- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 28
- Reaction score
- 358
- Age
- 39
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 5!
---------- Post added at 10:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:58 AM ----------
He went on you in his two nightsFaust: He's been acting really different to past games, where he had either a boring role or went straight for self-destruction as a bomb. Him acting rather active and normal this time might just be because he's finally a role where he can influence the whole the game through consecutive nights. Probably was the first time he had to think at night ("who should I protect, test my ability on?") which, together with a theme he liked, made him a lot more active and yes, way less trollish. He went for lawlett for two consecutive nights, which is a really rare behaviour for a mafia member. Why should you bring up your buddy twice? Of course it could be that this was just his plan, so he's not out of suspicion but I think it's not really likely atm. Him claiming to be a doctor at an early state was way more risky than claiming to be a normal townie too.
Chances of Faust being Mafia: 30%
---------- Post added at 10:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:58 AM ----------
OR faust is no doctor, you protected evil and you killed him. The Mafia killed Xi0. Xi0 and Evil already tell for evryone they are both masons. OR Faust is a naiveSorry, i was answering a call, that's why i didn't answer as fast as i could.
At this point, to get to some conclusions you have to just check some possibilities, and see if they all connect each other. If that's the case, you can pretty much get to final decision even though you skipped some other possibilities.
Honestly lets think of all hypotheses. Between evil and xi0 who do you think would be the target from the Mafia? I don't really buy the theory of mafia having a poisoner, cuz since i am a doctor and faust is also a doctor and imp was confirmed also being a doctor, there's a chance of the remaining 2 docs, that one of us is the insane doctor, which obviously would explain why 2 people died. With this said the theory of existing a mafia poisoner it's almost zero i would say.
Now what really answers all this would be ... who did Mafia targeted? I think the answer is pretty clear. Why would the Mafia go for someone who has revealed his previous role, the way xi0 did? At this point it would be so much better for Mafia if they killed the recruiter. So if Evil died, while i was protecting him, it doesn't clear the suspicious of me being insane, but xi0 dying does. If xi0 died, and if my theory is right and the other doc, which is prolly faust, tried to protect him and ended killing him, it pretty much clears my suspicious as being insane, and at the same time, it's also clear i am not the doctor since i also failed to save evil.

) so to me the case of voting for KD cleared him more than making him suspicious.
bro ... so i really didn't think of him being the bomb, even though at first i have to admit i didn't really think about it.
really does irritate a lot of people.