- Joined
- Jul 4, 2006
- Messages
- 4,316
- Reaction score
- 830
- Gender
- Male
- Country
1st of all just my oppinionsushi said:uh yea whose garp's wife nyway
2nd garp's wife another mystery
3rd there is not much to discuss about Luffy's mother.
1st of all just my oppinionsushi said:uh yea whose garp's wife nyway
lolLiqiud said:Eh ...My theory got ignored
LOLmovingstone said:Your is pretty much the same as other plus little twist and anyway don't take it too personaly (newbie are ussually ignore= sad but proved to be truth 75% of all times by the great mind of movingstone (accually i made that up))
... aw dude....sushi said:guys ...is it true that newbie is ignored???
ok, its a nice theory but unfortunatly im gonna have to shoot it down. Gol D. was executed 22 years ago. Luffy is only 17. so its kinda impossible for it to play out exactly as you said. it was a cool idea thoughLiqiud said:Eheh, My theory is that Luffy's mother was the daughter of Gol D. Roger. She married Dragon had Luffy and was most likely kidnapped by the WG to force Gol togive himself up. Garp probably disagreed with this but had to follow orders. Roger and him most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in and be executed while Garp would attempt save his daughter from the WG, who would of coarse kill her after she had outlived her usefulness. Garp didn't make it in time to save her. Dragon found out from his father and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.
Maybe, then his theory is truthsushi said:maybe cousins you know or even twin???
Maybe, it could be truthBunyaminRoy said:Guys, how about Luffy's mum is Gol d Roger's sister..?!! Can Liqiud's theory be use..?!!
LOLBoffenJL said:lol
LOL
... aw dude....
hmmmm, revised theory: Luffy's mother was the younger sister or daughter of Gol D. Roger. She fell in love, married, did all that good stuff with Dragon. Gol had everything in the world and had lived a long, good, life; the only thing left to obtain/explore was death. Roger and Garp most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in; Garp would get the credit for his capture. Luffy's mother was captured by the Navy about 5 or 6 years after Gol's death (long enough to have both Ace and Luffy) for association with the Pirate King. Dragon tried to save her, she was killed during the scuffle. Dragon escaped and/or killed the Naval officers, asked Garp to raise Ace and Luffy, and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.BunyaminRoy said:Guys, how about Luffy's mum is Gol d Roger's sister..?!! Can Liqiud's theory be use..?!!
Wait...What!?! Both Ace and Luffy look a hell of a lot like Roger (Black hair, similar features, similar color choices, smiling ALOT) and numerous characters (that bartender guy in Loguetown; Dr. Kureha; Gan Fall; Kokoro) have all said that Luffy acted just like Gol...movingstone said:But I gonna shoot it down anyway. GR look nothing like Luffy, Act nothing like luffy. Luffy could be a long distant relative of GR but not a close one. so, Luffy just so much better than GR that why he cannot be a close relative and anyway, I wonder why Dragon is Luffy's father he so cerious (serious). Maybe Dragon adopted Luffy? but anyway I must say Luffy's mother must be hell of a woman.
I knew people will react that way to my post. I trying to be extreme, anyway I hate the idea that Gold Roger is a relative of Luffy. Act like luffy = meaning his ambition and determination = that's it = plus smile before dying = and nothing else.Liqiud said:Wait...What!?! Both Ace and Luffy look a hell of a lot like Roger (Black hair, similar features, similar color choices, smiling ALOT) and numerous characters (that bartender guy in Loguetown; Dr. Kureha; Gan Fall; Kokoro) have all said that Luffy acted just like Gol...
this theory i like! i cant find anything that directly contradicts it. and it still has what i hope will be there for the story between Dragon and Luffys mom, the love vendetta. she gets captured just BECAUSE she is the daughter of roger. just like Tom was got executed because he built Rogers ship. nice one Liquid!Liqiud said:hmmmm, revised theory: Luffy's mother was the younger sister or daughter of Gol D. Roger. She fell in love, married, did all that good stuff with Dragon. Gol had everything in the world and had lived a long, good, life; the only thing left to obtain/explore was death. Roger and Garp most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in; Garp would get the credit for his capture. Luffy's mother was captured by the Navy about 5 or 6 years after Gol's death (long enough to have both Ace and Luffy) for association with the Pirate King. Dragon tried to save her, she was killed during the scuffle. Dragon escaped and/or killed the Naval officers, asked Garp to raise Ace and Luffy, and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.
Oh no, when i typed my other post, I expected alot of people to agrue me, you know. (because there is alot of loop holes on what I said - I do realize that and i did that on purpose )Liqiud said:On a side note: I am not 'people'
BoffenJL said:this theory i like! i cant find anything that directly contradicts it. and it still has what i hope will be there for the story between Dragon and Luffys mom, the love vendetta. she gets captured just BECAUSE she is the daughter of roger. just like Tom was got executed because he built Rogers ship. nice one Liquid!
Eheh, I knew that, I'm just a smartass O.omovingstone said:Oh no, when i typed my other post, I expected alot of people to agrue me, you know. (because there is alot of loop holes on what I said - I do realize that and i did that on purpose )
His original title for the One Piece concept was 'Romance Dawn'movingstone said:Anyway. The romantic just not Oda's style (but since I am not him = I dun even know what is Oda's style) and Gold Roger being Luffy's relative (this too common on a lot of manga) so just hoping it isn't that way.
All the D's act the pretty much the same. Dragon prolly does too, if Luffy's mom was a D.(my theory ) she probably acted like that too; we've only seen the mean pictures of Dragon so far...plus I'm pretty sure he smiled alot in Loguetown, just the sinister type, like Gol..movingstone said:But hey, anybody find somewhat of a resemblence between Luffy and Dragon (Luffy is mixture between his dad and mom so if his personality not like his dad, then his personality should be like his mom, same with how he act and think and look).
you're not bluffing, are you??Liqiud said:
His original title for the One Piece concept was 'Romance Dawn'
That was my opinion that I claimed solved the mistery incase you ddin't read it. Sorry, I was being a smartass againLiqiud said:hmmmm, revised theory: Luffy's mother was the younger sister or daughter of Gol D. Roger. She fell in love, married, did all that good stuff with Dragon. Gol had everything in the world and had lived a long, good, life; the only thing left to obtain/explore was death. Roger and Garp most likely met up and made a deal: Roger would turn himself in; Garp would get the credit for his capture. Luffy's mother was captured by the Navy about 5 or 6 years after Gol's death (long enough to have both Ace and Luffy) for association with the Pirate King. Dragon tried to save her, she was killed during the scuffle. Dragon escaped and/or killed the Naval officers, asked Garp to raise Ace and Luffy, and set out to destroy the WG, having a vendetta, a cause, and a reason to topple the WG.