Discussion Who is your Favorite Strawhat ?

[Bellamy]

Who is your favorite Strawhat and why ?

(yeah, there is some funky choices, but hey...)

 

[Ricko]

Zorro because he's a BADASS, and he's kind of goofy too, what I like it's that he give the serious side of the crew, and his rivalty with Sanjy
Zorro's fight are always epic.

 

[hokageji]

Sogeking, Ussop land, SUUUUPAHERO!!!

who else!!

 

[jamarTheDem]

Zoro of course

 

[jaymizzo]

Luffy and Robin are tied for me.

 

[M3J]

Zoro because he's beyond badass. He could probably tip a cow while looking cool. I enjoy his and Sanji's fights the most. Sanji is either a close second or tied with Zoro.

 

[Deleted member 182576]

Nefertari Vivi & Carue all the way. love them so much, especially vivi, she's such a great character and i don't care if she's "weak".
after Vivi, it's definetly Robin. Her whole backstory and the way she was introduced and the way she IS is just unique and awesome.
i like that she's kind of "emotionless" and doesn't fear anything and the way she asked luffy to join... and her DF is sooo awesome... sadly Oda doesn't give her any shining moment since Enies Lobby arc.

 

[I Am Atomic]

Luffy, of course! His fight is the longest and best

 

[Bellamy]

No surprise it will be Luffy or Zoro.
For me, it's obivously Franky.

He's the coolest looking character in my opinion. Even if recently Oda doesn't makes him as cool looking as before, I'm still fond of the cyborg.

He's been showcased so many times around Sanji/Zoro level, and he showed mad skills. I will always remember Franky VS Fukurou or Franky using pillars to make a giant nunchuck. I miss the Old Franky, the haircut, and the fighting style. That was really amazing. There's also a lot of Zoro and Franky Bros scenes showcased here and there, which I like.

Now, it's mostly lasers and guns. It's kind of a shame, really, but luckily Oda will surprise us. More Strong Right and Franky Boxing, I say ! The Shogun is huge, and crazy inventive, but... I don't know, sometimes I was wondering if I was still looking to a Pirate Anime. Haha.

Nevertheless, he's still one of the most funny and entertaining Strawhats to me without have to do any efforts. Only Usopp can make me laugh harder than his stupid ideas or funky dances. ****** ?

I think Franky is one of the most well build Strawhats. I love how he cries but never cries. His badass speech at Dressrosa. Sometimes, he's an ass, but an ass with a big soft heart. I'm looking forward to see how much he's strong now and how much he can do in the future.

Second would be sometimes Usopp, sometimes Zoro.

 

[BigBadDogg]

Luffy, Zoro and Nami are my favorite

 

[Impossibility]

Robin and Nami are my faves. Robin's dark humour, intellect, and composure are pretty strong traits. And Nami's intelligence, tactics, and brash attitude in regularly scheduled doses are almost always entertaining.

 

[M3J]

Nefertari Vivi & Carue all the way. love them so much, especially vivi, she's such a great character and i don't care if she's "weak".
after Vivi, it's definetly Robin. Her whole backstory and the way she was introduced and the way she IS is just unique and awesome.
i like that she's kind of "emotionless" and doesn't fear anything and the way she asked luffy to join... and her DF is sooo awesome... sadly Oda doesn't give her any shining moment since Enies Lobby arc.

Robin isn't really emotionless at all, more like calm and composed. She can be scared, sad, be happy, and even laugh. I like how she's calm and makes dark comments though, like thinking the Monster Trio were eaten by sea monsters or something. Definitely a great addition to the crew, and amazing personality wise. NOne of that over the top humor or quirk, and she can be quite realistic.

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

As much as I like Luffy, my favorite has to be Zoro. I know it's very cliche to say this, but he's badass, and his quirks are so funny. Plus his loyalty to Luffy knows no boundaries, sure everyone in the crew is supposed to be loyal, but I don't see anyone else take on the pain Luffy sustained on Thriller Bark, other than Sanji of course. Everyone in the crew is unique, that's what I like about them, and I learned to like certain characters that I wasn't fond of at first, like Robin.

 

[BetaRuler]

I tossed up between Brook or Sanji and took Brook! Because his jokes hit my funny bones! Yohohohohoo!
It's gotta be that relaxed and eccentric attitude "relax all we can do is wait til the others arrive, panicking wont speed things up!" "WHY ARE YOU SO RELAXED!?"

Sanji's "bro" times are among my fav crew moments too. Stupid bits like that "Women from the land of snow have the softest skin!" XD
Or his disregard to guys "Nami? HERE! Robin? Here! OK EVERYONES ACCOUNTED FOR!"

 

[ProGoddess]

Who is your favorite Strawhat and why ?

(yeah, there is some funky choices, but hey...)

The title says, "Who is your Favorite Strawhat?" but the list includes Vivi, Carue, Johnny and Yoksuku. I can understand Going Merry which was the StrawHat's first ship while Thousand Sunny being the successor and both ships are part of the StrawHat members.

The poll is very ambiguous - what are you looking at? Are you interested in the StrawHat members or their allies (like Vivi for instance)? Which "favorite" are you referring to? If it is only the StrawHat members, then only the members' names should be stated. If you are talking about the StrawHat's allies, then there is definitely a whole lot of them (since the Crew has been making a lot of friends throughout their journey) and not just the four that you have stated.

Kindly decide and edit your post accordingly.

 

[Sachsenhesse]

Zoro. For always kicking ass, even when he looses.

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

The title says, "Who is your Favorite Strawhat?" but the list includes Vivi, Carue, Johnny and Yoksuku. I can understand Going Merry which was the StrawHat's first ship while Thousand Sunny being the successor and both ships are part of the StrawHat members.

The poll is very ambiguous - what are you looking at? Are you interested in the StrawHat members or their allies (like Vivi for instance)? Which "favorite" are you referring to? If it is only the StrawHat members, then only the members' names should be stated. If you are talking about the StrawHat's allies, then there is definitely a whole lot of them (since the Crew has been making a lot of friends throughout their journey) and not just the four that you have stated.

Kindly decide and edit your post accordingly.

Yeah so far only the known SH's and the ships are part of the crew, Vivi and the others are more like allies. It would have been better to list only the known SHs or maybe just have a category named other, in case someone joins in this arc.

 

[Bellamy]

The title says, "Who is your Favorite Strawhat?" but the list includes Vivi, Carue, Johnny and Yoksuku. I can understand Going Merry which was the StrawHat's first ship while Thousand Sunny being the successor and both ships are part of the StrawHat members.

The poll is very ambiguous - what are you looking at? Are you interested in the StrawHat members or their allies (like Vivi for instance)? Which "favorite" are you referring to? If it is only the StrawHat members, then only the members' names should be stated. If you are talking about the StrawHat's allies, then there is definitely a whole lot of them (since the Crew has been making a lot of friends throughout their journey) and not just the four that you have stated.

Kindly decide and edit your post accordingly.

You know, all the Strawhats who were here during Alabasta think of Vivi (and Carue) as true Nakamas. And not simply allies.
Johnny and Yosaku are more like a funny thing than a true choice, come on. It doesn't really disturb anybody except you. In fact, I consider them as Nakamas because they were simply along the crew before the Baratie and until the end of Arlong Park. Nobody else canon was on the ship and along them like those four did.
Recently, we could talk about Kin'emon and Momonosuke and also Trafalgar Law but the future is uncertain.
Of course, they were many other allies live Duval, Hatchan, Rayleigh, Jinbei, Bon Clay, but again, none of them were along like those four.
I found funny to add them.

I will not edit the poll, sorry.

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

You know, all the Strawhats who were here during Alabasta think of Vivi (and Carue) as true Nakamas. And not simply allies.
Johnny and Yosaku are more like a funny thing than a true choice, come on. It doesn't really disturb anybody except you. In fact, I consider them as Nakamas because they were simply along the crew before the Baratie and until the end of Arlong Park. Nobody else canon was on the ship and along them like those four did.
Recently, we could talk about Kin'emon and Momonosuke and also Trafalgar Law but the future is uncertain.
Of course, they were many other allies live Duval, Hatchan, Rayleigh, Jinbei, Bon Clay, but again, none of them were along like those four.
I found funny to add them.

I will not edit the poll, sorry.

ProGoddess isn't the only one bothered by those choices, in fact it was never stated by Oda that those four were nakamas,as in part of the crew. That should be the definition of a nakama in here. Sure they fought with the SHs, and Vivi could have joined...but she didn't, which means that she doesn't have the same standing as Zoro or Sanji for example.It would make sense to see them as friends of the SHs, allies, or even possible SHs. If we had to count all the people that helped the SHs, then Duval and the others should be in there too. Do I need to remind you how he guarded the ship for 2 years, and all the injuries he suffered because of it?
So it would be better to have another option named "other" or simply take out those two options.

 

[VAArmOOs]

Zoro of course. He's loyal and he is almost impervious to manipulation. He has a very assertive personality, thank gOda for that!