Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Konja9]

And this, people, is in all likelihood the real reason Stone hasn't been doing as well as it should've. Nurayama.

We don't know how popular is Dr. Stone between female audience. Right?

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

We don't know how popular is Dr. Stone between female audience. Right?

Seeing the last top 3 in the popularity poll i think that is popular with female audience.

 

[Thores]

I took a screenshot of the last poll, with all the voters in each category.

Which poll would you guys like next?

Which of the remaining 2019 debuts will be the first to conclude, after The Last Saiyuki?
- Chainsaw Man
- Yui Kamio Lets Loose
- Samurai 8
- Double Taisei
- Beast Children
- Tokyo Shinobi Squad

Alternately, "which 2019 debuts will survive past the end of the year" if you want to do a poll that supports multiple votes per person.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

We don't know how popular is Dr. Stone between female audience. Right?

The true answer to that question is to check how many yaoi doujins about Senku and all of the male cast exist
jk

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 8, 2019, Original Post Date: Aug 8, 2019 ---

Which of the remaining 2019 debuts will be the first to conclude, after The Last Saiyuki?
- Chainsaw Man
- Yui Kamio Lets Loose
- Samurai 8
- Double Taisei
- Beast Children
- Tokyo Shinobi Squad

Alternately, "which 2019 debuts will survive past the end of the year" if you want to do a poll that supports multiple votes per person.

I call Yui Kamio

 

[Koni]

Which of the remaining 2019 debuts will be the first to conclude, after The Last Saiyuki?
- Chainsaw Man
- Yui Kamio Lets Loose
- Samurai 8
- Double Taisei
- Beast Children
- Tokyo Shinobi Squad

Alternately, "which 2019 debuts will survive past the end of the year" if you want to do a poll that supports multiple votes per person.

I think this is a good poll, though we should remove Chainsaw Man as an option, considering how well it’s been selling.

Personally, I’d say either Yui Kamio or Beast Children.

 

[savethecat]

Been catching up on Dr.Stone, and this current arc is fantastic

 

[lgrmjauffre]

Unfortunately, I feel like all the new series besides Chainsaw Man and Samurai 8 will be cut. The last couple of years we have only gotten a couple of successes a year, but we had 3 come out of 2016, so I'm sincerely hoping we have something else take off. I just don't think it will be any of the current ones.

Edit: we actually had 4 in 2016. Boruto had temporarily slipped my mind since it left WSJ.

 

[Aeneas]

Beast Children getting cancelled during the Rugby World Cup would be so cruel. You think they'd let it survive past then, but we'll see with those rankings.

 

[Rain Spectre]

I mean, does anyone genuinely see Beast Children surviving? Because it might be the overall most poorly received series that's been serialized this year.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

If Shonen Jump never had any mercy with soccer manga during World Cup, i don't see why they would care about Rugby World Cup

 

[Paze]

Any guesses on the genre of the new series?

 

[Aeneas]

If Shonen Jump never had any mercy with soccer manga during World Cup, i don't see why they would care about Rugby World Cup

How many have there been?

 

[Rain Spectre]

How many have there been?

Short answer? A lot. Soccer has been infamous for being a sport which Jump has attempted to launch at least once every few years for decades now, with the result working only once literally 20 years ago.

 

[Aiwass_97]

How many have there been?

Tokyo Wonder Boys was axed month before the 2014 World Cup

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

How many have there been?

The record is between the 2009 and 2011: Meister, Shonen Shikku, Light Wind and Dois Sol. They tried a lot during this time.

And you have Tokyo Wonder Boys that was one of their biggest disasters.

 

[savethecat]

There’s a timeline where Ole Golazo was never axed and the people of that Earth is currently watching the second season of the Studio Bones produced Ole Golazo anime.

It’s MAL score is sitting at a 9.20

And The Russo Brothers are in talks to direct the live action Ole Golazo anime, right off the heels of their successful Avengers Endgame movie.

In this universe your girlfriend didn’t leave you for your coworker, Chad, and every Friday night you bond by cuddling together and watching the new thrilling episode of Ole Golazo.

 

[Aeneas]

The record is between the 2009 and 2011: Meister, Shonen Shikku, Light Wind and Dois Sol. They tried a lot during this time.

And you have Tokyo Wonder Boys that was one of their biggest disasters.

Yeah, I meant specifically ones that ran close to the WC and then ended before or, more so, during it.

It looks like it would be unprecedented to end during the sport's big event (assuming it's not axed before it starts).

And damn, that Tokyo series. They only gave it 10 chapters.

 

[Neala897]

There’s a timeline where Ole Golazo was never axed and the people of that Earth is currently watching the second season of the Studio Bones produced Ole Golazo anime.

It’s MAL score is sitting at a 9.20

And The Russo Brothers are in talks to direct the live action Ole Golazo anime, right off the heels of their successful Avengers Endgame movie.

In this universe your girlfriend didn’t leave you for your coworker, Chad, and every Friday night you bond by cuddling together and watching the new thrilling episode of Ole Golazo.

You forgot the part where Japan players were so inspired by new episode that they didnt screw up that match with Belgium. The dark side is however is that manga known as Blue Lock never existed.

 

[vinceled]

After finishing volume 3 of Chainsawman, I have to say volume 4 cannot come out fast enough. Chapters 22-25 were just one huge cliffhanger.

 

[KennyKuro]

Round 2