Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[ziko77]

I don't know why dancing manga is in jump but this one is complete failure if we compare it to Ballroom e youkoso
http://bato.to/comic/_/comics/ballroom-e-youkoso-r10271
It is masterpiece.

I'm following both of these series, yeah Ballroom e youkoso is better in quality, art and writing than Sesuji wo pin. Sesuji wo pin isn't failure, it still fun to read and entertaining but reading this just like i read guide book "what is Ballroom Dance" ? no emotional and no complex like Ballroom e youkoso.

Let's just see who gets an anime first. Then we'll judge who's more successful. (Though still running wsj and having a strong ranking despite being a mere dancing manga is already a proof of its success)

If Sesuji wo pin will get 3 times nominee in Manga Taisho Award, then yes it's better than Ballroom e Youkoso because Ballroom e Youkoso already got 2 times . In 2015 Manga Taisho Award Ballroom e Youkoso's was 6th and Boku no Hero Academia 8th.

 

[piau9000]

Ranking - VOL 40

1 - One Piece
2 - Assassination Classroom
3 - Haikyuu
4 - Food Wars
5 - Gintama
6 - Toriko
7 - Straighten Up
8 - PSI Kusou Saiki
9 - Black Clover
10 - Nisekoi
11 - Kochikame
12 - World Trigger
13 - Devily Man
14 - Kagamigami
15 - Lady Justice




Average ranking of 2015 - VOL 40

"+" means that the series ended or moved to another magazine.

One Piece - 1.63
Assassination Classroom - 1.96
My Hero Academia - 2.51
Haikyuu - 4
Food Wars - 4.07
Black Clover - 4.71
Straighten Up - 5
Hinomaru Zumou - 5.87
Toriko - 6.72
Gintama - 6.90
PSI Kusou Saiki - 7.02
Nisekoi - 8.42
World Trigger - 9.24
Kagamigami - 9.57
+Gakkyuu Houtei - 11.15
Kochikame - 11.28
Bleach - 11.62
+Ultra Battle Satellite - 11.9
+Judos - 12
+Takujou no Ageha - 12.33
+Hi-Fi Cluster - 12.71
Devily Man - 13
+Cyborg Roggy - 13.5
+E-Robot - 13.5
+Sporting Salt - 13.5
Lady Justice - 13.87

 

[Mammo]

As far as I can tell, he is talking about Jurassic World, that he was finally able to see it and he liked the BGM. It seems to me that "CP" is not referring to colour pages than rather to a name

maybe he's referring to Chris Pratt?

 

[conankudo]

maybe he's referring to Chris Pratt?

Could be, but I don't know a thing about Jurassic Park. Im the wrong person to answer that

One Piece Movie ad from Jump issue #40: It will be Oda's third movie after Strong world and Film Z he is involved in:

---------- Post added at 11:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:51 AM ----------

Assassination Classroom and The Story of Isobe Isobee will also get Center Colour pages in issue #41

 

[101nemesis]

WSJ Cover & Lead Color

Spoiler

Pretty nice Cover and color spread from Kubo, if you ask me.

 

[Schabrak]

Expect some more breaks this and next year.

 

[justanotherone]

Expect some more breaks this and next year.

Are you talking about Bleach? Kubo doesn't take many breaks unless he is really sick.

 

[SharkBait]

Are you talking about Bleach? Kubo doesn't take many breaks unless he is really sick.

I thought he meant One Piece

 

[justanotherone]

I thought he meant One Piece

Ah right, because of the new movie announced. My bad.

Strong world and z were good, I am looking forward to this new one.

 

[Pietro]

black clover is 9 th.The worst position till this moment.
Kagamigami is just over Lady Justice,I hope next week it returns to its positions

 

[SharkBait]

Omg animated 3rd gym finally, my doujins animated soon. Look at Bokuto, Akashi, Lev, Tsukki! Kuroo!!!1

 

[Avok]

Wow! Black Clover is pretty low in the rankings.

Let's see if this marks its downfall.

 

[SharkBait]

Wow! Black Clover is pretty low in the rankings.

Let's see if this marks its downfall.

The weeks of color pages strongly suggest and highly implies that the editors have placed it lower in order to give other series a brief reprieve. This is surely not a reflection of BLack Clover losing popularity, but rather, an acknowledgement of its confirmed potential of being a hit manga.

 

[Avok]

The weeks of color pages strongly suggest and highly implies that the editors have placed it lower in order to give other series a brief reprieve. This is surely not a reflection of BLack Clover losing popularity, but rather, an acknowledgement of its confirmed potential of being a hit manga.

Yeah, that could be it. We'll have to see how it does in the following weeks.

 

[Bluenotebook]

Yeah, that could be it. We'll have to see how it does in the following weeks.

No, that's obviously not it.

 

[susanoo13]

Or it could possibly be that one chapter was less exciting than the rest and other series simply outpreformed it this time. At this time it's definitely not a downfall and I wouldn't worry about it until it gets 4 bottom 5's in a row, which is highly unlikely at this point. I wouldn't jump to your conclusion from 2 reasons :

1)What series that is above it need the reprieve? they're already established
2)Why not do it with a more stable series, or any other series such as Soma or HQ!!?

It was stated in Bakuman, most readers have a brain and don't just follow their series like zombies, if they liked something more(or 3 somethings for that matter)in the specific week, they will vote for for it. Just look at other bouncing series and see.

 

[Avok]

No, that's obviously not it.

I'm not saying that's definitely what happened, as I don't know for sure. Calm down.

 

[Bluenotebook]

I wasn't being aggressive.

 

[Avok]

It's ok. :P

 

[dark123]

Or it could possibly be that one chapter was less exciting than the rest and other series simply outpreformed it this time. At this time it's definitely not a downfall and I wouldn't worry about it until it gets 4 bottom 5's in a row, which is highly unlikely at this point. I wouldn't jump to your conclusion from 2 reasons :

1)What series that is above it need the reprieve? they're already established
2)Why not do it with a more stable series, or any other series such as Soma or HQ!!?

It was stated in Bakuman, most readers have a brain and don't just follow their series like zombies, if they liked something more(or 3 somethings for that matter)in the specific week, they will vote for for it. Just look at other bouncing series and see.

If that was true One Piece wouldn't be most of the time 1 because one piece most of the time is boring as fuck.