Fantasy Current Erza VS Current Mirajane

[Axiomus]

Except she didn’t have to resort to Alegria. Are you blind? She didn’t fight properly in her base form (which everyone can see because she didn’t fight like how she fought against Freed). Didn’t bother to try Sitri. Didn’t bother to try to Macro them. She jumped straight to Alegria because it had to have it’s time to shine.

Remember in the GMG when she used Sitri to one shot Jenny even though she would've still won even if she used the base form? It’s the exact same principle. New forms have to have time to shine in the story.

Yes she did. She literally did. It was literally what happened. Do you not see the irony of asking whether or not I am blind. Mirajane was getting beat up in her base form, and this was after Mirajane tried blasting them with Satan Soul with an attack as powerful as the one that finished off Freed. She wouldn't have resorted to Alegria if she had any other option, because she knew she was fighting a war and there were stronger enemies in the Spriggan 12 to fight. Even Natsu knew that he couldn't go all out fighting fodders.

Unlike Alegria, Sitri doesn't end up draining all of her magic power. It doesn't matter if she uses it against Jenny because it won't exhaust her. Also, Mirajane wasn't going to risk fighting an entire war with the Spriggans after that match.

 

[Animeluver]

Yes she did. She literally did. It was literally what happened. Do you not see the irony of asking whether or not I am blind. Mirajane was GETTING BEAT UP in her base form. She realized that Juliet and Heine were strong opponents that required her to use Alegria Soul. She wouldn't have resorted to Alegria if she had any other option, because she knew she was fighting a war and there were stronger enemies in the Spriggan 12 to fight after Juliet and Heine. Even Natsu knew that he couldn't go all out fighting fodders. Unlike Alegria, Sitri doesn't end up draining all of her magic power. It doesn't matter if she uses it against Jenny because it won't exhaust her.

Let’s see what happened:

They attacked her three times in her base form. This created distance between them. Why didn’t Mirajane take out her wings at this time to take flight? Why didn’t she use Soul Extinction? Why didn’t she use Evil Explosion? Why didn’t she rush at them? Why didn’t she try physical attacks?

Why did she give up after three attacks and not attack them properly in her base form? Oh yeah, because the plot needed to show us her new form. Just like how the plot needed Erza to slice a meteor with broken bones, even though it’s completely illogical, stupid and nonsensical. Fairytail is a story. A story will do whatever it needs to for whatever reason. So to hype Alegria up, Mirajane needed to struggle a bit, even though they should have made the struggle look more realistic. Mira stood still, got hit and gave up. Are you fucking kidding me? Did Mira even even try at all in her base form?

Watching Satan Soul against Juliet and Heine is a big downgrade from Satan Soul against Freed. It’s like there wasn’t even an attempt to win.

 

[Axiomus]

Let’s see what happened:

They attacked her three times in her base form. This created distance between them. Why didn’t Mirajane take out her wings at this time to take flight? Why didn’t she use Soul Extinction? Why didn’t she use Evil Explosion? Why didn’t she rush at them? Why didn’t she try physical attacks?

Why did she give up after three attacks and not attack them properly in her base form? Oh yeah, because the plot needed to show us her new form. Just like how the plot needed Erza to slice a meteor with broken bones, even though it’s completely illogical, stupid and nonsensical. Fairytail is a story. A story will do whatever it needs to for whatever reason. So to hype Alegria up, Mirajane needed to struggle a bit, even though they should have made the struggle look more realistic. Mira stood still, got hit and gave up. Are you fucking kidding me? Did Mira even even try at all in her base form?

Watching Satan Soul against Juliet and Heine is a big downgrade from Satan Soul against Freed. It’s like there wasn’t even an attempt to win.

You do realize soul extinction and evil explosion are actually just unnamed attacks in the manga, and that the names were tagged on by the previous anime studios right? Like not even the 2018 series that worked on the GMG and Tartarus arc. The first anime run. Hiro Mashima never writes names for Satan Soul's attacks. What we do see is that Mirajane tried to hit them with a huge blast just as impressive as the one that she used on Freed (which again, in the manga is unnamed). Juliet and Heine started attacking her after this blast. If an attack as powerful as any blast Mirajane has ever shown with Satan Soul was tanked, and her opponents started beating her up after tanking it....What makes you think Mirajane would have more success going hand to hand?

Spoiler: Mirajane attacks Juliet and Heine with a blast

]

Isn't it convenient that you ignore all of Mirajane's showings because "she was nerfed", and then also ignore all of Erza's showings because "only for the plot". Maybe it's fine just taking the manga at face value. At the end of the day, Hiro Mashima decides "the story". Power levels are part of "the story". If Hiro Mashima wants to portray Mirajane as top tier, he would make Mirajane do stuff like he makes Erza in "the story". We wouldn't be having this conversation because I would be pointing to overpowered stuff that Mirajane does in "the story", instead of arguing with you over why the Mirajane we see is different from the Mirajane you're thinking of.

 

[Animeluver]

You do realize soul extinction and evil explosion are actually just unnamed attacks in the manga, and that the names were tagged on by the previous anime studios right? Like not even the 2018 series that worked on the GMG and Tartarus arc. The first anime run. Hiro Mashima never writes names for Satan Soul's attacks. What we do see is that Mirajane tried to hit them with a huge blast just as impressive as the one that she used on Freed (which again, in the manga is unnamed). Juliet and Heine started attacking her after this blast. If an attack as powerful as any blast Mirajane has ever shown with Satan Soul was tanked, and her opponents started beating her up after tanking it....What makes you think Mirajane would have more success going hand to hand with them?

Spoiler: Mirajane attacks Juliet and Heine with a blast[IMG

]

Because Mirajane is physically strong while Juliet and Heine are not shown to have good hand to hand combat? Oh wait, I forgot that Mira had to flaunt her powerup so I guess she forgot that she was physically strong in her base form.

Erza is portrayed to be stronger because the dumb bitch is Mashima’s favourite. We both know this. We both acknowledge this. That’s why she can overcome disabilities and use a sword with broken bones. Because of favouritism. At least Mira could Macro the bitch to kill herself lol gg.

 

[Axiomus]

Because Mirajane is physically strong while Juliet and Heine are not shown to have good hand to hand combat? Oh wait, I forgot that Mira had to flaunt her powerup so I guess she forgot that she was physically strong in her base form.

Erza is portrayed to be stronger because the dumb bitch is Mashima’s favourite. We both know this. We both acknowledge this. That’s why she can overcome disabilities and use a sword with broken bones. Because of favouritism. At least Mira could Macro the bitch to kill herself lol gg.

Mirajane's blasts are stronger than her hand to hand attacks. Freed could hold his own in hand to hand combat and tank physical blows from Mira, but was taken out by a big blast. Juliet and Heine already tanked the big blast, meaning they have better durability than Freed. They would tank Mirajane's hand to hand attacks too. They could always use their magic even at hand to hand distance. Also, Juliet kicked Mirajane in the face.

Now we all see who the real hater is.

 

[LaGOAT]

Because Mirajane is physically strong while Juliet and Heine are not shown to have good hand to hand combat? Oh wait, I forgot that Mira had to flaunt her powerup so I guess she forgot that she was physically strong in her base form.

Erza is portrayed to be stronger because the dumb bitch is Mashima’s favourite. We both know this. We both acknowledge this. That’s why she can overcome disabilities and use a sword with broken bones. Because of favouritism. At least Mira could Macro the bitch to kill herself lol gg.

Bro satan soul isn’t her strongest form so why do ubeleive satan soul is that powerful name one time Mira won with satan soul except for fried

 

[Animeluver]

Bro satan soul isn’t her strongest form so why do ubeleive satan soul is that powerful name one time Mira won with satan soul except for fried

Against Kamika.

 

[Star Frost]

Because Mirajane is physically strong while Juliet and Heine are not shown to have good hand to hand combat? Oh wait, I forgot that Mira had to flaunt her powerup so I guess she forgot that she was physically strong in her base form.

Erza is portrayed to be stronger because the dumb bitch is Mashima’s favourite. We both know this. We both acknowledge this. That’s why she can overcome disabilities and use a sword with broken bones. Because of favouritism. At least Mira could Macro the bitch to kill herself lol gg.

Or again, Juliet and Heine are actually that strong to hold their own against her in her base form. How can she forget how she is in her own form she used at such who knows how long when she said herself how she underestimated them and acknowledge that they are indeed strong? She unleashed her strongest attack in her base form that they thought was all the best she could do that they tanked and then followed afterwards was owning her. I also noticed too that they didn’t even feel her to be that threatening while in that form like they did when she went Alegria. This moment is just like how Max was holding his own against Natsu after the 7 year timeskip until he used Laxus power.

 

[Seven777]

I'll agree that landing on Acnologia doesn't necessarily make you fast. Acnologia has a habit of just tanking attacks because he's immune to damage by magic. Nonetheless Acnologia is still fast, and he can remain completely untouched by the machine-gun bullets fired from Christina. Tagging Acnologia when he doesn't want to be tagged makes you fast. At least faster than gunfire. Erza's swords were physical attacks. Sure a lot of her swords have magic, but a lot didn't. Satan Soul isn't an untouchable speedster. Mirajane in Satan Soul has been tagged by Freed and Azuma in previous arcs, and by Juliet and Heine in the Alvarez arc. For the purposes of this discussion, Erza dropping all her swords is more than fast enough to tag Mirajane.

Spoiler: Acnologia dodging gunfire

Sure, but later Christina ends up shooting and hitting Acno anyway, and immediately after simply rams and hits Acno. Sure Acno can dodge on occasion, when he chooses to, but its a rare occasion, and he's not necessarily good at it either.

As for Satan Soul not being that fast, I agree, her being tagged by Juliet and Hyne makes that clear, but neither is Erza. Azir can still hit Erza, solo Ikaruga can, Berserkers can. Erza hitting Acnologia doesn't really make me think speed, it just makes me think Acno is being an idiot like usual, if Ikaruga and Azir can react to her attacks, then so can anyone who's decently powerful.

Despite all that stuff at the end of Alvarez, I'm fairly certain Mira and Erza are back on par, the new series seems to be bringing back old power levels. In a normal fight I'd still give Erza the slight edge, but now more than that. Erza's only really super strong when she's using The One magic, which she uses often, but not at will, plus Mira could prob use it too if she was more important.

 

[LaGOAT]

Against Kamika.

Fodder who is probably at Gmg freed lvl at.best Face it satan soul isn’t her strongest takeover

 

[Animeluver]

Fodder who is probably at Gmg freed lvl at.best Face it satan soul isn’t her strongest takeover

Never said it was. When did I say that?

 

[LaGOAT]

Never said it was. When did I say that?

Ya I didn’t u right but satan soul hasn’t impressive ever since the fighting festival arc

 

[Animeluver]

Ya I didn’t u right but satan soul hasn’t impressive ever since the fighting festival arc

Yes, it has. The base form defeated Kamika and was stale mating Seilah at the start of their battle.

 

[LaGOAT]

Yes, it has. The base form defeated Kamika and was stale mating Seilah at the start of their battle.

Kamika was in the same tier as maybe gmg freed not that impressive Juliet and Heine overwhelming her. Satan soul as been that irrelevant against fairly strong opponents hence why she using different takeover

 

[Ronin31]

I don't see any scenarios where Mirajane can beat Erza. Or perhaps people think Mirajane can nuke at least as strong as RL Laxus.
Mirajane is strong but both Laxus and Erza are on a higher level.

 

[FireIce]

Erza comfortably mops the floor with Mirajane any day of the week.

She defeated Misaki and stalemated Laxus, who stomped Skullion and Madmole, and Mirajane can't defeat these guys even with Elfman's help.

The only time Mirajane has been on the same level as Erza was during the GMG, because she recovered to usage of Sitri after the three months of training while Erza hadn't unlocked second origin yet, so her strongest armor still was Armadura Fairy. Sitri and Armadura were apparently equals before the series started.

 

[Shoutmon]

I feel like Mira should be on par with Erza, but from what we've seen, that's not the case.

Erza has better feats and scales higher than Mira does, so she takes this

 

[Ratrace]

I feel like Mira should be on par with Erza, but from what we've seen, that's not the case.

Erza has better feats and scales higher than Mira does, so she takes this

Also like many other characters Mira lacks feats as well

 

[Darklord#10]

I never thought a time would come when Erza will stomp Mira comfortably. But we all know how this fight s going to go if Hiro writes it. It might end in a tie or extreme diff in favor of Erza. Lol you could add gray and gajeel Erza still stomps low diff

 

[Ratrace]

I never thought a time would come when Erza will stomp Mira comfortably. But we all know how this fight s going to go if Hiro writes it. It might end in a tie or extreme diff in favor of Erza. Lol you could add gray and gajeel Erza still stomps low diff

Hiro writes fights closer than they should be