Games Mafia Game 144 - Pan the Diver - Day 5

[Copy Panda]

D5 VOTES

Voting 6/8

5x Kako - Sam #1377, Lumi #1394, Nash #1432 #1448, Tatsu #1479, Arrow #1378 #1484
1x Nash - Kakoha #1447

DAY DURATION

Spoiler: Event Rules

0-50m - [Surface] - Pantis Shrimp respects the power of love! One random mafia and one random townie turn into Lovers!

51-100m - [Shallows] - Pantis Shrimp can't let it rest! All passive roles at [Shallows] height are replaced with Restless Spirit!

101-150m - [Depths] - Pantis Shrimp is overruled! All defused Bombs receive a Sea-Urchin (one-time NVD)! Starting from the following Day Phase: all Bomb Defusers who have successfully dismantled a bomb (at any point during the game, including different depths) become a Noble.

151-200m - [Abyss] - Pantis Shrimp has been parried! A random plain townie's [Abyss] role is replaced with Prostitute! A random mafia's passive [Abyss] role is replaced with Escort!

Beware of the poll closing time.​

 

[SirSamuel016]

I'm not fussed about depths this early on tbh but it is interesting to see a few be adamant on staying somewhere or going deeper without much reasoning

 

[Erinyes]

Yes, but one of them repeats so its really three; I already said as much to clarify in post #16

oh ok my bad i thought 4 , so there are 2 players with 3 roles

 

[Stylether]

Style and Gry, are your surface roles that important that you're doing the math on how to prevent the deep dive in the next day phase?

I mean, I like doing things and getting to keep doing things? I also got the impression, from the amount of people coming out in favour of the shallows, that keeping us there is generally beneficial, so considering both cases, why not stay up here?

9 out of 16 players voted to ascend 40, they can't all be town.

But they can't all be scum (fish pun) either? This feels like applying voting logic (if there's scum on this option then it's an anti-town option) to depth (with only 4 depth segments there's bound to be segments beneficial to both teams, especially the starting one).

So yeah, I don't entirely vibe with the logic here, but ultimately I won't be too fussed if we did dive, it'll make my nights easier on me. Less thinking.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 5:44 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 5:38 AM ---

I would like to thank the extended timer for doing a lot of heavy lifting, I see most of us won't have made it in the original 24h

 

[GrySun]

Style and Gry, are your surface roles that important that you're doing the math on how to prevent the deep dive in the next day phase?

Maybe

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:15 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:13 AM ---

Like Style said it cant be a fully mafia benefitial thing with how many want it, so whats the problem with staying up here?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:16 AM ---

Actually yup, I'm starting to dislike that "town wants the surface roles more" idea.

Do elaborate on why

 

[Lumii?!]

votekill DD before i forgot
do we dive 80m and then go up 40m or do we go up 40 mso still 0 meters and then go down 80 ?

 

[GrySun]

votekill DD before i forgot
do we dive 80m and then go up 40m or do we go up 40 mso still 0 meters and then go down 80 ?

You mean if those 2 options win? We just add/substract and then do the one movement probably.

But anyways. Hello new player. Hows it going? Why are you voting DD? Any insight into other players you have to share so far, or anything you want to share about yourself?

 

[SirSamuel016]

We just add/substract and then do the one movement probably.

That's how I understand it; say we have +80m depth and -40m (go up 40), that means we go down 40m overall from our current point

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:26 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:26 AM ---

votekill DD before i forgot
do we dive 80m and then go up 40m or do we go up 40 mso still 0 meters and then go down 80 ?

Why are you voting for dd?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:28 AM ---

Votekill Mazino
Game end at a very inconvenient time for me but I'll try to be around.

What was your reasoning for this?

 

[GrySun]

Sam we need to somehow get some talks going

 

[Lumii?!]

You mean if those 2 options win? We just add/substract and then do the one movement probably.

But anyways. Hello new player. Hows it going? Why are you voting DD? Any insight into other players you have to share so far, or anything you want to share about yourself?

voted for him cause natasha pointed out the fact he voted for someone without knowing who it was... can still change my mind

 

[SirSamuel016]

Sam we need to somehow get some talks going

My bad boss, Super Sam is slightly nerfed by University atm (big heckin research essay to write) but I still intend on being as ultra-active as I can

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:31 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:30 AM ---

voted for him cause natasha pointed out the fact he voted for someone without knowing who it was... can still change my mind

Why trust Natasha though and follow?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:33 AM ---

The only person yet to hint is @89_Snehal who only came along to diss my rap and then fucked off. Bit of a disappointing debut from them

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:41 AM ---

Sam we need to somehow get some talks going

@Stylether @Lumii?! @GrySun @Mazino I see that you're all around so is there anything that has stood out for you so far? Plus who if any do you suspect, even a little?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:41 AM ---

I see @Degojaru and @89_Snehal are around now too so I ask the same of you

 

[Lumii?!]

My bad boss, Super Sam is slightly nerfed by University atm (big heckin research essay to write) but I still intend on being as ultra-active as I can

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:31 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:30 AM ---

Why trust Natasha though and follow?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:33 AM ---

The only person yet to hint is @89_Snehal who only came along to diss my rap and then fucked off. Bit of a disappointing debut from them

well Natasha was the first to make a claim so I felt like it was a more trust worthy action to do so

 

[shinobi]

I mean, I like doing things and getting to keep doing things? I also got the impression, from the amount of people coming out in favour of the shallows, that keeping us there is generally beneficial, so considering both cases, why not stay up here?




But they can't all be scum (fish pun) either? This feels like applying voting logic (if there's scum on this option then it's an anti-town option) to depth (with only 4 depth segments there's bound to be segments beneficial to both teams, especially the starting one).

So yeah, I don't entirely vibe with the logic here, but ultimately I won't be too fussed if we did dive, it'll make my nights easier on me. Less thinking.

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 5:44 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 5:38 AM ---

I would like to thank the extended timer for doing a lot of heavy lifting, I see most of us won't have made it in the original 24h

As I said, the 9 players can't all be town, not that they're all mafia. In short, asking for certain depth is not alignment indicative per se. Which is why saying "the surface roles are more to town benefit" is weird.

This will be sorted out by voting anyway, but people vote for their own benefit, to play the roles they want more, not for town.

 

[Lumii?!]

well Natasha was the first to make a claim so I felt like it was a more trust worthy action to do so

+ it was the only convincing clue I saw

 

[89_Snehal]

I would like to hear why natasha voted or pointed for DD tho , still early to guess who is mafia , and ya.... Samuel rap was poem.

 

[Degojaru]

@Stylether @Lumii?! @GrySun @Mazino I see that you're all around so is there anything that has stood out for you so far? Plus who if any do you suspect, even a little?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:41 AM ---

I see @Degojaru and @89_Snehal are around now too so I ask the same of you

I was out, finish reading but don't have any suspects for now.

I'm fine staying in surface but seems that we'll dive deeper in D2

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:55 AM ---

As I said, the 9 players can't all be town, not that they're all mafia. In short, asking for certain depth is not alignment indicative per se. Which is why saying "the surface roles are more to town benefit" is weird.

This will be sorted out by voting anyway, but people vote for their own benefit, to play the roles they want more, not for town.

I'm with Shino in this, a townie can vote to descend 80m if they have a preferable role there

 

[shinobi]

Maybe

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:15 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:13 AM ---

Like Style said it cant be a fully mafia benefitial thing with how many want it, so whats the problem with staying up here?

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:16 AM ---

Do elaborate on why

Are you asking because you really don't know? Because there are probably doctor, det, spy, and prosti roles in the other depths waiting to play their roles. Sticking to one depth meaning wasting the roles in other places. Which is why I asked if your role and style's role are worth it.

It doesn't matter where we end in d1, staying in one place tho is a different story.

 

[Degojaru]

Also Sty and Pom voted twice, I assume they want to ascend 40m

 

[SirSamuel016]

Samuel rap was poem.

Yo yo
Why the fuck are you hating on me and my art for man?
That's some fucked up terror shit, straight taliban
You've done nothing noteworthy, just piss and moan
Get your shit together cuz I'm in the zone

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:58 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:57 AM ---

I would like to hear why natasha voted or pointed for DD tho

She explained her thinking somewhat though???

 

[Lumii?!]

I would like to hear why natasha voted or pointed for DD tho , still early to guess who is mafia , and ya.... Samuel rap was poem.

natasha said DD voted for someone without knowing who it was

 

[89_Snehal]

Yo yo
Why the fuck are you hating on me and my art for man?
That's some fucked up terror shit, straight taliban
You've done nothing noteworthy, just piss and moan
Get your shit together cuz I'm in the zone

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 6:58 AM, Original Post Date: Wednesday at 6:57 AM ---

She explained her thinking somewhat though???

Ayo relax I was joking cause you mentioned about it again , you took is seriously, sorry mate, let's focus on game now

--- Double Post Merged, Wednesday at 7:02 AM ---

natasha said DD voted for someone without knowing who it was

Ooh okk i missed the chat above earlier