Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[ShenGao]

this is one of the most offensive comments someone has ever written on this site. Please delete your account. There is no way neo;lation is a for sure cancellation. Just reread it and look at it. Its like, what Jump has been in need of all year.

It was cancelled the moment they came up with the name NeZero;lation.

 

[tirakai]

''37.　*,*23,744　*,*23,744　Hinomaruzumou Vol.23 ''

low sales since its first publish in shonen jump ( still ongoing + get an anime )
can someone please explain to me why ?

If you're asking why it's a low seller, it's probably because Reina's first reaction in the series to her brother doing sumo is how most people think of the sport (that it's weird and gross). How great the series is doesn't matter if people finding the premise itself gross.

If you're asking why it's still going, it had a lot of good ToC rankings for a while and WSJ will keep around low sellers if they think they're interesting and add good variety to the magazine.

 

[CrimsonEpitaph]

''37.　*,*23,744　*,*23,744　Hinomaruzumou Vol.23 ''

low sales since its first publish in shonen jump ( still ongoing + get an anime )
can someone please explain to me why ?

Some people think that the Japanese government/Sumo organizations support it.

 

[savethecat]

I actually think Ne0 and Chainsaw are around the same quality.
I think either one of them get axed, or both.
Who knows. Maybe both will stay

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

this is one of the most offensive comments someone has ever written on this site. Please delete your account. There is no way neo;lation is a for sure cancellation. Just reread it and look at it. Its like, what Jump has been in need of all year.

No, you delete your account please

 

[xAsum0x]

Gokutei Higuma does seem to be getting good reception though, the mini series must've been pretty popular

 

[MangAniMY]

 

[SharkBait]

No, you delete your account please

I'll delete my account when BLack Clover is proven as the next Naruto.

 

[TxxT]

I'll delete my account when BLack Clover is proven as the next Naruto.

So never

 

[Trigunblitz]

I'll delete my account when BLack Clover is proven as the next Naruto.

This is very interesting because an inherit assumption in the statement is that you do not want to delete your account—or you obviously wouldn’t be such an active member. Also inherent is that you don’t actually believe BC is on Naruto’s level.

How deep is your trolling? Do you even like BC or is it just the best tool to provoke ppl?

 

[SharkBait]

This is very interesting because an inherit assumption in the statement is that you do not want to delete your account—or you obviously wouldn’t be such an active member. Also inherent is that you don’t actually believe BC is on Naruto’s level.

How deep is your trolling? Do you even like BC or is it just the best tool to provoke ppl?

BLack Clover is in my current top three of current jump, up there with Haikyuu!! and ne0;lation and Food Wars and Boruto (if that counts). I have full faith that BLack Clover could someday reach Naruto level, hence why I would even bet my entire account on it. However, as I mentioned a few posts ago, based on the current approximated print manga sales, and its absence in the top 10 or so, it was clear that this year it couldn't reach that level. I believe it did in digital sales, but because people here continue to believe digital sales are meaningless and very inconsequential, you can clearly see the issue with definitively proving to them that BLack Clover is at or above Naruto level.

 

[xAsum0x]

Jujutsu Kaisen gets a character book

 

[MangAniMY]

BLack Clover is in my current top three of current jump, up there with Haikyuu!! and ne0;lation and Food Wars and Boruto (if that counts). I have full faith that BLack Clover could someday reach Naruto level, hence why I would even bet my entire account on it. However, as I mentioned a few posts ago, based on the current approximated print manga sales, and its absence in the top 10 or so, it was clear that this year it couldn't reach that level. I believe it did in digital sales, but because people here continue to believe digital sales are meaningless and very inconsequential, you can clearly see the issue with definitively proving to them that BLack Clover is at or above Naruto level.

just a question,

where do you honestly rank the shonen jump manga in term of just digital sales, specifically for 2018

 

[DyanSon]

BLack Clover is in my current top three of current jump, up there with Haikyuu!! and ne0;lation and Food Wars and Boruto (if that counts). I have full faith that BLack Clover could someday reach Naruto level, hence why I would even bet my entire account on it. However, as I mentioned a few posts ago, based on the current approximated print manga sales, and its absence in the top 10 or so, it was clear that this year it couldn't reach that level. I believe it did in digital sales, but because people here continue to believe digital sales are meaningless and very inconsequential, you can clearly see the issue with definitively proving to them that BLack Clover is at or above Naruto level.

>dude DIGITAL SALES LMOA

 

[CuriousReborn]

BLack Clover is in my current top three of current jump, up there with Haikyuu!! and ne0;lation and Food Wars and Boruto (if that counts). I have full faith that BLack Clover could someday reach Naruto level, hence why I would even bet my entire account on it. However, as I mentioned a few posts ago, based on the current approximated print manga sales, and its absence in the top 10 or so, it was clear that this year it couldn't reach that level. I believe it did in digital sales, but because people here continue to believe digital sales are meaningless and very inconsequential, you can clearly see the issue with definitively proving to them that BLack Clover is at or above Naruto level.

I agree, ne0;lation is the new storm that will take jump up to the new level.

 

[SharkBait]

Jujutsu Kaisen gets a character book

Wow that feels so fast.

 

[FengarGB]

Gokutei Higuma does seem to be getting good reception though, the mini series must've been pretty popular

The oneshot/mini series reminded me of shaman king in the way the spirits are handled for power. The art was good in the big moments, but some of the faces disappointed me in quality. Expecting the mangaka fixes that on the new series.It looks more lore and spirit heavy than jujutsu too.

 

[101nemesis]

just a question,

where do you honestly rank the shonen jump manga in term of just digital sales, specifically for 2018

You do realize this question will get answers that are purely hypothetical since no one has any sort of data. It's along the same lines as trying to guess which series will survive a serialization and be a million seller.

This is very interesting because an inherit assumption in the statement is that you do not want to delete your account—or you obviously wouldn’t be such an active member. Also inherent is that you don’t actually believe BC is on Naruto’s level.

How deep is your trolling? Do you even like BC or is it just the best tool to provoke ppl?

I'm quite certain that he's very aware that digital sales isn't even remotely as high as he claims it to be. He's pretty smart and usually follows a lot of data himself.
He does it because he knows he'll get to troll people such as me who get triggered when people mention "digital sales" without any actual data. I take the bait for digital sales trolling solely because I like talking about sales.

But yeah, he does genuinely love BC, which is fine.

 

[Caiops]

I believe Kimetsu no Yaiba sell more than One Piece if you count the digital sales.

So in the end, Kimetsu no Yaiba is the most popular manga in the magazine.

 

[MangAniMY]

You do realize this question will get answers that are purely hypothetical since no one has any sort of data. It's along the same lines as trying to guess which series will survive a serialization and be a million seller.


I'm quite certain that he's very aware that digital sales isn't even remotely as high as he claims it to be. He's pretty smart and usually follows a lot of data himself.
He does it because he knows he'll get to troll people such as me who get triggered when people mention "digital sales" without any actual data. I take the bait for digital sales trolling solely because I like talking about sales.

But yeah, he does genuinely love BC, which is fine.

I mean we don't have actual numbers, but we do have rankings from multiple e-stores (compiling some of the major ones at the moment)