Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.9

[Imperium]

Kat asked me to help her host a game, I agreed and I guess she will be hosting after Xadyu with me as co-host.^^ And we have prepared a bit ...

I honestly think there should be a limit of at least playing a certain number of games before you can host, or co-host or wtv.

 

[Josef]

I honestly think there should be a limit of at least playing a certain number of games before you can host, or co-host or wtv.

Indeed, well I have played 9, and i thought I had some experience to try out hosting, with help ofc. But honestly it is not enough imo, maybe I can do with a few more playing. But what do you suggest the number of games played should be before you host?

 

[Hardy]

I honestly think there should be a limit of at least playing a certain number of games before you can host, or co-host or wtv.

Except that Kat has played 9 (8, the list in the history thread is wrong?) already, more than niichan (7) and Faust (6) when they started hosting.

But I agree.

Indeed, well I have played 9, and i thought I had some experience to try out hosting, with help ofc. But honestly it is not enough imo, maybe I can do with a few more playing. But what do you suggest the number of games played should be before you host?

10?

 

[MidoBan]

I honestly think there should be a limit of at least playing a certain number of games before you can host, or co-host or wtv.

I think i played 11 or 12 games only ç.ç it was 14 o.o

 

[jorped]

I have only played 6 games

 

[Hardy]

Imo, we should just have some group that gives their thumbs up or thumbs down to a new host. I'm not a fan of democracies, an aristocracy sounds way better (to avoid having 1 dictator or 30 people voting for no reason, making it a popularity contest). Evil (for obvious reasons, he introduced the game, has hosted more than anyone else and takes more care of the section than anyone else imo), DD (2nd top host, knows lots about the game) and Imp (hasn't hosted once as far as I know, but he has contributed lots and is -prolly and arguably- the best mafia player) could be that group.

Of course, this is a suggestion, just an idea, everyone is free to say their opinions about the topic and bash me as much as you want for this

I have only played 6 games

No wonder you suck.

 

[Imperium]

I think that's ridiculous. The hosts shouldnt be decided by a select group of people, its for the forum as a whole. I am totally against that and would not like to be a part of any such group.

Anybody should be able to host but after a minimum amount of game (like 5 or something) was all that I was saying, otherwise the game mechanics might not be understood and we would end up with a blai game again. I didnt think Kat played that amount so I pointed that out but it seems like she has, so carry on I guess.

 

[Hardy]

I think that's ridiculous. The hosts shouldnt be decided by a select group of people, its for the forum as a whole. I am totally against that and would not like to be a part of any such group.

Anybody should be able to host but after a minimum amount of game (like 5 or something) was all that I was saying, otherwise the game mechanics might not be understood and we would end up with a blai game again. I didnt think Kat played that amount so I pointed that out but it seems like she has, so carry on I guess.

Just like we do with roles?

It's harder in this case, as people aren't just roles. You can't say ¨that role sucks¨. Nor I think that the amount of played games has anything to do with the capability (is that a word) of a person to host.

In any case, it was just a suggestion, and I knew that it could get that kind of feedback, that's why I said you could bash me in the end, lol.

---------- Post added at 07:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:31 PM ----------

Or you can just let anyone host and people are free to join or not.

 

[digitaldude]

I honestly think there should be a limit of at least playing a certain number of games before you can host, or co-host or wtv.

At least 20, xadyu has over that number I think.

 

[Hardy]

At least 20, xadyu has over that number I think.

18.

Only you, Lala, Imp and Lawlett have over 20 games.

 

[digitaldude]

Imo, we should just have some group that gives their thumbs up or thumbs down to a new host. I'm not a fan of democracies, an aristocracy sounds way better (to avoid having 1 dictator or 30 people voting for no reason, making it a popularity contest). Evil (for obvious reasons, he introduced the game, has hosted more than anyone else and takes more care of the section than anyone else imo), DD (2nd top host, knows lots about the game) and Imp (hasn't hosted once as far as I know, but he has contributed lots and is -prolly and arguably- the best mafia player) could be that group.

Of course, this is a suggestion, just an idea, everyone is free to say their opinions about the topic and bash me as much as you want for this



No wonder you suck.

I would say no to almost everyone. evil would say yes to almost everyone. Imp would be the decider, I say no to this idea.

---------- Post added at 10:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:46 PM ----------

18.

Only you, Lala, Imp and Lawlett have over 20 games.

Ah...Then give the hosting to lawlett.

 

[Hardy]

So Imp and DD said no, 2/3, I guess it's already denied.



Nah, I really didn't expect positive feedback from it, lol. But saw it somehow fair.

Letting anyone host should be ok I guess.

Ah...Then give the hosting to lawlett.

Exactly what I thought when I saw the list

 

[digitaldude]

So Imp and DD said no, 2/3, I guess it's already denied.



Nah, I really didn't expect positive feedback from it, lol. But saw it somehow fair.

Letting anyone host should be ok I guess.

WRONGU!

 

[Hardy]

How then, smartass >_>

If people don't trust a host, they are free not to join the game and that's it.

 

[digitaldude]

How then, smartass >_>

If people don't trust a host, they are free not to join the game and that's it.

Damn you hardy!

 

[Hardy]

Wow, I'm such a polar dude. In one post I suggest an aristocracy and 1 post after it I suggest people to do wtf they want

Damn you hardy!

well, seems fair :/

 

[Josef]

Mafia Game hosting isn't American Idol.

 

[Hardy]

Mafia Game hosting isn't American Idol.

Actually, American Idol's final stage is a complete democracy.

DD would be a good Simon though.

 

[digitaldude]

Actually, American Idol's final stage is a complete democracy.

DD would be a good Simon though.

You know how I told the previous poster he is the worst poster in mafia game?

Well, you are the worst poster in the funforum!

 

[gnut]

I would say no to almost everyone. evil would say yes to almost everyone. Imp would be the decider, I say no to this idea.

---------- Post added at 10:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:46 PM ----------



Ah...Then give the hosting to lawlett.

whats wrong with lulu....he probably smarter than the whole lot of us