Discussion The Official Lucy Heartfilia Thread

Your favourite Celestial Star Dress

  • Aquarius

    Votes: 14 19.4%
  • Leo

    Votes: 12 16.7%
  • Sagitarius

    Votes: 9 12.5%
  • Aries

    Votes: 2 2.8%
  • Gemini

    Votes: 6 8.3%
  • Scorpio

    Votes: 10 13.9%
  • Virgo

    Votes: 4 5.6%
  • Taurus

    Votes: 2 2.8%
  • Cancer

    Votes: 8 11.1%
  • Capricorn

    Votes: 5 6.9%

  • Total voters
    72

Gabo

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2015
Messages
1,111
Reaction score
2,111
Age
44
Gender
Male
Country
Mexico
I love Lucy's character.

It may not be the strongest, but in spite of everything, she grew up a lot.

The Stardress I really like, I really find it a bit difficult to decide which one I like the most.

I want to see the Capricorn Suit.

I would like to see the CSK, I imagine that Lucy will have to make some sacrifice to use it and that is why she has not used it yet.
 

GamerSkull

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2016
Messages
790
Reaction score
1,854
Age
31
Country
United States
I love Lucy's character.

It may not be the strongest, but in spite of everything, she grew up a lot.

The Stardress I really like, I really find it a bit difficult to decide which one I like the most.

I want to see the Capricorn Suit.

I would like to see the CSK, I imagine that Lucy will have to make some sacrifice to use it and that is why she has not used it yet.
My favorite star dresses include the Scorpio one (I really love the design, especially the headband thing) and the Sagittarius one (I really like the idea of Lucy being an archer).
 
Last edited:

GamerSkull

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2016
Messages
790
Reaction score
1,854
Age
31
Country
United States
I'm honestly thinking that Lucy will be the one to end up re-writing the book of END and will either stop Natsu's life from being linked to anyone else or will tether his life to herself so he's alive as long as she is alive.

Given that's she has an ambition for writing, it would make sense for her character.
 

Gabo

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2015
Messages
1,111
Reaction score
2,111
Age
44
Gender
Male
Country
Mexico
Lucy is just perfect as she is, I love being so human and not an all-powerful World Breaker.

She likes me precisely because of her human traits, because she is not a Mary Sue, she has palpable defects, she even tries to overcome them and she is always there to help them no matter how difficult the situation is or how dangerous the enemy is.

The truth is that she is a charming character and makes her wish she has a Happy Ending
 

DemonKing888

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,202
Reaction score
1,152
Age
38
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I'm honestly thinking that Lucy will be the one to end up re-writing the book of END and will either stop Natsu's life from being linked to anyone else or will tether his life to herself so he's alive as long as she is alive.

Given that's she has an ambition for writing, it would make sense for her character.
That would be amazing, and such a beautiful ending if Natsus life force got linked to Lucy and the book Lucy is writing replaces the book of END.
 

Cosmicstar

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2013
Messages
1,289
Reaction score
1,797
Age
31
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
I am just waiting here for another battle involving Lucy.

I wish she would summon Crux to utilize Stellar Memory to learn more about Anna plan to defeat Acnologia. Not only that but more about how the keys were creates, The first Celestial Wizard and Anna relationship with Acnologia. I doubt Anna went through with this plan without having history with Acnologia.

I also want to know why Layla didn't take the children from the gates to the Heartfilla residence given how huge and rich they were. She would have had to see them come out the gate and then proceed to close the gate.
 

Kiki

MIRAXUS FOREVER
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2015
Messages
9,668
Reaction score
31,968
Age
33
Gender
Male
Country
Fairy Tail
The whole Anna, Layla, Lucy, Eclipse, Dragon Slayers, etc caught my interest...
  • Are clans a thing in FT universe?
  • Does the Heartfilia own all the golden keys? If so, why did they spread them instead of keeping them safe? Or were they spread by an accident?
  • Why did Layla keep this from Lucy instead of telling her the truth? Why did the Celestial Spirits not tell Lucy the memories of the stars before?
  • Who picked/separated the 5 DSs? (Natsu to FT, Gajeel to Phantom Lord, Wendy to Cait Shelter, Sting and Rogue to Sabertooth)
 

GamerSkull

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2016
Messages
790
Reaction score
1,854
Age
31
Country
United States
It's possible Layla may have also done something to the dragonslayers upon their arrival in x777. If clans did exist, it seems that the Dragneels and the Heartfilia clans were on amicable terms...

I'm curious to see if there will be any backstory on Zeref's relations with the Heartfilia family... or if that backstory will be relegated to the dragonslayers instead.
 
Last edited:

Crescent Jinx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2016
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
15,385
Gender
Female
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
Still not given up on my theory I posted (not sure if posted it on here but did on ftbase)

Star dress Chapters:
418-428: Virgo (and Leo)
428-438: Taurus
438-448:Sagittarius
448-458: Ares
458-468: Aquarius
468-478: Leo (and Taurus)
478-488: Gemini
....U1
488-508: Cancer and Scorpio (with Aquarius/Taurus)
508-528: ??? (Predict: Libra and Pisces)
528-538: ??? (Predict: Capricorn)
---------------
120 chapters of the 12 zodiac
_________
538-548: 13th key

Virgo - Lucy
Taurus - Natsu
Sagittarius - Makarov
Ares - Mavis or Erza
Aquarius - Brandish
Leo - Laxus
Gemini - Chelia and Wendy
Scorpio - Gajeel
Cancer - Gray

Larcade and Mavis are Pisces.
Irene/Erza is Libra.

...so these two spirits or star dresses need to be used between 508-528

Capricorn is August (or Zeref).

So Lucy's star dress need be use between 528-538.

13th key... black key is Acnologia or Zeref.



if Mashima adds it.... would be between 538-548.
 
Last edited:

Gabo

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2015
Messages
1,111
Reaction score
2,111
Age
44
Gender
Male
Country
Mexico
While Lucy has been able to show off a bit in this saga, her moment of glory will come when something really bad affects everyone, remember that in Tartaros and GMG she shines in the most vital moments.

I think Lucy will shine when the issue of END is presented and maybe for the moment the fact that she is warming up Natsu, serves to prevent END temporarily awakening or maybe it is she who is responsible for END does not unleash their power full
 

Cat Sidhe26

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
16,204
Gender
Female
Country
United States
Still not given up on my theory I posted (not sure if posted it on here but did on ftbase)

Star dress Chapters:
418-428: Virgo (and Leo)
428-438: Taurus
438-448:Sagittarius
448-458: Ares
458-468: Aquarius
468-478: Leo (and Taurus)
478-488: Gemini
....U1
488-508: Cancer and Scorpio (with Aquarius/Taurus)
508-528: ??? (Predict: Libra and Pisces)
528-538: ??? (Predict: Capricorn)
---------------
120 chapters of the 12 zodiac
_________
538-548: 13th key

Virgo - Lucy
Taurus - Natsu
Sagittarius - Makarov
Ares - Mavis or Erza
Aquarius - Brandish
Leo - Laxus
Gemini - Chelia and Wendy
Scorpio - Gajeel
Cancer - Gray

Larcade and Mavis are Pisces.
Irene/Erza is Libra.

...so these two spirits or star dresses need to be used between 508-528

Capricorn is August (or Zeref).

So Lucy's star dress need be use between 528-538.

13th key... black key is Acnologia or Zeref.



if Mashima adds it.... would be between 538-548.
Larcade and Mavis really do fit Pisces since Pisces are a mother and son like Mavis and Larcade are. Through that would mean we will go back to the Larcade subplot after chapter 520. Also Larcade would be a good way to resolve the Fairy Heart subplot which should be resolve before the Zeref fight. Irene and Erza are a good fit to Libra seeing they both balance each other out. Also for the Pisces, Libra, and Ophiuchus keys to be used Yukino has to use them in a fight since Pisces, Libra, and Ophiuchus keys belong to Yukino. So I guess this means Yukino and Sorano will get a fight against Ajeel or Jacob when the Universe One dispels which will allow Sorano to redeem herself and be able to give Yukino a hug.
 
Last edited:

Crescent Jinx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2016
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
15,385
Gender
Female
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
Larcade and Mavis really do fit Pisces since Pisces are a mother and son like Mavis and Larcade are. Through that would mean we will go back to the Larcade subplot after chapter 520. Also Larcade would be a good way to resolve the Fairy Heart subplot which should be resolve before the Zeref fight. Irene and Erza are a good fit to Libra seeing they both balance each other out. Also for the Pisces, Libra, and Ophiuchus keys to be used Yukino has to use them in a fight since Pisces, Libra, and Ophiuchus keys belong to Yukino. So I guess this means Yukino and Sorano will get a fight against Ajeel or Jacob when the Universe One dispels which will allow Sorano to redeem herself and be able to give Yukino a hug.
That's what I think too. Especially since Mashima has this sister subplot and literally has not done anything with it. On top of that. Yukino hasn't summoned a spirit since Avatar to make Sting skinny.

And the Larcade subplot got introduced without being explained. Since Yukino and sorano are with him, it might remind Mashima to move back to both subplots after we have some END drama.

And really it's just too obvious that Capricorn's star dress would be next to be used.

I can't wait to see how Lucy will be shown/used in this arc. I hope Mashima will giver her the importance she deserves.
As a fan, I also want the return of Virgo and Ares star dresses. All the other star dresses bar, The one that hasn't been shown yet, were used in battle moments with names attacks.
Lucy's Virgo star dress didn't get to show spica hole or spica lock. Nor did we actually see the digging magic when she tunneled into Avatar. Also Ares not only has her wool bomb but she can combo make a wool typhoon with Taurus. And a sand-wool typhoon with Taurus and Scorpio.

I want a battle of Lucy, CSK, Brandish, 12 zodiac, Yukino, Sorano vs someone. If Lucy broke another key, I wonder if she could start combining star dresses, maybe in a moment of desperation..... break them all for super zodiac form.

And before anyone says anything about the 12 zodiac spirits themselves being fodder. Early on in the manga, Lucy told
Natsu that if she trained, her spirits could become stronger than him because the spirits power is based on their celestial wizard. Plus if yukino and Sorano were summoning some and brandish was magnifying the magic of all three celestial girls not to mention enlarging the spirits to be giant happy size......

Yea..... that would be badass.

And if CSK was there too.

But that would be over kill for all the villains introduced this arc......

If only there was someone left in this story that could handle the csk, Spriggan, our girl in multiple star dresses, 12 zodiac together, and two supporting celestial wizards.
 

Cat Sidhe26

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
16,204
Gender
Female
Country
United States
That's what I think too. Especially since Mashima has this sister subplot and literally has not done anything with it. On top of that. Yukino hasn't summoned a spirit since Avatar to make Sting skinny.

And the Larcade subplot got introduced without being explained. Since Yukino and sorano are with him, it might remind Mashima to move back to both subplots after we have some END drama.

And really it's just too obvious that Capricorn's star dress would be next to be used.



As a fan, I also want the return of Virgo and Ares star dresses. All the other star dresses bar, The one that hasn't been shown yet, were used in battle moments with names attacks.
Lucy's Virgo star dress didn't get to show spica hole or spica lock. Nor did we actually see the digging magic when she tunneled into Avatar. Also Ares not only has her wool bomb but she can combo make a wool typhoon with Taurus. And a sand-wool typhoon with Taurus and Scorpio.

I want a battle of Lucy, CSK, Brandish, 12 zodiac, Yukino, Sorano vs someone. If Lucy broke another key, I wonder if she could start combining star dresses, maybe in a moment of desperation..... break them all for super zodiac form.

And before anyone says anything about the 12 zodiac spirits themselves being fodder. Early on in the manga, Lucy told
Natsu that if she trained, her spirits could become stronger than him because the spirits power is based on their celestial wizard. Plus if yukino and Sorano were summoning some and brandish was magnifying the magic of all three celestial girls not to mention enlarging the spirits to be giant happy size......

Yea..... that would be badass.

And if CSK was there too.

But that would be over kill for all the villains introduced this arc......

If only there was someone left in this story that could handle the csk, Spriggan, our girl in multiple star dresses, 12 zodiac together, and two supporting celestial wizards.
I guess great minds think alike. I'm fine with Mashima going back to Yukino and Sorano after we see what's going on what Natsu, just as long as a Sorano can redeem herself and be able to give Yukino a hug. I will admit I been waiting to see the Capircorn Stardress for along time and what it will look like. I wonder what magic the Capircorn Stardress will use and who do you think Lucy will use it against, August or someone else? I remember Lucy saying that about the 12 zodiac spirits in the beginning of the Phantom Lord arc and Sorano isn't a Celestial Spirit Mage anymore since she now uses Angel Magic.
 

Crescent Jinx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2016
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
15,385
Gender
Female
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
I guess great minds think alike. I'm fine with Mashima going back to Yukino and Sorano after we see what's going on what Natsu, just as long as a Sorano can redeem herself and be able to give Yukino a hug. I will admit I been waiting to see the Capircorn Stardress for along time and what it will look like. I wonder what magic the Capircorn Stardress will use and who do you think Lucy will use it against, August or someone else? I remember Lucy saying that about the 12 zodiac spirits in the beginning of the Phantom Lord arc and Sorano isn't a Celestial Spirit Mage anymore since she now uses Angel Magic.
Sorano does use angel magic which we could see. Or she could help yukino out for sake of plot.

Or even something as little as doing Urano metria since Angel should know the spell. Cuz yukino already did unison raid with Lucy in the spirit filler anime arc.

Lucy still has potential to fight August cuz she many times has the new character team up with her for her fight - yukino in gmg; cana in tenrou; hibiki in OS; Juvia in toh. So in this case would be brandish unless Mashima does some End drama. Or gets Mavis to fight August.

The next battle she could have would be a return of an older villain like if U1 caused Lucy to drop on someone like Azir (who would be like jackal). Because Azir is weak to water and Lucy is a water mage now on star dress. He's also weak to strategy and Lucy is somewhat immune to sand in Scorpio star dress. Plus Ares wool absorbs sand. And Taurus can use sand to form his sand typhoon spell.
And we saw star shot take out azirs sand wyverns. (This is actually the battle I would prefer)

The third battle could be Zeref. Maybe not a physical battle but an intelligence battle. Because even tho Mavis is foreshadowed to take him out. Lucy and Zeref have similarities. Both are writers and book lovers who love Natsu. Lucy used the eclipse gate to travel back in time to save Natsu in gmg.
Zeref build the eclipse gate to send Natsu into future. Zeref also has 400 years history with heartfilia women. They could fight over END's book as oppose to Lucy actually trying to kill Zeref like Natsu or Gray would. If happy could sneak steal the book while Lucy was distracting him, that would be a win. (Second choice cuz nobody would
See this coming)

Another fight Lucy could have vs END as you talked about before. Since beginning of series Mashima has thrown around jokes about Lucy fighting Natsu. From her saying early on if she trained she could be stronger..... to Edolas taking everyone's power leaving her as solo magic user..... to Lucy and Natsu wanting to fight on tenrou when Lucy was helping Cana....... to having their comedy Cain battle..... to her in Avatar wanting to fight him. Plus Mashima likes to make shipping couples battle.
 

Cat Sidhe26

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
16,204
Gender
Female
Country
United States
Sorano does use angel magic which we could see. Or she could help yukino out for sake of plot.

Or even something as little as doing Urano metria since Angel should know the spell. Cuz yukino already did unison raid with Lucy in the spirit filler anime arc.

Lucy still has potential to fight August cuz she many times has the new character team up with her for her fight - yukino in gmg; cana in tenrou; hibiki in OS; Juvia in toh. So in this case would be brandish unless Mashima does some End drama. Or gets Mavis to fight August.

The next battle she could have would be a return of an older villain like if U1 caused Lucy to drop on someone like Azir (who would be like jackal). Because Azir is weak to water and Lucy is a water mage now on star dress. He's also weak to strategy and Lucy is somewhat immune to sand in Scorpio star dress. Plus Ares wool absorbs sand. And Taurus can use sand to form his sand typhoon spell.
And we saw star shot take out azirs sand wyverns. (This is actually the battle I would prefer)

The third battle could be Zeref. Maybe not a physical battle but an intelligence battle. Because even tho Mavis is foreshadowed to take him out. Lucy and Zeref have similarities. Both are writers and book lovers who love Natsu. Lucy used the eclipse gate to travel back in time to save Natsu in gmg.
Zeref build the eclipse gate to send Natsu into future. Zeref also has 400 years history with heartfilia women. They could fight over END's book as oppose to Lucy actually trying to kill Zeref like Natsu or Gray would. If happy could sneak steal the book while Lucy was distracting him, that would be a win. (Second choice cuz nobody would
See this coming)

Another fight Lucy could have vs END as you talked about before. Since beginning of series Mashima has thrown around jokes about Lucy fighting Natsu. From her saying early on if she trained she could be stronger..... to Edolas taking everyone's power leaving her as solo magic user..... to Lucy and Natsu wanting to fight on tenrou when Lucy was helping Cana....... to having their comedy Cain battle..... to her in Avatar wanting to fight him. Plus Mashima likes to make shipping couples battle.
So do you think Sorano and Yukino will fight Larcade or Jacob when the Universe One dispels? Through it looks like the Universe One will dispel next chapter because of Irene's death. I'm leaning towards Lucy fighting August and Mavis should be the one to take out Zeref since it just feels right that Mavis does take out Zeref. I don't think Mavis will fight August since Mavis parallels Clea ( because of their similar personalities, changes in personalities after Clea becomes a Rave Guardian and after Mavis lives with the curse for a year, and Mavis dying and being freed from the lacrima is symbolic of Clea dying and coming back as a Rave Guardian) I think either Natsu will fight August or Lucy and Brandish will fight August. The next chapter title sounds like Natsu will have to chose between the Dragon seed and the demon seed and Natsu would obviously chose the dragon seed over the demon seed any day. If I remember correctly Capircorn uses hand to hand combat so when Lucy uses the Capircorn stardress it will end up being a physical battle through it was never revealed what magic Capircorn uses.
 
Last edited:

Crescent Jinx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2016
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
15,385
Gender
Female
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
So do you think Sorano and Yukino will fight Larcade or Jacob when the Universe One dispels? Through it looks like the Universe One will dispel next chapter because of Irene's death. I'm leaning towards Lucy fighting August and Mavis should be the one to take out Zeref since it just feels right that Mavis does take out Zeref. I don't think Mavis will fight August since Mavis parallels Clea ( because of their similar personalities, changes in personalities after Clea becomes a Rave Guardian and after Mavis lives with the curse for a year, and Mavis dying and being freed from the lacrima is symbolic of Clea dying and coming back as a Rave Guardian) I think either Natsu will fight August or Lucy and Brandish will fight August. The next chapter title sounds like Natsu will have to chose between the Dragon seed and the demon seed and Natsu would obviously chose the dragon seed over the demon seed any day. If I remember correctly Capircorn uses hand to hand combat so when Lucy uses the Capircorn stardress it will end up being a physical battle through it was never revealed what magic Capircorn uses.
Mavis does mimic Clea. Well the idea for Mavis is Mashima trying to be troll or plot twist with switching opponents for Mavis/Natsu/Lucy. Sometime has done that where you think persona a eill fight person b
But they fight person c and person d fights person a. Just trying to be open.

It just depends on what he wants to do with Mavis. Is she a way to cure Zeref or defeat him or kill him or die herself as a sacrifice?

I try to fight battles that balance each other out when I pair weird opponents. Thus Azir vs Lucy. That would have both opponents using not multiple magics and Lucy having to tactically combo her magic. Yukino and Sorano is a bit weird because on one hand yukino has gravity and water with her zodiac. But what does Sorano have? We never get shown much of her angel
Magic. And ophericus was large but took so long to summon and didn't do anything. I don't know who to pair them up without looking weird.

Of angel had a way to cancel Jacobs magic. Would think him. If Azir could be held down by libras gravity for a clean hit, that would work but that would basically follow all the other battles. Larcade..... not so much.

Mavis also could fight Jacob because Mashima likes to bring people back to fight people who humiliate them.

It's also hard to say.... this character will do this and this will do that. Because at the end of the day. Most of theee bad guys are there just to be defeated. Look at Irene....so far no really impacting the current storyline except for taking Acnologia out. And being defeated by daughter/dragon slayer combo. Wonot reallu depends on what Mashima' she goal is for getting...... Mavis to fight. Or yukino/Sorano to fight. Or Lucy to fight.

Yea that the plot hole with Capricorn. He never had a
Magic shown. Which he could have some berserker physical ability like I think One of Haru's swords did. But if that was so..... why didn't Mashima let Lucy fight jacob in that star dress? Which would make more sense.

Because he's the main physical Spriggan. Like you said..... can't really see her hand to hand combating whoever is left- azir, August, Larcade, or Zeref.

She could have had Loke in background keeping his regulus to negate the invisibility. Jacob just seems like a natural opponent for Capricorn.

Especially if you add the fact that jacob steals people and puts them in other dimensions same way Zoledo did in tenrou.

Or Capricorn could have some energy ability as he was shown training Lucy in how to build her enegy on the beach. He also was able to take Loke's regulus.

Actually the star dresses used have been weird because
Jacob was a natural opponent to Capricorn.
Azir for Scorpio star dress.

You could even say these spirits could have supported against:
Horologium for Dimaria.
Libra for Brandish.
Loke's light for Larcade.
 
Last edited:

Cat Sidhe26

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
16,204
Gender
Female
Country
United States
Mavis does mimic Clea. Well the idea for Mavis is Mashima trying to be troll or plot twist with switching opponents for Mavis/Natsu/Lucy. Sometime has done that where you think persona a eill fight person b
But they fight person c and person d fights person a. Just trying to be open.

It just depends on what he wants to do with Mavis. Is she a way to cure Zeref or defeat him or kill him or die herself as a sacrifice?

I try to fight battles that balance each other out when I pair weird opponents. Thus Azir vs Lucy. That would have both opponents using not multiple magics and Lucy having to tactically combo her magic. Yukino and Sorano is a bit weird because on one hand yukino has gravity and water with her zodiac. But what does Sorano have? We never get shown much of her angel
Magic. And ophericus was large but took so long to summon and didn't do anything. I don't know who to pair them up without looking weird.

Of angel had a way to cancel Jacobs magic. Would think him. If Azir could be held down by libras gravity for a clean hit, that would work but that would basically follow all the other battles. Larcade..... not so much.

Mavis also could fight Jacob because Mashima likes to bring people back to fight people who humiliate them.

It's also hard to say.... this character will do this and this will do that. Because at the end of the day. Most of theee bad guys are there just to be defeated. Look at Irene....so far no really impacting the current storyline except for taking Acnologia out. And being defeated by daughter/dragon slayer combo. Wonot reallu depends on what Mashima' she goal is for getting...... Mavis to fight. Or yukino/Sorano to fight. Or Lucy to fight.

Yea that the plot hole with Capricorn. He never had a
Magic shown. Which he could have some berserker physical ability like I think One of Haru's swords did. But if that was so..... why didn't Mashima let Lucy fight jacob in that star dress? Which would make more sense.

Because he's the main physical Spriggan. Like you said..... can't really see her hand to hand combating whoever is left- azir, August, Larcade, or Zeref.

She could have had Loke in background keeping his regulus to negate the invisibility. Jacob just seems like a natural opponent for Capricorn.

Especially if you add the fact that jacob steals people and puts them in other dimensions same way Zoledo did in tenrou.

Or Capricorn could have some energy ability as he was shown training Lucy in how to build her enegy on the beach. He also was able to take Loke's regulus.

Actually the star dresses used have been weird because
Jacob was a natural opponent to Capricorn.
Azir for Scorpio star dress.

You could even say these spirits could have supported against:
Horologium for Dimaria.
Libra for Brandish.
Loke's light for Larcade.
I think Mavis would be a cure for Zeref since I think Mavis's plan might have something to do with making Zeref mortal which might have something to with Mavis's plan. Didn't Yukino trained in hand to hand combat and studied martial arts while she was in Sabertooth and Sorano use some hand to hand combat? That would allow Yukino and Sorano be able to fight Jacob with both their magic and hand to hand combat. When you said it's weird that Lucy already used the Scorpio Star Dress do you mean she won't fight Ajeel or do you mean something else? Maybe Capricorn does have an energy ability but if Capricorn does have energy ability then which spriggan could Lucy use that on and who do you think will fight Larcade. Lucy's goal to fight would be to protect Natsu since in chapter 501 Lucy said she wanted to protect Nasu. Yukino and Sorano's goal to fight would be so Sorano can redeem herself and so Yukino can be a family again with her sister. Mavis's goal would be to protect her guild and her friends and I remember it was the Sacrifar sword form that had the berserker physical ability.
 
Last edited:
Top