Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.7

[Nast.J]

yeah actually, then i'd ask someone to take kdown's role too

There's no point in that, we've already discovered if kdown was a townie/mafia.

The best course of action would be to just put someone else who didn't play the game to take Kat's place. Imo Faust should, he's followed the game since the beggining.

 

[Hardy]

Yeah but Faust is banned. It's either someone who was out since the start but kinda watched the game a bit (Nuno I'm looking at you) or no one.

 

[xi0]

There's no point in that, we've already discovered if kdown was a townie/mafia.

The best course of action would be to just put someone else who didn't play the game to take Kat's place. Imo Faust should, he's followed the game since the beggining.

I still think that's a bad idea. You sign up and start from the same point everyone else does. Faust wasn't involved in the first day and because of that, he could neither get a foothold or a place in the game, nor has he had to absolve himself of any missteps.

---------- Post added at 11:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:10 AM ----------

Yeah but Faust is banned. It's either someone who was out since the start but kinda watched the game a bit (Nuno I'm looking at you) or no one.

No, Nuno knows some of the mafia.

 

[Hardy]

No, Nuno knows some of the mafia.

...

If I was playing I'd...

lol

 

[Darjaille]

Yeah but Faust is banned. It's either someone who was out since the start but kinda watched the game a bit (Nuno I'm looking at you) or no one.

Nuno is not viable.

 

[xi0]

...

If I was playing I'd...

lol

What? It's a common occurrence, even with people eliminated. I'd be surprised if you didn't know them. I usually take a stab at it when I'm killed.

 

[Hardy]

... I'm gonna shut up.

 

[Kat]

Okay Okay ... It's fine I simply won't play the next game. It was just a suggestion. I'm able to play until tomorrow 6am. So I will give you a vote tomorrow cause I hope night will be ended. You will get later why I wanted that. So leave it like it was before this.

 

[kdowns]

Whewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww Yay for puking my guts out and not really being able to do anything xD

 

[Faust]

I'm willing to take over Kat's role!

---------- Post added at 11:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:48 PM ----------

Oh yeah I'm banned!
Hostkill is a better decision then.

 

[Naomi]

Whoa, I didn't really see that one coming. XD Overall, I think I agree with the general consensus that Hardy should not take the role. If Kat can't play the game, it's a shame. But it's not someone else's job to cover her ass. She doesn't deserve special treatment. It's either she finds the time to play the game she committed to play or gets hostkilled like KD.

 

[Nuno]

So I want to ask all of you if it's okay that Hardy takes over Kat's role? She has to leave for a trip and won't return from friday to monday so this is the only possible choice left besides hostkilling her. I'm not a big fan of the method but it's a possible option and I want to hear your thoughts. If that is okay with all of you, he will inherit her ava and her role and start playing in her stead (he will play until the game ends, no matter if it's still ongoing when she returns).

I will only agree to it if none of you have a problem with that but keep in mind that I will have to hostkill her otherwise. I'm fine with whatever you lot decide, it's up to you if you prefer her getting hostkilled or if Hardy takes over.

Please write your answer here or send me a PM.

Let me play



---------- Post added at 06:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:24 PM ----------

I voted in the poll for luls. I have nothing against Faust in terms of hosting, if he thinks he has what it takes. That being said I probably won't even play so it's kind of douchebag of me to vote. But I agree with Evil that we have the host coverage we need now. However both DD and niichan might want to play, so yeah.

 

[wizzard]

I don't mind playing 2 roles in the same time xD

 

[digitaldude]

hardy is not taking kat's role.

 

[Kat]

Hey I already told you its fine just let it be... there is no need to discuss about it anymore.. Im gonna play maybe I will find wifi in Paris (dont really want to spend my time on the internet there but wtv)

 

[Nast.J]

Hey I already told you its fine just let it be... there is no need to discuss about it anymore.. Im gonna play maybe I will find wifi in Paris (dont really want to spend my time on the internet there but wtv)

, you should just spend the night to play mafia when you have nothing else to do and enjoy Paris during the day!

 

[Kat]

, you should just spend the night to play mafia when you have nothing else to do and enjoy Paris during the day!

I will see what I will be able to do with that mafia game but Thank youuu ~

 

[wizzard]

When did niichan said he's coming back? turns out I'll be going to Bukuresht this Saturday ^^ wanna figure out do I need to bring a laptop or can I get through without it

 

[Kaoz]

Hostkilling for inactivity is a pretty retarded practice and something that should only be done if there's really no other option. After all you're not only punishing the person you kill, but their entire team as well (it's not like it's their fault), and it influences and at times even decides the game. It's not like it's difficult to avoid either, just plan ahead a bit and don't have everyone who signs up start, keep two or three people back as subs and then hostsub instead of hostkill.

Someone said something about subbing not working because it's a different person or something iirc (only skimmed the last couple pages), but that's not really true. While there is some change, the interactions of the first player are still there, they don't just disappear when they sub out. It's not an optimal situation of course, but a hell of a lot better than deciding the game right there.

As for dead players subbing, it can work if they died early and didn't have interactions with anyone outside the game thread. Wouldn't recommended it over dedicated subs though.

Oh and @some other comment I vaguely remember, just because you didn't do it until now doesn't mean you have to continue not doing it, given that it improves the game as a whole.

 

[jorped]

Is this the scene where the hero makes his appearance?

Spoiler

HEE HAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

I haven't read anything at all apart from some posts here and there, but if it's extremely need for someone to take Kat's role i wouldn't mind doing so.
I think i will have some time during this weekend, even though i am finally going home after a couple of months without doing so. Don't expect much though, since i will prolly end having to read almost everything i can, and i have other stuff to do as well. But it's definitely better than hostkilling. So in case Niichan finds this viable, he should pm me and tell me so, cuz i might forget to check this place.