Wrestling With Momoko, Merry Wind, Joka Joker, Cool: Rental Body Guard, Kirin: The Last Unicorn)

6 Success END (Rokudenashi Blues, Tottemo Luckyman!, Captain Tsubasa: World Youth, Level E, Sexy Commando, Gaiden)


1998

11 New Series

3 Huge Success- (Hunter x Hunter, Rookies, Shaman King)

4 Notable Success (Whistle, Rising Impact)

1 Mini-series (Kajika)

5 Failures (Ei-Row, Shonen Tantei Q, Kappa Revolution, Base Boys, Boku wa Shonen Tantei Dan)

3 Success END (Midori no Makibao, Jinnai Ryūjujutsu Butōden Majima-kun Suttobasu!!, Wild Half)


1999

13 New Series

3 Huge Success- (Naruto, Hikaru no Go, Prince of Tennis)

10 Failures (Shinkaigyo, Yamato Gensoki, Shukyu-den, Daisuo Dice King, Bushizawa Receive, Mahhaheddo, Survibee, Childragon, ZombiePowder, Romancers)

4 Success End (Hareluya II, Jigoku Sensei Nube, Ruroni Kenshin, Meiryotei Gotoseijuro)


2000

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (Jaguar)

2 Notable Success (Stone Ocean, Black Cat)

1 Quasi Success (Bremen)

1 Mini-series (Sandland)

8 Failures (Tsurikkizu Pintaro, Sanjushi, Normandy Secret Club, Kaiser Spike, Rocket de Tsukinukero!, Junjo Pine, Lilim Kiss, Bakabakashino!)

3 Success End (Hoshin Engi, Hanasaka Tenshi Tenten-kun, I”s)



2001

11 New Series

1 Huge Success (Bleach)

2 Notable Success (Bobobo, Mr. Fullswing)

7 Failures (Gun Blaze West!, Jushin Ikaritorajiro, Karasuman, Magician, I’m A Faker, Grand Vacan, Mononoke! Nyantaro, Sowaka)


2002

10 New Series

1 Huge Success (Eyeshield 21)

1 Notable Success (Ichigo 100%)

1 Quasi Success (Pretty Face)

8 Failures (Sakuratetsu Taiwahen, Akkera Kanjincho, Shonen Espa Nejime, Number 10, Sword Breaker, AON, Ultra Red)

2 Success End (Leader Den Takeshi, Rising Impact)


2003

11 New Series

1 Quasi Success (Buso Renkin)

10 Failures (Granada, Tattoo Hearts, Yamikami Kou, Santa!, Kicks Megamix, Gocchan desu!, Kanagawa Isonan Futengumi, Sengoku Rappaden Sasori, Thoroughbred to Yobanai de, Kannade)

4 Success End (Rookies, Whistle!, Hikaru no Go, Pretty Face)


2004

12 New Series

4 Huge Success (Death Note, Gintama, Reborn! D. Gray Man)

1 Notable Success (Muhyo and Roji)

1 Exception (Steel Ball Run moved magazines)

6 Failures (Live, Gedo the Unidentified Mysterious Boy, Muteki Tetsuhime Spin-chan, Shonen Guardian, Chijo Saisoku Seishun Takkyu Puyan, WaqWaq)

3 Success End (Yugioh, Shaman King, Black Cat)


2005

9 New Series

1 Notable Success (Neuro)

3 Quasi Success (Takaya, Mieru Hito, Taizo Moteo Saga)

1 Exception (Beshari Kurashi moved magazines)

4 Failures (Yuto, Kain, Kirihoshi, Odoboro Poruta)

3 Success End (Bobobo, Ichigo 100%, Buso Renkin)


2006

11 New Series

1 Notable Success (To-Love Ru)

4 Quasi Success (Shinetsu BoBoBo, Maison Du Penguin,Mx0, P2 Pingpong)
6 Failures (Tsugihagi Hyoryusakka, Takaya, Nazo no Murasame-kun, Over Time, Zan, Hand’s)

2 Success End (Death Note, Mieru Hito)


2007

11 New Series

1 Notable Success (Sket Dance)

3 Quasi Success (Samurai Usagi, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hatsuoki Limited)

7 Failures (Blue Dragon, Corrector M&Y, Junbor Balutronica, Volleyball Tsukai Godago, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hitomi no Catoblepas, Belmonde Le VisiteuR)

3 Success End (Taizo Moteo Saga, Shinetsu BoBoBo, P2 Pingpong)


2008

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (Bakuman)

3 Notable Success (Nurahiyon no Mago, Toriko, Inumarudashi)

1 Quasi Success (Psyren)
8 Failures (K.O. Sen, Muddy, Shiritsu Poseidon Gakuen Kotobu, Bari Haken, Double Arts, Dogashi Kaden!, Chagecha, Asklepios)

6 Success End (Prince of Tennis, Muhyo to Roji, Mx0, Samurai Usagi, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hatsukoi Limited,


2009

14 New Series

1 Huge Success (Kuroko no Basuke)

2 Notable Success (Beelzebub, Medaka Box)

1 Quasi Success (Hokenshitsu no Shinigami)

10 Failures (Meister, Bokke-san, Hoopmen, Akaboshi, Anedoki, Kagijin, Wasshoi! Waji Mania, Super Dog Rilienthal, Neko Wappa!, Shinseiki Idol Densetsu Kanata Seven Change)

4 Success End (Eyeshield 21, D. Gray Man (moved to Jump SQ), Neuro, To Love Ru)


2010

8 New Series

1 Quasi Success (Enigma)

7 Failures (Lock On!, Kiben Gakuha, Metallica Metalluca, Shonen Shikku, SWOT, Oumagadoki Doubutsuen, Light Wing)

2 Success End (Jaguar, Psyren)



2011

10 New Series

1 Notable Success (Nisekoi)

2 Quasi Successes (Magico, Kurogane)

7 Failures (Dois Sol, Marchen Oji Grimm, Sengoku Armors, Kikai Banashi Hanasaka Ikkyu, ST&RS, Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa, Pakky!)

2 Success End (Hokenshitsu no Shinigami, Enigma)


2012

13 New Series

3 Huge Success (Haikyuu, AssClass, Shokugeki no Soma)

1 Notable Success (Saiki Kusuo no Sainan)

1 Miniseries (Koganeiro)

8 Failures (Pajama na Kanojo, Koisome Momiji, Sensei no Bulge, Takamagahara, Retsu! Date Senpai, Cross Manage, Hungry Joker, Shinmai Fukei Kiruko-san)

5 Success End (Nurahiyon no Mago, Bakuman, Inumarudashii, Magico, Reborn!)


2013

11 New Series

2 Notable Success (World Trigger, Isobe Isobe Monogatari)

2 Quasi Success (Soul Catcher(S) (Transferred to bimonthly magazine Jump NEXT after a little over a year of serialization)

1 Miniseries (Ginga Patrol Jaco)

6 Failures (Koisuru Edison, Mutou Black, Smoky BB, Kurokuroku, Hime-doll, Hachi, Koi no Cupid)

3 Success End (Sket Dance, Medaka Box, Kurogane)


2014 (so far)

16 new series

1 Huge Success (My Hero Academia)

1 Notable Success (Hinomarou Sumo)

2 Mini-Series (Sore Ike! Yuugou-Kun, Moromono no Jijou)

1 Exception (iShoujo moved magazines)

14 Failures (Iron Knight, Tokyo Wonder Boys, Stealth Symphony, Illegal Rare, Mitsukubi Condor, Yoakemono, Sporting Salt, Hi-Fi Cluster, Judos, Takujo no Ageha, E-robot)

4 Success End (Naruto, Kuroko no Basuke, Beelzebub, Soul Catchers)


2015 (so far)

13 new series

1 Notable Success (Black Clover)

2 Quasi Success (Straighten Up!, Samon-Kun Wa Summoner

9 Failures (Gakyuu Houtei, Cyborg Roggy, Ultra Battle Satellite, Kagamigami, Lady Justice, Devily Man, Best Blue, Buddy Strike, Mononofu)

1 Mini-series (Naruto Gaiden)



2016 (so far)

11 New series

1 (likely) Huge success (the promised neverland)

3 (likely) Notable success (Kimetsu no Yaiba, Boruto, Yuragi sou no Yuuna-san)

1 (likely) Quasi Success (Spring Weapon #1)

6 Failures (Takuan to Batsu, Love Rush, Red Sprite, Amalgam of Distortion, Demon’s Plan, Ore Golazo )

5 Success End (AssClass, Nisekoi, Bleach, Kochikame, Toriko)


2017 (so far)

11 new series

3 (likely Notable Success) (We Never Learn, Dr. Stone, Robot x Lazerbeam)

7 Failures (U19, Demon Prince Poro’s Diaries, Hungry Marie, Cross Account, Shoodan, Full Drive, Golem Hearts)

3 Success End (Straighten Up, Samon-kun wa Summoner, Isobe Isobe Monogatari)

 

[cody]

Speaking of that...

Lemme share this updated piece of shit only cause I've been doing it for years now.

Year Jump Success/Failures


Put this together awhile ago because I was bored and continue updating it every year. Thought I’d share.

I started this list at 1997 since that was the debut of One Piece and began the era of modern Jump.


These aren’t the perfect criteria to judge success by, but it’s the one I’m using.

Huge Success= Became a defining series for Jump.

Notable Success= 3 Or More Years

Quasi Success= Ran for 1-2 Years (with exceptions for short series who received anime)


For 2014+ these are tentative guesses on success.


1997

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (One Piece)

3 Notable Success (Hanasaka Tenshi Tenten-kun, I’’s, Leader Den Takeshi)

1 Quasi Success (Meiryotei Gotoseijuro)

1 Mini-series (Cowa!)

7 Failures (Watashi no Kaeru-sama, Butsu Zone, Wrestling With Momoko, Merry Wind, Joka Joker, Cool: Rental Body Guard, Kirin: The Last Unicorn)

6 Success END (Rokudenashi Blues, Tottemo Luckyman!, Captain Tsubasa: World Youth, Level E, Sexy Commando, Gaiden)


1998

11 New Series

3 Huge Success- (Hunter x Hunter, Rookies, Shaman King)

4 Notable Success (Whistle, Rising Impact)

1 Mini-series (Kajika)

5 Failures (Ei-Row, Shonen Tantei Q, Kappa Revolution, Base Boys, Boku wa Shonen Tantei Dan)

3 Success END (Midori no Makibao, Jinnai Ryūjujutsu Butōden Majima-kun Suttobasu!!, Wild Half)


1999

13 New Series

3 Huge Success- (Naruto, Hikaru no Go, Prince of Tennis)

10 Failures (Shinkaigyo, Yamato Gensoki, Shukyu-den, Daisuo Dice King, Bushizawa Receive, Mahhaheddo, Survibee, Childragon, ZombiePowder, Romancers)

4 Success End (Hareluya II, Jigoku Sensei Nube, Ruroni Kenshin, Meiryotei Gotoseijuro)


2000

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (Jaguar)

2 Notable Success (Stone Ocean, Black Cat)

1 Quasi Success (Bremen)

1 Mini-series (Sandland)

8 Failures (Tsurikkizu Pintaro, Sanjushi, Normandy Secret Club, Kaiser Spike, Rocket de Tsukinukero!, Junjo Pine, Lilim Kiss, Bakabakashino!)

3 Success End (Hoshin Engi, Hanasaka Tenshi Tenten-kun, I”s)



2001

11 New Series

1 Huge Success (Bleach)

2 Notable Success (Bobobo, Mr. Fullswing)

7 Failures (Gun Blaze West!, Jushin Ikaritorajiro, Karasuman, Magician, I’m A Faker, Grand Vacan, Mononoke! Nyantaro, Sowaka)


2002

10 New Series

1 Huge Success (Eyeshield 21)

1 Notable Success (Ichigo 100%)

1 Quasi Success (Pretty Face)

8 Failures (Sakuratetsu Taiwahen, Akkera Kanjincho, Shonen Espa Nejime, Number 10, Sword Breaker, AON, Ultra Red)

2 Success End (Leader Den Takeshi, Rising Impact)


2003

11 New Series

1 Quasi Success (Buso Renkin)

10 Failures (Granada, Tattoo Hearts, Yamikami Kou, Santa!, Kicks Megamix, Gocchan desu!, Kanagawa Isonan Futengumi, Sengoku Rappaden Sasori, Thoroughbred to Yobanai de, Kannade)

4 Success End (Rookies, Whistle!, Hikaru no Go, Pretty Face)


2004

12 New Series

4 Huge Success (Death Note, Gintama, Reborn! D. Gray Man)

1 Notable Success (Muhyo and Roji)

1 Exception (Steel Ball Run moved magazines)

6 Failures (Live, Gedo the Unidentified Mysterious Boy, Muteki Tetsuhime Spin-chan, Shonen Guardian, Chijo Saisoku Seishun Takkyu Puyan, WaqWaq)

3 Success End (Yugioh, Shaman King, Black Cat)


2005

9 New Series

1 Notable Success (Neuro)

3 Quasi Success (Takaya, Mieru Hito, Taizo Moteo Saga)

1 Exception (Beshari Kurashi moved magazines)

4 Failures (Yuto, Kain, Kirihoshi, Odoboro Poruta)

3 Success End (Bobobo, Ichigo 100%, Buso Renkin)


2006

11 New Series

1 Notable Success (To-Love Ru)

4 Quasi Success (Shinetsu BoBoBo, Maison Du Penguin,Mx0, P2 Pingpong)
6 Failures (Tsugihagi Hyoryusakka, Takaya, Nazo no Murasame-kun, Over Time, Zan, Hand’s)

2 Success End (Death Note, Mieru Hito)


2007

11 New Series

1 Notable Success (Sket Dance)

3 Quasi Success (Samurai Usagi, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hatsuoki Limited)

7 Failures (Blue Dragon, Corrector M&Y, Junbor Balutronica, Volleyball Tsukai Godago, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hitomi no Catoblepas, Belmonde Le VisiteuR)

3 Success End (Taizo Moteo Saga, Shinetsu BoBoBo, P2 Pingpong)


2008

13 New Series

1 Huge Success (Bakuman)

3 Notable Success (Nurahiyon no Mago, Toriko, Inumarudashi)

1 Quasi Success (Psyren)
8 Failures (K.O. Sen, Muddy, Shiritsu Poseidon Gakuen Kotobu, Bari Haken, Double Arts, Dogashi Kaden!, Chagecha, Asklepios)

6 Success End (Prince of Tennis, Muhyo to Roji, Mx0, Samurai Usagi, Boku no Watashi no Yusha Gaku, Hatsukoi Limited,


2009

14 New Series

1 Huge Success (Kuroko no Basuke)

2 Notable Success (Beelzebub, Medaka Box)

1 Quasi Success (Hokenshitsu no Shinigami)

10 Failures (Meister, Bokke-san, Hoopmen, Akaboshi, Anedoki, Kagijin, Wasshoi! Waji Mania, Super Dog Rilienthal, Neko Wappa!, Shinseiki Idol Densetsu Kanata Seven Change)

4 Success End (Eyeshield 21, D. Gray Man (moved to Jump SQ), Neuro, To Love Ru)


2010

8 New Series

1 Quasi Success (Enigma)

7 Failures (Lock On!, Kiben Gakuha, Metallica Metalluca, Shonen Shikku, SWOT, Oumagadoki Doubutsuen, Light Wing)

2 Success End (Jaguar, Psyren)



2011

10 New Series

1 Notable Success (Nisekoi)

2 Quasi Successes (Magico, Kurogane)

7 Failures (Dois Sol, Marchen Oji Grimm, Sengoku Armors, Kikai Banashi Hanasaka Ikkyu, ST&RS, Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa, Pakky!)

2 Success End (Hokenshitsu no Shinigami, Enigma)


2012

13 New Series

3 Huge Success (Haikyuu, AssClass, Shokugeki no Soma)

1 Notable Success (Saiki Kusuo no Sainan)

1 Miniseries (Koganeiro)

8 Failures (Pajama na Kanojo, Koisome Momiji, Sensei no Bulge, Takamagahara, Retsu! Date Senpai, Cross Manage, Hungry Joker, Shinmai Fukei Kiruko-san)

5 Success End (Nurahiyon no Mago, Bakuman, Inumarudashii, Magico, Reborn!)


2013

11 New Series

2 Notable Success (World Trigger, Isobe Isobe Monogatari)

2 Quasi Success (Soul Catcher(S) (Transferred to bimonthly magazine Jump NEXT after a little over a year of serialization)

1 Miniseries (Ginga Patrol Jaco)

6 Failures (Koisuru Edison, Mutou Black, Smoky BB, Kurokuroku, Hime-doll, Hachi, Koi no Cupid)

3 Success End (Sket Dance, Medaka Box, Kurogane)


2014 (so far)

16 new series

1 Huge Success (My Hero Academia)

1 Notable Success (Hinomarou Sumo)

2 Mini-Series (Sore Ike! Yuugou-Kun, Moromono no Jijou)

1 Exception (iShoujo moved magazines)

14 Failures (Iron Knight, Tokyo Wonder Boys, Stealth Symphony, Illegal Rare, Mitsukubi Condor, Yoakemono, Sporting Salt, Hi-Fi Cluster, Judos, Takujo no Ageha, E-robot)

4 Success End (Naruto, Kuroko no Basuke, Beelzebub, Soul Catchers)


2015 (so far)

13 new series

1 Notable Success (Black Clover)

2 Quasi Success (Straighten Up!, Samon-Kun Wa Summoner

9 Failures (Gakyuu Houtei, Cyborg Roggy, Ultra Battle Satellite, Kagamigami, Lady Justice, Devily Man, Best Blue, Buddy Strike, Mononofu)

1 Mini-series (Naruto Gaiden)



2016 (so far)

11 New series

1 (likely) Huge success (the promised neverland)

3 (likely) Notable success (Kimetsu no Yaiba, Boruto, Yuragi sou no Yuuna-san)

1 (likely) Quasi Success (Spring Weapon #1)

6 Failures (Takuan to Batsu, Love Rush, Red Sprite, Amalgam of Distortion, Demon’s Plan, Ore Golazo )

5 Success End (AssClass, Nisekoi, Bleach, Kochikame, Toriko)


2017 (so far)

11 new series

3 (likely Notable Success) (We Never Learn, Dr. Stone, Robot x Lazerbeam)

7 Failures (U19, Demon Prince Poro’s Diaries, Hungry Marie, Cross Account, Shoodan, Full Drive, Golem Hearts)

3 Success End (Straighten Up, Samon-kun wa Summoner, Isobe Isobe Monogatari)

This was great! This just shows how harsh things were for newcomers for the longest time because too many older manga were running in the magazine(just look at the 2010's) and I feel like 2012 was the begging of a new era in a way with those 4 crucial manga that started in that year (Nisekoi also popped up at the end of 2011). Then 2014 came around with BNHA and WSJ really put their hopes into it if it got an anime decided for it so early on and HZ was also solidifying a newer generation of the Jump magazine(and well WT was supposed to be part of the new generation as well, but RIP). Then in 2016 there were 5 big-huge series that finished and it really made it less impossible for some new mangaka and manga to flourish.

 

[Franz]

That's an awful ranking. Toriko isn't as successful as Reborn/MHA/Bakuman and especially Haikyuu!!. Psyren is a flop. Bakuman is more successful than Toriko by a large margin, Toriko couldn't break the 500k mark but Bakuman at one point passed the 600k mark.

For a period of time it was the third Big of Jump and it is still a manga that has reached and exceeded 40 volumes lasting 8 years .....

How do you make a distinction between successful and very successful?

By the sales

Speaking of that...

3 (likely) Notable success (Kimetsu no Yaiba, Boruto, Yuragi sou no Yuuna-san)

I would not consider Boruto a notable success ...

 

[Doughboy]

Nice list, really interesting to see what series succeeded and failed. I just have this really good vibe that the next big series will be Gole-

7 Failures (U19, Demon Prince Poro’s Diaries, Hungry Marie, Cross Account, Shoodan, Full Drive, Golem Hearts)

still shook

 

[OfficialHxH]

I put Golem Hearts on hold not that its bad but that it just doesnt grab my attention. I still go through Full Drive because its easy to read and go through fast but its starting to grow dull. Lycopene its a gag manga so i don't even know if that will get canceled before the others. I don't read it anymore though, do yall?

But seriously though these past batch of jump start series suck lol. Im looking forward to Actage in 2018

 

[Newkerzy]

Dunno if this was posted before, but MHA just barely made it into the Top 10 media franchises of this year.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-12-23/top-selling-media-franchises-in-japan-2017/.125682

On another note, Todoroki got 9th place in "Most appealing character poll"

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/in...-includes-old-favorites-new-surprises/.125644

 

[cody]

Dunno if this was posted before, but MHA just barely made it into the Top 10 media franchises of this year.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-12-23/top-selling-media-franchises-in-japan-2017/.125682

On another note, Todoroki got 9th place in "Most appealing character poll"

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/in...-includes-old-favorites-new-surprises/.125644

I'm pretty sure the media franchises thing was posted here.

 

[101nemesis]

For a period of time it was the third Big of Jump and it is still a manga that has reached and exceeded 40 volumes lasting 8 years .....

We should clarify that it got pushed really hard by WSJ. But did it really live up to being on front cover for those 2 years? That is definitely up in the air. I'm inclined to say it didn't. But obviously, you or someone else might think otherwise.

By the sales

So going by sales per volume, Bakuman was a bigger and more stable success (15 million sales with 20 volumes; with volumes average during its ending at 550 - 600k) as opposed to Toriko's (Available data is 20 million with 30 volumes; with volumes towards the end averaging around 200-270k). Bakuman was very stable, had a better average and had better peak sales than Toriko.

I would not consider Boruto a notable success ...

It's volume sell around 300-400k. That's definitely a notable success.

 

[De La Croissant]

Dunno if this was posted before, but MHA just barely made it into the Top 10 media franchises of this year.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-12-23/top-selling-media-franchises-in-japan-2017/.125682

Someone posted the top 10 franchises a few weeks ago and it was a bit different. Your name was first, I think.