Movie One Piece Live Action

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
Season 2 EpisodesRatingLikesDislikesAdditional Comments
1: "The Beginning and the End"/10
2: "Good Whale Hunting/10
3: "Whisky Business"/10
4: "Big Trouble in Little Garden"/10
5: "Wax On, Wax Off"/10
6: "Nami Deerest"/10
7: "Reindeer Shames"/10
8: "Deer and Loathing in Drum Kingdom"/10
Overall rating
 
Last edited:

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,513
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's a lot better than I expected thus far. One of my only gripes is with the writing and something that is just in the nature of being a live action - some of the dialogue seems poorly written when acted out. I think this is more in the nature of how manga dialogue translates to live action in general. Second gripe would be the whole emphasis on Luffy insisting everyone is already in his crew; I quite enjoyed the way he basically gave Zoro no choice to join and Zoro accepted that in the manga (I help you live and you join me). The overused joke of "you're now my crew member" was a little cringey for me. Not a big deal. Was also surprised by Helmeppo's butt, and that one Zoro scene. Lol

I'm only a single ep in though and I'd give it an 8/10.
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
LA Sanji and Zoro are x100000 more likeable to me than their canon counterparts

Zoro initiating a secret-spilling drinking game as this stoic alcoholic, the sheer love Taz put into learning about kitchen life. Hot dang.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---



Given the source material, I think Luffy's child actor was about as good as we can possibly hope for.
--- Double Post Merged, ---



Some of y'all know how bitterly nitpicky I can be. When
We Are started playing when they got the Merry
I was literally doing the Neverending Story "YAHHHHH" fist pump and cheering at like 6 in the morning
I also had my doubts, I'm literally watching brago watch it right now.
 

Lord Rayleigh

Intl Translator
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
3,133
Reaction score
4,269
Gender
Male
Country
France
They kept calling him "Chore Boy" at Baratie. I like it. This feels like a Rough Tale = Laugh Tale joke with Joy Boy this time.
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
I donno what I was smoking giving that first episode 6.5, and y'all let me doing it too :notlikethis
 

Pirate Queen

Registered User
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
9,676
Reaction score
17,731
Country
United States
So edgy to hate on people that enjoy One Piece in different mediums 😒
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
I donno what I was smoking giving that first episode 6.5, and y'all let me doing it too :notlikethis
I was gonna say something about that, lol. That's one of the best adaptations of something like this you can get for an introductory episode. It's so ridiculously economical- it's paced just right to not feel too rushed or skimping on details.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

So edgy to hate on people that enjoy One Piece in different mediums 😒
If it was actually bad, I'd at least be baffled anyone was enjoying it- looking at you, LA Bleach.

This ain't bad at all though.
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
I was gonna say something about that, lol. That's one of the best adaptations of something like this you can get for an introductory episode. It's so ridiculously economical- it's paced just right to not feel too rushed or skimping on details.
You should called out my foolishness sooner, I now must send a written letter of apology to Oda-sensei and the guys from OPLA.
 

Riku

Dirty Blonde
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Nov 24, 2007
Messages
3,735
Reaction score
17,766
Country
Torumekian Empire
Just finished. Too tired to proper write, but it was great! Loved the characters and cast. Liked the Garp story more than I thought. I didn't like some changes they made, but mostly I think they did great with what they changed. Like there was clear reason why and they made it work. There where also times when the script felt too forced, but usually you do really need to spell out things when making a blockbuster script.

Solid 8.

Now on to the Grand Line! Nice little teaser there.

I hope this does well. Bit disappointed I didn't see it in the Netflix top 10 after quitting, but I guess not everyone's gonna binge it on a week day, and the statistics update with delay always.
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
Just finished. Too tired to proper write, but it was great! Loved the characters and cast. Liked the Garp story more than I thought. I didn't like some changes they made, but mostly I think they did great with what they changed. Like there was clear reason why and they made it work. There where also times when the script felt too forced, but usually you do really need to spell out things when making a blockbuster script.

Solid 8.

Now on to the Grand Line! Nice little teaser there.

I hope this does well. Bit disappointed I didn't see it in the Netflix top 10 after quitting, but I guess not everyone's gonna binge it on a week day, and the statistics update with delay always.
Glad you enjoyed it king!
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Think i've watched episode 1 like 3 times now
 

Riku

Dirty Blonde
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Nov 24, 2007
Messages
3,735
Reaction score
17,766
Country
Torumekian Empire
Glad you enjoyed it king!
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Think i've watched episode 1 like 3 times now
I'm gonna watch it with my partner again tomorrow and then with the Japanese dub on Saturday :nod
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
So my partner drunkenly suggested watching the live action as a compromise because she refuses to start something as long as One Piece under normal circumstances. I've never seen a monkey's paw curl harder than this, because now she absolutely will be watching One Piece when she assumed (rightfully) it'd be bad enough that I would cancel watching it.

On the bright side she does get front row viewing of me being childishly gleeful about something for once.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Buggy being Caesar'd/Caribou'd for the latter part of East Blue is so incredibly appropriate
--- Double Post Merged, ---

Coby as a liberal being radicalized leftward is so damn good

Helmeppo's hair having an origin story to rival Gwen's in Spider-verse is so damn good

Also:
OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMGO OMG ZEFF AND GARP DINNER DATE
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
Arlong was spitting some truth in the OPLA Jesus
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
Arlong was spitting some truth in the OPLA Jesus
TRUTH. The Jinbei name drop was just enough to give some extra spice

Also:

I'm about to get to "Luffy, help me!"

Preparing angel-tear decanters
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Hmmm no "WHICH ONE OF YOU IS ARLONG!?"

-1

Wait that was a Vilhelm Scream

+1
 

Rein Avara

aka Ēsu Taichou
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
3,226
Reaction score
6,476
Gender
Male
Country
Avatar
TRUTH. The Jinbei name drop was just enough to give some extra spice

Also:

I'm about to get to "Luffy, help me!"

Preparing angel-tear decanters
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Hmmm no "WHICH ONE OF YOU IS ARLONG!?"

-1

Wait that was a Vilhelm Scream

+1
Last two episodes are damn beautiful, I will rewatch again tomorrow
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Reading this thread is interesting. We have diverse of opinions. We like and dislike different things. Like I thought ep 3 is stronger than ep 4, due to the crew dynamics. And I thought the ep is pretty hilarious.
 

Pirate Queen

Registered User
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
9,676
Reaction score
17,731
Country
United States
Mihawk camping Eastblue Pirates in live action.... bro can't escape the fraud watch allegations in ANY One Piece media format

But Garp calling the 2nd strongest Warlord to hunt down Luffy was pretty awesome
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Some mix feelings on episode 5, I gonna give it an 8/10 Great...

I do like Sanji's introduction and the Baratie's atmosphere. I had hope that Zeff didn't threw food away. But in the show, he kinda did because Luffy ate it. Though I vaguely remember the same thing happen in the manga but i thought one of their core value is not wasting food. Need to reread this.

Mihawk's intro is great. The fight scene that he introduced in is very fun but but but but. It does diminished some of his characterization. He is one of the least obedience among the warlords. Maybe, you can said because it is a request from Garp. But still he isn't supposed to be a good lap dog. This also caused some problems as well. In the manga, he kinda accidentally stumble upon the strawhats while hunting down Krieg. Here he is in a random place, and then have to hunt down Luffy in an entire ocean. And somehow manage to get into the right bar.

Mihawk here has a lot of sass. It does work in the live action. However, I rather he is more stoic and talk less. And when he does talk, it just epic lines. That is a tad hard to translate. So what they did is acceptable.

Zoro's flashback from last ep is pretty good. And it does set up pretty nicely for the confrontation. The fight is as good as it can be. Except the attack at the end lol, it doesn't translate all that welll. But it was short enough for me to buy into it without overthinking it. Zoro's emotional moments is a tad of a mix bag. I guess you can consider it as well done. And it feel almost 1 to 1 translation from the manga. However, because of that, it doesn't feel as natural. I wish Mackenyu intepret it as his own, rather than a duplication. A lesser duplication since it lack that crazy snot crying that infamous for One Piece.

Zoro-Nami's drinking game is pretty good. Usopp lack the cowardice trait in the last episode. But the show continue to be excellence with his bullshit trait. Luffy-Sanji dynamic is pretty good. Though at one point the group had a forced group laugh. This is the second time, where I don't feel very natural. These scenes would be good for some improv acting. Where the actor by their own natural personality and comedy making each other laugh. I like that more. Than rehearsed lines.

Garp's stuffs in the beginning was fine. He throwing the cannon ball was cool. I still feel it some what jarring. But consider he serving the role of Johnny and Yosaku and push the strawhats to the next location. Then it is a well adapted giving the resources.

The lack of audience does make the Mihawk v Zoro a bit less impressive. But for what it is still super impressive. Mihawk's sword like Kuro's claws. Are less bad here compare to the trailer. But still look kinda cheap. Mostly due to the anime aestic. Same with Fullbody's wig. However as time gone by, my brain may trained to take these as more believable and come with the territory.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


Normie's review..
 

wing_gundam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
1,276
Reaction score
875
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Only watched ep 1 so far. Mildly entertained. More so than I though. I enjoyed the real world feel in a lot of settings. Hellempo naked scene was just chef's kiss. So far he nailed the acting more than Luffy's actor (who's too serious and delivers his lines too slow imo).

The only thing griping me is the hair. Like it just looks so dyed. Idk what I was expecting.

Garp's accent though...

The CGI isn't horrible. As I said mildly entertained. Much much better than any other LA anime out there (though Ashoka is doing pretty well - but that has a much lower bar to hit - no crazy 'powers' and they have a precedent clearly)
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Episode 6, I really want to give this an excellence score of 9 but I do wonder if it deserve it. So for now, 8.75 at the high end of Great. And even then I wonder if I am super bias.



Continue to love the additional stuffs that the show did. Because it is new. And this episode, give me things that keep me entertain and temporary forget what was left out. First thing, the Garp stuffs start to get annoying. They better had some great pay off.



I had some misgiving about Zeff’s mustaches at first. But by the end, I really really like this actor. The additional scene of him fixing up Zoro and taught us some new about the old sailor’s stuff with the fish skins. His flashback with Sanji. To a lesser extend his dealing with Arlong, and goodbye to Sanji. The Baratie staff became a victim when time cut down. Like I said an additional 10 minutes could help. A montage of Luffy working there for a week. And how the staffs interact with each others. They went from being colorful to just literal background. In the manga, they were also used for power scale. Patty first was super impressive. Then, Iron Fist is a step up, then Pearl, the Gin/Sanji, then Krieg, and Mihawk just blew everyone out of the water. But yeah, cutting these folks down. Making Baratie less of a stake, making Sanji’s good bye much much less than what it was in the anime.



Which that being said, I did get a tad teary with Sanji’s flashback and goodbye. Because at the end of the day, the core that is the shared dream between Zeff and Sanji. Sanji’s child actor isn’t like the best but he was good enough. So for Usopp child actor is the worst but that flashback was non existence in the first place. Zoro child actor is the best. Then Luffy/Sanji child actor. They did conveyed the harshness of the shipwreck and being stranded as best as they could. It was great but it can’t beat the manga. You can’t starve the physical actors (though they really tried in Les Miserable), that would be child abuse. They did their best with the make up. In the manga, Sanji was sunken. Boney, and his eyes were death. Like what you see of pics of the holocaust. Maybe western audience can buy this. Harry Potter actor to me was too fat, since I came from a country with starving beggar kids all over the street. I know what abused and starved kid look like. With that being, great flashback.



Baratie is the first arc where Oda tried to do these competing groups (the marines, the cooks, the strawhats, Mihawk, Krieg pirates). We sort of not really have it here in the show. We removed the Krieg pirates in general. Instead we got way more crew dynamics and the Arlong pirates.



The theme of what is a captain got played up here, way way before Water 7. Nami in conflict with Luffy. Nami really care about Zoro. And her betrayal here, I thought was pretty great. Especially last arc really played up with her views on friendship. Luffy starting from being cheery, to losing his smile as the episode goes on. And with Luffy and Zoro’s scene at the end. Though I would have like to here “I will be with you always, till the end.” Or something. The way he hugged Zoro, I really felt it. Usopp continued to be a 4th wheel here. Though we finally see him being a coward.



Arlong and crews. Oh boy, really great. Chew looks awesome. Same as Kuroobi. The Sanji vs Kuroobi and Arlong vs Luffy were great. This is the part in a movie where the protagonists are down and returned triumphantly at the end. It does feel like a cohesive season with this change. The fishmen are menacing enough despite the whole “height” thing. Some of the ideologies at play here.



This is what I want from an adaption. Give me things that won’t make me miss what not on the plate. Wonderful episode.

Edit: They fixed my Mihawk issue from ep 5 here. Which is great.
 
Last edited:

Organizized

Pirate King in the North
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Scavenger Hunter Supreme
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
4,334
Reaction score
22,333
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Little disappointed I can't select Japanese dub on my Netflix... was planning on rewatching it in Japanese when I'm done.

Anyway, only managed to squeeze in two episodes yesterday, now I've slept on it and here's my first impressions on ep 1 and 2.

Episode 1: Romance Dawn - 7/10
Episode 2: The Man in the Straw Hat - 8/10

Liked

• The opening was very cool. Ian McShane as the Narrator was a great casting choice, and the little scene between Garp and Roger before the execution really added to the build-up to his "exclamation".
• The Straw Hats casting! So great!
• The visuals! The sets! The Easter eggs! It all just looks really good.
• Koby is great in this. Obviously they had to tone his whininess down and it worked well.
• Helmeppo's actor was perfect in his role; really, really punchable throughout.
• Jeff Ward's Buggy is probably the best part of these two first episodes. They took the "flashy" part of him and turned it up to 11. Loved him, and the way they turned his "taking over the town" into a circus with the townsfolk as chained up audience was very clever.
• The fight scenes are really well choreographed and directed.

Disliked
• Splitting Luffy's "flashback" into so many little parts over two episodes kinda caused the big moments of it (Shanks losing his arm + Shanks putting the hat on Luffy) to hit less, I think. Also I was *really* missing the "put your life on the line" quote...
• Garp being so damn serious all the time. Yeah, I get he's supposed to be this "looming threat" coming after Luffy but... idk, this is the manga reader brain talking but he's just not "Garp" enough.

Neutral
• It's fun, but not really funny (barring some Buggy moments). Some moments are touching, but not nearly making me cry. I know those big scenes are yet to come, but so far the pacing is a bit too choppy and rush in places so that the progression of bonds between characters feel a little sudden/unnatural, so the emotional moments might keep missing the mark a bit. Prove me wrong, show!
• Also, I feel like the decision to make Garp this kind of big presence in the main storyline this early might lead to me having bigger issues as we go on. Again, prove me wrong, show!
 
Top