Discussion Best Offense - Results

[Kiki]

Welcome to the infamous power levels-based ranking event! Mini festival for all Fairy Tail section members, warming before the true festival: Fairy Tail Fighting Tournament!

This game is basically similar to @BluePegasus 's previous games (link 1 link 2) and Top 10 rank games in Fun Forum section combined. This time the category is "Most Offensive Mages"!

RULES

1. DM your rank to @Kiki
2. The rank consists of 10 mages you consider to be the most offensive (great attack point)
3. Rank is simple, just give us rank from 1-10. The mage at #1 place gets 10 pts, the one at #10 place gets 1 pts. No x.5 points this time. No tie.
4. It is open until 5 days from now. The ranking will be revealed everyday
5. No troll ranking
6. Dragons are not allowed. Dead characters are not allowed

Okay everyone, DM your rank now! Spread the news, don't forget to tag your friends!

Results

 

[Axiomus]

1. Natsu
2. Gildarts
3. Laxus
4. Erza
5. Jellal
6. Skullion
7. Mirajane
8. Gray
9. Gajeel
10. Sting

This is how I currently see it. May change in the upcoming chapters as more Dragon Eaters tap into their Dragon Force.

 

[atlantisreturns]

1. Natsu
2. Gildarts
3. Laxus
4. Erza
5. Jellal
6. Skullion
7. Mirajane
8. Gray
9. Gajeel
10. Sting

This is how I currently see it. May change in the upcoming chapters as more Dragon Eaters tap into their Dragon Force.

I'd say let us separate Natsu from DF Natsu for this competition. It would lead to misunderstanding among people.

Because you know Natsu's DF is like , unreliable , and he cannot activate it whenever he wants. So while we may have DF Natsu in our mind , others might mistake it as Regular Natsu.

 

[Axiomus]

I'd say let us separate Natsu from DF Natsu for this competition. It would lead to misunderstanding among people.

Because you know Natsu's DF is like , unreliable , and he cannot activate it whenever he wants. So while we may have DF Natsu in our mind , others might mistake it as Regular Natsu.

If you don't think Natsu can enter DF on his own free will, then just rank accordingly.

 

[Star Frost]

Ooo you should do versatile next

 

[Jko]

I think I'm just going to focus my list primarily on the 100YQ. It would be too much of a headache to go through Alvarez feats lol.

 

[Kiki]

Ah yes, forgot to say, I think I wont provide list of characters you can see it on wikia

@Star Frost thats good suggestion. Also I want to suggest another cat: most clever mages or smthg. Clever at battles of course

 

[grey matter]

Welcome to the infamous power levels-based ranking event! Mini festival for all Fairy Tail section members, warming before the true festival: Fairy Tail Fighting Tournament!

This game is basically similar to @BluePegasus 's previous games (link 1 link 2) and Top 10 rank games in Fun Forum section combined. This time the category is "Most Offensive Mages"!

RULES

1. DM your rank to @Kiki
2. The rank consists of 10 mages you consider to be the most offensive (great attack point)
3. Rank is simple, just give us rank from 1-10. The mage at #1 place gets 10 pts, the one at #10 place gets 1 pts. No x.5 points this time. No tie.
4. It is open until 5 days from now. The ranking will be revealed everyday
5. No troll ranking
6. Dragons are not allowed. Dead characters are not allowed

Okay everyone, DM your rank now! Spread the news, don't forget to tag your friends!

No dead characters?
Half the fun & effort goes away now lol

 

[Tirl]

Little question, should we use all mage's power or one high spell can consider to? If so, Makarov no diff everyone with Fairy Low xd
Also, offensive it is like battle potential or destruction?

upd. saw about dead characters, too sad. Guess I wont play this time, half of my list are dead

 

[Kiki]

On dead chars topics, idk, i thought we all already agreed before lol but its not like it cant be changed. So i will give you guys time to discuss it or should we make a poll?

@Tirl Fairy Law is featless imo. It only beat Jose who is fodder at this point and Albareth soldiers. Most offensive as in the lethality of a mage's attack, damage output, attack potency, or whatever related to it.

 

[Ebony Maw]

Damn it, was hoping we could see some new feats from Jellal before this rating happened! Oh well.

Looking forward to seeing what people generally think about offensive power ranks atm. Thanks again for doing this @Kiki!

 

[Vis]

Ah yes, forgot to say, I think I wont provide list of characters you can see it on wikia

Honestly, I feel like you should list out at least the top 25 contenders in your opinion or something though. People often forget some characters and they simply get left out of the whole list, and wikia would give you like hundreds and hundreds of characters, not exactly the easiest list to skim through.

 

[Axiomus]

I feel like if you're struggling to remember a character, they probably aren't going to be in the top 10s.

 

[grey matter]

I feel like if you're struggling to remember a character, they probably aren't going to be in the top 10s.

Not sure about that lol, @Jko forgot about Gildarts in the top 10 tankiest list

Many forgot August as well

 

[Sevently]

it would be better with dead characters

 

[Axiomus]

Having dead characters might not change this all that much. Really the only big game changers I can think of is Irene and August. Irene was technically restricted last competition because she was a dragon. That really only leaves August. I dunno, maybe Wall can steal the top 10s if we really hype etherion.

Not sure about that lol, @Jko forgot about Gildarts in the top 10 tankiest list

I meant if most people forgot. If the character isn't well remembered enough, then he probably isn't very strong. Especially with characters with amazing attack power, as those tend to be remembered well.

 

[grey matter]

Having dead characters might not change this all that much. Really the only big game changers I can think of is Irene and August. Irene was technically restricted last competition because she was a dragon. That really only leaves August. I dunno, maybe Wall can steal the top 10s if we really hype etherion.



I meant if most people forgot. If the character isn't well remembered enough, then he probably isn't very strong. Especially with characters with amazing attack power, as those tend to be remembered well.

I can certainly see August, Serena and Wahl getting in through attack power; Bradman and Larcade getting in through hax, for at least quite a few people. That's 5 already lol.

Mard (Memento Mori) and law from Hades (GH boost) may be contenders as well.

Yeah, that's true. If everyone forgets then the guy is irrelevant. But in rankings, just a few people missing makes all the difference at the top. Laxus and Erza ended up above August and Gildarts just because a few people forgot about them lol

 

[Takuan]

I'll send my PM in a little while.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 15, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 15, 2020 ---

By the way, are we supposed to add comments or explain our reasons in the PM? Because in some posts you sometimes put comments from people.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 15, 2020 ---

Also, Most Offense, does that include any form of Hax? I see Axiomus mentioned Skullion. It's not just about raw power, hax counts, right ?

 

[Axiomus]

Also, Most Offense, does that include any form of Hax? I see Axiomus mentioned Skullion. It's not just about raw power, hax counts, right ?

Anything that does damage. So "hax" that does damage counts. Stuff that wins without inflicting any damage wouldn't.

Though when it comes to Skullion, I don't really consider him to rely on hax for his offense. He was going to turn the sea into ash, and he technically overpowered Ice-Make: SIlver.

I can certainly see August, Serena and Wahl getting in through attack power; Bradman and Larcade getting in through hax, for at least quite a few people. That's 5 already lol.

Mard (Memento Mori) and law from Hades (GH boost) may be contenders as well.

Yeah, that's true. If everyone forgets then the guy is irrelevant. But in rankings, just a few people missing makes all the difference at the top. Laxus and Erza ended up above August and Gildarts just because a few people forgot about them lol

Well, I guess. August is still the only big game changer if we include dead characters for me, though I suppose I can't speak for everyone. Maybe Wall. Serena seems to be a fan favorite, and he's a dragon slayer. Though personally, I can't see the argument for God Serena. Bloodman and Larcade were beaten by Gajeel and Sting respectively. Since Gajeel and Sting are already at the bottom of my list, I figured they simply don't have that high of a chance.

Though I suppose it would be more fun to include them anyways. It's still open for discussion. Maybe we should poll it?

 

[Kiki]

Honestly, I feel like you should list out at least the top 25 contenders in your opinion or something though. People often forget some characters and they simply get left out of the whole list, and wikia would give you like hundreds and hundreds of characters, not exactly the easiest list to skim through.

list would limit people's imagination. and there's a possibility one prefers character A to B in their list. list would fit a category based on group, such as Ishgar, Albareth, or dark guilds ranking. you don't have to search for all characters list on wikia lol. To make it easier, just search by group/affiliation such as Tartaros, Spriggan 12, FT. From FT, take some mages you consider most offensive. From Tartaros, take some too. And so on. I believe every strong mage is/was in a group. Avatar is a fodder group so you can just skip them.

By the way, are we supposed to add comments or explain our reasons in the PM? Because in some posts you sometimes put comments from people.

it's up to you me putting comments only happened in waifu ranking. it didn't in tanky one. because Brandish wanted to do it. but I suggest if you want to go deep, you can post your comments in this thread

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 15, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 15, 2020 ---

Not sure about that lol, @Jko forgot about Gildarts in the top 10 tankiest list

Many forgot August as well

jko is different case. I posted a August vs Gildarts and Cana but he still forgot about him maybe he and the others simply skipped my posts

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 15, 2020 ---

4 Days Left!​

Participants so far:
@Kouichi
@August_Lightning
@IamtherealMirajane
@Seven777
@grey matter
@Vis

DM now!