Games MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE ENDGAME!!

[Hakuteiken]

I actually don't remember Charlie having any thing to do with that fact. If you could tell me what posts you are referring to, i could tell you if you are right or wrong.
But as i mentioned, Evil said he had a role before joining the Mason, and he even gave us the order if i am not wrong ... i think that's how we deduced there were some high chances of Evil being the recruiter.

1) Charlie asked me if I was recruited and I confirmed. It was consistent with me saying I had a night role and lost it later on.
2) Evil confirmed my mason status.
3) Gary later said he was also a mason.
4) Charlie revealed he was the mason as last. It looked weird for us masons to completely reveal ourselves and narrow down the search for recruiter. Since me and Gary were almost automatically out of options for the role, only Evil and Charlie was left.
5) Mafia got their hint. We got our doubts about Charlie.

Complete downfall.

 

[xi0]

I actually don't remember Charlie having any thing to do with that fact. I know you guys have been mentioning it for a while, and i even used as an excuse to go for Charlie, but honestly, i don't remember much about that part. If you could tell me what posts you are referring to, i could tell you if you are right or wrong. But as i mentioned, Evil said he had a role before joining the Mason, and he even gave us the order if i am not wrong ... i think that's how we deduced there were some high chances of Evil being the recruiter.

Because he revealed that he was a mason. I believe Evil implied that the Recruiter didn't start out with any masons. This left the Recruiter unknown. But because Charlie admitted he was a Mason and and that he ALSO wasn't a Recruiter, it meant one of us was lying. If he hadn't said anything until much later, some things would have been left in the dark for the Mafia.

That being said, I don't know if it would have kept you guys from picking out Evil. It was a 1 in 4 shot and he looked as the point man, so yeah. But I don't see how Haku or myself implying our previous roles caused more of a problem for us than Charlie staying silent.

---------- Post added at 02:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:28 PM ----------

What Haku said

 

[Evil3ye]

xi0 came out before me though. 2 and 3 are switched.

 

[Mazino]

game was unfair either way just 3 mafia against so many townies

 

[xi0]

game was unfair either way just 3 mafia against so many townies

Blame Pro-player kdowns for that

 

[jorped]

But didn't this all start with the fact i thought Evil and xi0 were somehow connected? I remember having suspicious about those 2, and at that point we didn't know anything about the mason group. So even if Charlie actions ended forcing you guys to reveal more information than what was needed, not like he gave it with no reason, right?

 

[digitaldude]

game was unfair either way just 3 mafia against so many townies

4 mafia and a sleeper plus the mentor, the game just turned out really badly for the mafia, with the vigilante and getting blocked, plus the mentor dying first day.

 

[Evil3ye]

game was unfair either way just 3 mafia against so many townies

Three?! You are forgetting your ingenious head who "always has a reason for being inactive", - which is his role of course! How can nobody get it?!?!

 

[Mazino]

4 mafia and a sleeper plus the mentor, the game just turned out really badly with the mafia, with the vigilante and getting blocked, plus the mentor dying first day.

kdowns doesnt count...sleeper rlly did his job oversleeping the whole game...mentor was bad luck but even he isnt pro mafia so yeah

 

[xi0]

But didn't this all start with the fact i thought Evil and xi0 were somehow connected? I remember having suspicious about those 2, and at that point we didn't know anything,yet, about the mason group. So even if Charlie actions ended forcing you guys to reveal more information than what was needed, not like he gave it with no reason, right?

The first time you pointed it out, I was still a Prostitute. It was just a coincidence. The day we decided to go after lawl was the day after I recruited, so we were only in cahoots then. Though I do believe we shared similar opinions prior to him recruiting me, and I wasn't necessarily suspicious of him either.

 

[Hakuteiken]

But didn't this all start with the fact i thought Evil and xi0 were somehow connected? I remember having suspicious about those 2, and at that point we didn't know anything about the mason group. So even if Charlie actions ended forcing you guys to reveal more information than what was needed, not like he gave it with no reason, right?

That was pretty baseless., I'd say. As far as I could remember, Evil said he didn't suspect Gary for no apparent reason and you all jumped on it, believing they were scheming something.

 

[jorped]

4 mafia and a sleeper plus the mentor, the game just turned out really badly for the mafia, with the vigilante and getting blocked, plus the mentor dying first day.

We have to agree, townies had everything to win this game

 

[Evil3ye]

4 mafia and a sleeper plus the mentor, the game just turned out really badly for the mafia, with the vigilante and getting blocked, plus the mentor dying first day.

Vigilante's pick was the leading person to be lynched, I don't see how that was a problem for them, as then instead a townie was lynched afterwards.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Come on now. 4 host kills. We can easily say it was actually five, since the only reason we hanged Faust was because he was inactive. It was just the Mafia side was playing poorly, not participating. That's what made me think niichan was a Mafia or something, since the other candidates never seemed to show any kind of analytical thinking to provide (except you and you only began taking part when you were forced to by being left alone).

 

[jorped]

That was pretty baseless., I'd say. As far as I could remember, Evil said he didn't suspect Gary for no apparent reason and you all jumped on it, believing they were scheming something.

It wasn't baseless. Evil and xi0 were acting together, supporting each other just too much. It was obvious they had a connection! Ofc they could share the same opinions, but for someone outside, it felt like everything was going according to what they had planned.
It wasn't out of nowhere, but even if it was, it wouldn't nullify the incredibly awesome but lucky move xi0 did on his first night

Vigilante's pick was the leading person to be lynched, I don't see how that was a problem for them, as then instead a townie was lynched afterwards.

Yeah. I have to agree, we didn't mind a bit TheMoa using his role like that. I would even say it was good for us.
But i think what DD means, is the fact .. Mafia being basically 3, and the townies still having a vigilant ... it wasn't just fair to be honest

 

[Evil3ye]

It wasn't baseless. Evil and xi0 were acting together, supporting each other just too much. It was obvious they had a connection! Ofc they could share the same opinions, but for someone outside, it felt like everything was going according to what they had planned.
It wasn't out of nowhere, but even if it was, it wouldn't nullify the incredibly awesome but lucky move xi0 did on his first night

And here you are wrong, because when we both jumped on Lawlett we did not have a night before to plan this all out, as xi0 was just recruited.

 

[jorped]

And here you are wrong, because when we both jumped on Lawlett we did not have a night before to plan this all out, as xi0 was just recruited.

Ok, but it seemed like you had team up. You knew both of you were townies, am i right? It seemed like it was premeditated, but obviously as you mentioned now that wasn't the case. Still you were ganging up on my fellow, and honestly it seemed as something rather suspicious for me. It seemed that to the very least you had some connection.

 

[Evil3ye]

And this is why there was no reason to be hiding anymore. A certain someone should have stayed in the background though.

 

[jorped]

I still have to understand why on earth did Faust use his role on xi0. Unless he bought my theory of you guys being suspicious? I don't see any other valid reason for him to do that.

 

[Evil3ye]

He wanted to protect him obviously. Since he was saving people/being blocked, he didn't know about his insanity.