Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2012] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[kewl0210]

I guess I'll mention what I'm reading.
Toriko
One Piece
Naruto
Beelzebub
Gintama
HXH

I'm behind on:
Sket Dance
Bleach
Kuroko no Basuke
Inumaru Dashi
Medaka Box
Nurarihyon no Mago
Magico

I'm mostly behind on those due to lack of time to catch up, I've got about 30 manga I'm currently reading or am planning to read. I only read the beginning of Medaka Box and Magico. I'll probably read the rest of Bleach when it ends just to see how it went. My favorite series is Toriko, and One Piece and HXH are close. HXH maybe more, but it's not running right now. People seem to like Nisekoi, so Ill try reading that once I can buy a tankoubon of it.

And I guess we'll see if that TOC is real. I was looking up the authors of Onani Master Kurosawa. The author writes novels and things now, and the artist (Sometimes going under just Yoko, and sometimes as Yoko Takuma) had done a one-shot in NEXT and later a One-Shot in the main magazine.
He got an honorable mention in the 29th Jump Treasure Newcomer Award for this:
http://www.shonenjump.com/j/manga-shou/treasure/comics/12ketsu_senka-ni-saku.html
He also did Kyougi Dance-Bu ni Youkoso (Welcome to the Competitive Dance Club) which ran as a one-shot in Jump 6 months ago.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

In order of preference:

Sket Dance
Toriko
Gintama
One Piece
Saiki
Bulge
Inumaru
Haikyu
Beelzebub
Kuroko
Nura
Kurogane
Magico
Pajama
Nisekoi

Dropped:

Naruto
Bleach
Reborn
Medaka

Where do you read PSI at I am interested

 

[wintercry]

Raw, likely.

 

[clydu94]

It's my turn now !

Series I read in order of preference :

- Hunter x Hiatus (My very first manga)
- One Piece (I dropped it 3 or 4 years ago and I got back into it because of the hype)
- Bleach (Love this manga so much..)
- Bulge (If it keeps this up, it can become a very strong serie)
- Pajama (very enjoyable since Chapter 8, there's less ecchi and I like that)
- Naruto (I don't even know where to begin with that..)

Series on hold :

- Gintama
- Toriko
- Nisekoi

 

[Limit]

Too bad Pajama is so low, it could have been really enjoyable if it lasts longer. Hopefully the rankings go higher if it can.
Well I guess I'll take a crack at it as well.
Series that I read:
-One Piece Definitely my favorite manga
-Beelzebub It's pretty enjoyable, mostly the gags though
-HunterxHunter It would be way better if it wasn't for all the hiatuses
-Gintama The gags are hilarious and the action is cool too
-Nisekoi It's one of the more enjoyable rom-coms I've read these past few years
-Bulge It has a great start and I'm hoping it lives up to the potential
-Sket Dance Great series, too bad the scans are behind. If I could find tank raws and a translator I'd definitely help out the series.
-Naruto The current arc isn't so good imo, but I'll stick with it until the end.

Series that I dropped/on hold:
-Bleach I'll probably read it in a bit, but I haven't read anything since the fullbring arc
-Pajama The rankings are low so I'll hold off for a while to see if it's cancelled.
-Magico Couldn't get into it.
-Reborn I'm waiting for this arc to end.

 

[[Cross]]

hm, in no particular order:

Reading (I enjoy reading weekly):
- Naruto (kinda pushing it lately though)
- Medaka Box
- Bleach
- Beelzebub
- One Piece

Stuff on Hold:
- Reborn (The new arc got hella boring, but am too far in to drop it, I'll probably marathon when it ends)
- Magico (Same reason as Reborn)
- Sket Dance (Too lazy to catch up)

Dropped (they became too dull for me to read):
- Nisekoi
- Pajama
- Kurogane
- Nurarihyon no Mago

 

[FanOfAniManga]

Let's see...

Series I read:
- Sensei no Bulge: Currently, it's the series I'm closely following the most because I'm most excited with this one.
- Beelzebub: The story hasn't been eyecatching lately, but it's still quite enjoyable to read.

Series I'm behind on:
- Sket Dance: I only started watching/reading it since April of last year and I still have a lot of catching up to do to get to the latest chapters. My pace is pretty slow because I keep forgetting about it.
- Nurarihyon no Mago: The random debut of so many new characters in such a radically changed storyline is really giving me a hard time to read on. It's also pretty clear that the series won't be able to last much longer, so my overall excitement for this series is mostly killed.
- Bleach: I have the same problems with Bleach as I did with Nurarihyon no Mago. Ever since Aizen's defeat, I just can't get myself to care about any newer developments in the story much longer.

Series I've dropped:
- Naruto: It's been 5 years since I've dropped Naruto because starting the early Shippuden storyline kind of turned me off somehow. Maybe I'll start reading it again, but not in the near future.

 

[crimsonlink310]

crimsonlink310
OP's middle part did end with the TS, it will be hard to look for an end, when the last third of the plot just started.
You would miss the closure of the manga[Naruto], just because it will take a bit more than the war to finish the story?

More like One Piece has finally reached the middle point. You do realize that the Straw Hats have to got through 7 more Islands to reach the end right? Punk Hazard arc will hopefully end before the end of the year.

As for Naruto, I would drop it if there is no closure right after the war. Say like a new arc starts and there is no conclusion in sight.

As for the rankings, only Beelzebub ranking disappoints me. How can such a funny manga be in the bottom 5. At least Reborn! is out of the bottom 5.

BTW how can Koganeiro be canceled 2 issues later when it has barely made an appearance? lol

Oh I forgot to mention that Kurogane is lucky thats its a color page right now. Is the Author really bad? He seems to have gotten a bad rep or something lol. Which sucks because I actually like Kurogane a lot.

 

[Negative Syndicate]

BTW how can Koganeiro be canceled 2 issues later when it has barely made an appearance? lol

It's not cancelled; it was scheduled to relase for just three chapters.

 

[crimsonlink310]

It's not cancelled; it was scheduled to relase for just three chapters.

Oh ok, I just saw the mini series title next to it. Now I feel stupid hahahaha.

 

[Drmke]

BTW how can Koganeiro be canceled 2 issues later when it has barely made an appearance? lol

Koganeiro (Center Colour, Mini Series, 31pg.) <- Artist of Onani Master Kurosawa

Koganeiro (Center Colour, Mini Series, 31pg.) <- Artist of Onani Master Kurosawa

Koganeiro (Center Colour, Mini Series, 31pg.) <- Artist of Onani Master Kurosawa

Why you no read?!

tl;dr: It's a miniseries.

 

[Jaiden82]

Jump series I enjoy reading
Bleach (fav jump series, don't really care what people say about it anymore)
Naruto (I can never get tired of my boy Naruto)
Reborn (Tsuna is still no good)
Nurarihyon No Mago (Love the art and story. IMO the most underrated series in Jump)
Beelzebub (Oga rules)
Nisekoi (One of my favorite new series)
Medaka Box (Some outrageous characters in it but I like it)
Magico (Low rankings are killing it but I just the love the characters)
Kurogane (Stopped at ch.31 because it was the last english scan of it to come out but I still like it)
Pajama No Konojo (Found it interesting off the jump and look forward to every chapter)
HxH (Sad it went on hiatus again)
One Piece (Not a huge fan like everybody else but its something to read)
Sensei No Bulge (First two chapters were good, let's see if it keeps up)

Dropped
Toriko (Couldn't really stand it really)

Will probably read in the near future (maybe)
Gintama (Keep saying I would read this one day but I never get the chance to)
Sket Dance (People keep telling me its good but we'll see)

 

[xi0]

Current

One Piece
Naruto
Bleach

Behind

Toriko
Medaka Box
Nurarihyon no Mago
Sket Dance
Beelzebub
Medaka Box

Dropped

Reborn! - Could pick it back up, but I doubt it.

 

[Savi]

I'm reading everything in Jump that got Edited Manga, so Inumaru Dashi and PSI is out of the list and I still need to catch up with Mago, the rest reading weekly when chapters released.
I'm a fan of old Jump, lately I finished reading some old manga like Kinnikuman, Stone Ocean, Mazinger Z and much more! Recommend for everyone to read old Jump manga, most of them are better than what Jump got today.

 

[brigid001]

Series I Read:
One Piece(from time to time)
Naruto (haven't enjoyed it in awhile but determined to stick with it)
Bleach( like naruto)
Reborn(still enjoying it incredibly)
HXH(my fave jump manga!! Come back soon Togashi!)
Nisekoi( Really enjoying this series. It's a fun read)
Haikyuu( really enjoy this but it hasn't been updated recently)
Bulge(off to a good start, hope it does well)

Dropped:
Magico( I read this for a long time but after the arc with his brother I completely lost interest)

 

[gananime]

Series which I read:

Weekly
Hunter x Hunter (best running series of Jump Waiting for its return from hiatus. Hope the new arc is awesome as always!)

One Piece (This one took so damn long catching up to..after watching 500+ episodes and finally caught up at Fishman Island arc in the manga. Punk Hazard arc is really good. However the story shows no sign of converging, I wonder if OP will still remain popular if Oda keeps dragging out the story)

Naruto (It's getting boring and dragged out. Kishi should converge and end it soon)

Bleach (It's gotten awful. Even after the Fullbring Arc, it hasn't managed to pick up.)

Reborn (It has been really dragged out too. The recent chapters are interesting though. Hope Amano gives it a proper conclusion and not drag out any more)

Catching up

Gintama (I'm really enjoying it. Will catch up to it soon. Many thanks for kewl and his group for Editing it )

Dropped/Hiatus

Toriko (I got into it after seeing how well it polled every week and thought to give it a try. Just managed to reach chapter 25-ish. Dont know if I'll pick it up again)

ST&RS (Picked it up after lot of initial hype and then it went downhill -_- )

Completed
Bakuman
Death Note
Hikaru no Go
I love Obata sensei's series Eagerly waiting for his next work,irrespective of whether he partners with Ohba or anyone else!

Plan to read
Sket Dance (It has survived for 5 years and continuing. I'm interested to see how good it is)

Beelzebub (I've seen 1-2 episodes of the anime here and there and it was funny. But heard that it's got lot of fillers,so thought of starting from chap 1 of the manga)

Nisekoi (Was hesitant to give it a chance first lest it follows the same path of ST&RS. Now that it has been consistently doing well,I'm gonna read this soon)

Nurarhiyon no Mago (It seemed interesting at first. But the talks of it ending soon and poorly polling in the TOCs has left me skeptical)

Jump Issue #27 TOC
Bleach (Cover, Lead CP)
Naruto
One Piece
Toriko
Koganeiro (Center Colour, Mini Series, 31pg.) <- Artist of Onani Master Kurosawa
Sensei no Bulge (23pg.)
Nisekoi
Nurarihyon no Mago (Center Colour, Popularity Contest Results Annnouncement)
PSI Kusuo Saiki
Koisome Momiji
Haikyuu
Sket Dance
Kurogane (Center Colour)
Gintama
Kuroko no Basket
Reborn!
Inumaru Dashi (END)
Kochikame
Medaka Box
Beelzebub
Magico
Pajama na Kanojo

Jump Issue #28 Information
Lead CP: One Piece
Center Colour: Sket Dance, Kochikame, Kuroko no Basket

Jump Issue #29 Information
END: Koganeiro

I think there's a good chance that this TOC may not be true as it contradicts your earlier statement with Medaka Box.

The super early Medaka Box spoiler provider just came online.

I just asked him for the Jump rankings but he will probably only give me Medaka Box's position. We might get lucky, though

------------------------------------------------------

Yep, he only gave me Medaka Box's position.



He usually states when Medaka is in the bottom 5 so I'm guessing Medaka is probably bottom 6th-8th.

 

[Oberon]

I have found also this ToC, the top right or wrong is similar to that of Zeromcd. The lower part and bottom are quite different. I don't know if mine is fake and the one of Zeromcd is correct and viceversa...

222 ：Classical名無しさん：2012/05/30(水) 13:04:31.74 ID:cD3f4Vee
鰤
ワンピース
ナルト
トリコ
こがねいろ
バルジ
ニセコイ
ぬらり
ハイキュー
紅葉
斉木
銀魂
スケット
べるぜ
クロガネ
黒子
パジャマ
リボン
いぬまる
こち亀
めだか
マジコ

Jump #27 (04/06) :
Bleach (Cover & Lead Color Page)
One Piece
Naruto
Toriko
Kogainero (Color Page, New Series*, 31 pg.)
Sensei no Balge (23 pg.)
Nisekoi
Nurarihyon no Mago (Color Page, Popularity Contest Results)
Hq!!
Koisome Momiji
PSI Kusuo Saiki
Gintama
Sket Dance
Beelzebub
Kurogane (Color Page)
Kuroko no Basket
Pajama na Kanojo
Reborn!
Inumaru Dashi (End)
Kochikame
Medaka Box
Magico
Hunter x Hunter (Hiatus)

-----

* The series will consist of just three chapters.

 

[Zeltrax]

Hey, this seems fun!
Currently reading:
One Piece [ Do you even need to ask? ]
Naruto [ Just waiting for it to end. ]
Bleach [ I don't know, I still like it somewhat despite all the flames I guess. ]
Nisekoi [ Romance in jump and a pretty well done romance. ]
Beelzebub [ For LOL ]
HxH [ Hiatus again...]
Barrage [ This manga will get better and a lot better imo ]

Need Catching up/ Might not even bother catching up:
Toriko [I think I'll read it in arcs]
Nura [Underrated]
Sket Dance [A must]

Dropped:
Reborn [meh.]

 

[meeedoooz]

reading
Naruto ( best manga imo )
bleach ( second favorite right now )
HxH ( hope it comes back soon )
gintama ( king of comedy )

dropped
OP ( got into it because of the war, after that i didn't find a single reason to stick with it )
reborn

 

[Schabrak]

OP ( got into it because of the war, after that i didn't find a single reason to stick with it )

Did you try the next arc, which is undoubtedly much better and everything before the war?