Big F for Shibata. I was really excited to see his return to the magazine but this portrays really well how most people (me included) are feeling about the manga now...
Chiyoko reigns supreme and is the superior actress.
It's both lazy to add nothing (lmao bleach xd), and add too much. Also you touched another grudge I have post timeskip: "new" world is just old world with higher bounties number and not new in any other sense at all.
He probably means to say Oda rarely experiments with panel shapes or layouts, sticking just to his usual sequences with plain squares and rectangles rather than doing creative panel layouts or sequences much.
Really do feel pretty bad for Shibata. It takes five years for him to get another go-around, only to from the looks of it bomb even harder. Dunno if I'd call him a "bad" mangaka, but it's clear he doesn't have what it takes to solidify himself.
Yup. OP's panels feel so expository, there's so rarely an emotional impact to them.
I think Zipman has more just fallen off the side of the cliff.
Kinda feel bad for Zipman because in this two last polls that the series had 0 votes i had to exclude the only vote it got because the user still not have enough comments (20something comments, user-san just comment more so your vote will count!)
The two polls were combined.
Like Ryuusei said, is the combination of the two polls with the second having more weight in the total: https://mangahelpers.com/forum/thre...p-issue-13-rank-your-3-best-chapters.3015808/
Anyone know what numbers Hungry Joker did? Curious if I can test something.
Personally, I think it's pointless to dwell on what-ifs, especially this kind where we're asking if a work of fiction would've preformed better in a different environment. There's simply too many factors to consider to where a meaningful point can be made.
Soul Catcher(S) would totally survive if it was published now, sales were at the same level of Chainsaw Man:
Hn, interesting. Anyone know where the author is?
the problem is you have to account for time, who knows how this translates to now in sales, numbers were way bigger then, and different audiences
These two probably don't meet the criteria exactly, but:
Yes but the thing is, the series at the time already had some impressive sales and dedicate fanbase despite the not much good toc rankings, it was quite popular between fujoshis, and the popularity poll received over 35k votes despite already being at JumpNEXT at the time:
He started a detective series on Saikyo Jump in 2018 but i think already ended
Yup. all quantitative comparison with the past are relative after all.
I don't know if I would go as far as to say Gotouge is the best panelist in jump rn, but Gotouge definitely has great paneling that goes underappreciated because of her artstyle.
So does that mean that people who voted in both polls got their votes counted double?MANGAHELPERS POLL ISSUE #13 (2020) - VOTING RESULTS
1. Act-Age 102 - 64 Votes
2. One Piece 972 - 63 Votes
3. Mitama Secureity 25 and 26 - 53 Votes
4. Mashle 5 - 43 Votes
5. Dr. Stone 140 - 42 Votes
6. Chainsaw Man 59 - 36 Votes
7. Mission: Yozakura Family 25 - 34 Votes
8. Kimetsu no Yaiba 195 - 28 Votes
9. Haikyuu!! 384 - 27 Votes
10. We Never Learn 148 - 23 Votes
11. Jujutsu Kaisen 96 - 23 Votes
12. Undead Unluck 6 - 22 Votes
13. Black Clover 240 - 17 Votes
14. Samurai 8: The Tale of Hachimaru 39 - 14 Votes
15. The Promised Neverland 168 - 13 Votes
16. Guardian of the Witch 4 - 9 Votes
17. Agravity Boys 10 - 8 Votes
18. Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san 196 - 3 Votes
19. ZIPMAN!! 11 - 0 Votes
Notes:
-62 Voters (13 excluded)
-Tied mangas decided by which is older
-Total number of votes is the combined between both polls