Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[HIGAN0]

Weekly Shonen Jump Circulation Drops again...sigh :

July-September→October-December/2016
ジャンプ 2,151,667 → 2,005,833 / -150k down

it's not just Jump,but almost every manga magazine.....

Compare to Shonen Magazine & Sunday :
Magazine / マガジン995,017→986,017 / -11k down
Sunday / サンデー330,000→323,250 / -7k down

Source and more magazine data /nswf/

 

[Swavey]

Weekly Shonen Jump Circulation Drops again...sigh :
July-September→October-December/2016
ジャンプ 2,151,667 → 2,005,833 / -150k down
it's not just Jump,but almost every manga magazine.....
Compare to Shonen Magazine & Sunday :
Magazine / マガジン995,017→986,017 / -11k down
Sunday / サンデー330,000→323,250 / -7k down

Source and more magazine data /nswf/

That is what you get when you axe Bleach's successor

 

[Kadir0]

That is what you get when you axe Bleach's successor

Bleach's successor?

 

[Scruffy8642]

Bleach's successor?

Red Sprite

 

[TM2]

I seriously doubt there will be another "big 3" series on the scale or Bleach, Naruto, One Piece ever again. Not because the big series at the time were the best written or illustrated but because they came out during a time when there wasn't as much competition and the internet was still struggling to get mainstream use. Not to mention because of these conditions they effectively raised a generation. So any "successor" that comes along with inevitably need to compete with a veritable library of other series that had long established their fanbase.

 

[WyldViolet]

The big 3 does not exist. It is a western invention.
Do we really have to go through this again?

 

[Tamil]

Big 3 is a title from 4chan...The community just ran with it.

 

[Mammo]

Nah, I'm not here to bait you guys like some members do. I just state my opinion and since we don't agree in almost anything, it is always food for discussion. I like this way because we are here to discuss, much better than the boring rhetoric that everything is a matter of taste and not discussable.

I'm just saying, you're free to discuss what you want and we're free to put your opinions to in the same basket we put sharkbait's opinions in
I really don't see a different about "it have cute boys it's a masterpiece" and "it have cute girls, I will defended and whiteknight it although I never it"

 

[conankudo]

Weekly Shonen Jump Circulation Drops again...sigh :
July-September→October-December/2016
ジャンプ 2,151,667 → 2,005,833 / -150k down
it's not just Jump,but almost every manga magazine.....
Compare to Shonen Magazine & Sunday :
Magazine / マガジン995,017→986,017 / -11k down
Sunday / サンデー330,000→323,250 / -7k down

Source and more magazine data /nswf/

IF people would read Investor Z, they would know that there is a very logical explanation why magazines are dropping in general in recent years

 

[Mammo]

IF people would read Investor Z, they would know that there is a very logical explanation why magazines are dropping in general in recent years

I've been trying to get into it but I just don't have time to pick anything new
you have my permission to spoil that part for me
please tell me, oh wise one

=================

KAITO new manga started today btw
https://shonenjumpplus.com/episode/13932016480028800124

 

[SkerllyFC]

At least Hiro Mashima has more clear romances than Bleach and Naruto combined. Or you gonna say is it only me?

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

At least Hiro Mashima has more clear romances than Bleach and Naruto combined. Or you gonna say is it only me?

Well, yeah, it's only you. That romance between Lisana and Natsu is awful. Seriously. But I don't think we should discuss Fairy Tail here since this is JUMP's TOC thread.

 

[vampire killer]

Well with Black clover getting anime and the second season of boku no hero academia shonen jump should see bug increase in new readers.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Mutou Black mangaka needs to come back. His insect miniseries on Plus was great.

 

[Swavey]

Well, yeah, it's only you. That romance between Lisana and Natsu is awful. Seriously. But I don't think we should discuss Fairy Tail here since this is JUMP's TOC thread.

You can it is part of the big 3 now that Bleach got the axe

 

[shoyoboyo]

You can it is part of the big 3 now that Bleach got the axe

You can't be serious.

 

[WyldViolet]

You can it is part of the big 3 now that Bleach got the axe

Please stand by while I exhaust my cosmos of REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'s.

 

[IHateAsta]

OP has 0 romance unless we count Ivankov x Sanji .
Bleach's Romance is awful .
Naruto is the best among these 3 ,Sasuke x Naruto , Minato and Kushina , Temari x Shika
but still Kenshin has to be the best imo .

 

[Leoat12]

I'm just saying, you're free to discuss what you want and we're free to put your opinions to in the same basket we put sharkbait's opinions in
I really don't see a different about "it have cute boys it's a masterpiece" and "it have cute girls, I will defended and whiteknight it although I never it"

Basically you are saying that I blidnly defend anything that has cute girls on it. You are mistaken. I can give you a dozen of examples of the contrary as soon as I get home or you could see my dropped list on MAL.
All this began because of a series that hasn't started yet. There are things that I expect from a romance and if it doesn't fulfill the expectations, I will criticize it.
Since you guys don't see me criticizing the mangas I read as much as you wanted, I will start to give my impressions here (meaning the forum).

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

You can it is part of the big 3 now that Bleach got the axe

My sides.