Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[MangAniMY]

Without knowing anything from both, and from visuals alone,


Alice to Taiyou sound like a singing version of Tenshi to Akuto

 

[cody]

Are you serious? This is the name of the manga? lol It's bigger than any LN title that I saw haha

Just use the abbreviation. SJJDTSSHTS

EASY PEASY

 

[ShenGao]

They should axe the manga after chapter 1 for having an unnecessarily long name like "Sougou Jikan Jigyougaisha Daiyou Torishimariyaku Shachou Senzoku Hisho Tanaka". 85% of the volume cover will be used for the name alone.

 

[cody]

They should axe the manga after chapter 1 for having an unnecessarily long name like "Sougou Jikan Jigyougaisha Daiyou Torishimariyaku Shachou Senzoku Hisho Tanaka". 85% of the volume cover will be used for the name alone.

Axed after 1 chapter? But wouldn't that make it like a one-shot in a way?

 

[Reigen]

They should axe the manga after chapter 1 for having an unnecessarily long name like "Sougou Jikan Jigyougaisha Daiyou Torishimariyaku Shachou Senzoku Hisho Tanaka". 85% of the volume cover will be used for the name alone.

Only if it's done by the same person who designed Dr. Stone's covers lol

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Still no cover. The bullying to Black Clover is real.

 

[Mammo]

it's that time where we throw are heads back and judge other's taste

Keiji Amatsuka fav manga: Bleach, Ping Pong, Dogs

Takahide Touno fav manga: Kekkai Sensen, G Senjou Heavens Door, Yondemasu yo Azazel-san

 

[shoyoboyo]

Wow, this is one of the few times where the favorites are not one of Jumps top selling manga from the previous generation or two.

 

[101nemesis]

it's that time where we throw are heads back and judge other's taste

Keiji Amatsuka fav manga: Bleach, Ping Pong, Dogs

Now I know why I thought of Aizen when I saw the character.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Really disappointed in what Jump continues to serialize. This is not a shoujo mag, we don't need anymore fluffy or soft stories like a singing manga. And now we are getting light novel inspired junk? Disgraceful. We need to start a dialogue of the current trends in Shounen magazines....

 

[Reigen]

Really disappointed in what Jump continues to serialize. This is not a shoujo mag, we don't need anymore fluffy or soft stories like a singing manga. And now we are getting light novel inspired junk? Disgraceful. We need to start a dialogue of the current trends in Shounen magazines....

 

[WyldViolet]

Really disappointed in what Jump continues to serialize. This is not a shoujo mag, we don't need anymore fluffy or soft stories like a singing manga. And now we are getting light novel inspired junk? Disgraceful. We need to start a dialogue of the current trends in Shounen magazines....

/s?

 

[revo68]

 

[OfficialHxH]

 

[Franz]

Will there be the results of the Popularity Poll?

 

[MangAniMY]

as a PV(promotional video) guy, the way you use PV(preview) irks me...

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 14, 2018, Original Post Date: Jun 14, 2018 ---

Really disappointed in what Jump continues to serialize. This is not a shoujo mag, we don't need anymore fluffy or soft stories like a singing manga. And now we are getting light novel inspired junk? Disgraceful. We need to start a dialogue of the current trends in Shounen magazines....

I don't get it...

 

[Doughboy]

Really disappointed in what Jump continues to serialize. This is not a shoujo mag, we don't need anymore fluffy or soft stories like a singing manga. And now we are getting light novel inspired junk? Disgraceful. We need to start a dialogue of the current trends in Shounen magazines....

Don't let the unpopular opinion or potential backlash sway you from what's real, I got your back. Jump is searching for something they won't find.

Spoiler: Mood....

 

[WyldViolet]

People who only read within their comfort zone is one thing. It's weird to limit yourself, but I get it.
People expecting everything to be within their comfort zone is bizarre.
If Jump was nothing but Black Clover clones it would be a pretty stale fucking magazine.

 

[Heiji]

Will there be the results of the Popularity Poll?

1位　アスタ　3064
2位　ヤミ　1967
3位　ユノ　1421
4位　ラック　1214
5位　ユリウス　1032
6位　フエゴレオン　836
7位　メレオレオナ　781
8位　ゴーシュ　725
9位　ノエル　709
10位　ノゼル　641

 

[Doughboy]

I don't get it...

Jump has sold its soul on appealing to every group, genre, and age range. With most of the readers in our generation (we're all mostly 20s-30s), we develop different tastes as we grow older. It gives us a different perspective in a fictional setting that can resonate with us if done right. From a real life perspective that's great to hear, it opens the possibilities for authors of all kinds. But this ain't how it was supposed to turn out. Variety was never the issue in recent years, the entertainment aspect was. It's gone.

People who only read within their comfort zone is one thing. It's weird to limit yourself, but I get it.
People expecting everything to be within their comfort zone is bizarre.
If Jump was nothing but Black Clover clones it would be a pretty stale fucking magazine.

But you're no different than me. None of these new seralizations move you to read it. I read Act Age 6 and I felt moved, that ain't battle shonen. It's anorexic girls trying to be the next Meghan Good.