Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Mammo]

Gintama just took BnHA usual spot

if you look to the top 5 (OP-Gintama-Kimetsu-Haikyuu-BC)
the only title that is not regularly in the top 5 is Gintama

we had a similar situation last year when Gintama went to unexpected hiatus and Bleach suddenly jumped in the toc

Dr stone spoilers, got it from 4chan with no idea who they got it from

Spoiler: Dr Stone

The Hero is the black haired guy and his name is Taiju. The Blond one is called Tenkuu and the heroine is Yuzuriha.
One day Taiju confesses to a girl (implied to be Yuzuriha) when the sky is covered in a strange light. Everyone who touched that light turned to stone. Taiki and the girl are turned to stone and over 1000 years pass. His stone breaks and he explores the world until he finds his old friend Tenkuu who was freed from being a stone half a year ago. Tenkuu guides Taiju and takes him to his small treehouse. He intends to team up with them and bring the civilization back to where it was. They decide to investigate what the light thousands of years ago was and how to fix the situation

not really surprising, if you go to Inagaki twitter account he have a Dragon Quest avatar

Petrification and healing it is always a plot device in every game

 

[G_I_A]

Hahahaha MHA fans are DESPERATE right now... I hope it gets a one year hiatus...

Things not looking good for Neverland... Week after week it continues to go down... Souma bottom is wtv.

 

[xAsum0x]

Hahahaha MHA fans are DESPERATE right now... I hope it gets a one year hiatus...

Things not looking good for Neverland... Week after week it continues to go down... Souma bottom is wtv.

Did one of em piss in your cereal? You seem to have a strong dislike for people who are fans of the manga

 

[G_I_A]

Yeah I have... MHA fans are completely based about the series thinking that it's the BEST thing that happened to the magazine so far, neglecting pretty much everything else...

If this break is not anime-related Horikoshi seems to be having issues on maintaining the weekly load of annoying dialogues.

 

[Nakura]

Even for series I hate, I'd never wish anything bad upon the fans, or the mangaka.

 

[xAsum0x]

I have idea what your talking about lol. Just because people enjoy talking about it and think it's great doesn't mean they neglect other manga in the magazine

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 1, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 1, 2017 ---

Even for series I hate, I'd never wish anything bad upon the fans, or the mangaka.

I mean technically he didn't, but it's just awkward seeing him constantly wish bad things on the franchise

 

[Mammo]

just ignore him, all he does is lie and flip flop

and if you reply to him he will fill the thread with 4 pages of shitposts and trying hard to be sharkbait

but to hate Chinese cartoon enough to wish harm on another human, that sound like next level insane to me

 

[G_I_A]

/\ Haha I love how he gets annoyed by my comments that pretty much says the truth that nobody wanna hear...

But yeah I did not wish bad for anybody haha, I want Horikoshi full health a year from now after his long hiatus, (or planning the mastermind anime that you guys think that s2 will be haha)

But since Mammo LOVES it, here comments another one:

Since HZ will be getting a color page next week (nobody knows why) I hope its finally... FINALLY the ending annoucement.

Also this week's will have BC 100º (despairing haters with nonsense, no plot whatsoever, no nothing) chapter.

 

[Divinenega]

Things not looking good for Neverland... Week after week it continues to go down... Souma bottom is wtv.

Neverland was ranked 3rd last week so not sure what the heck you're talking about. It's only ranked 7th this time which isn't exactly great but not really "it's doooomeeeed" material unless it stays low. Though given nearly half the magazine is comprised of unranked series right now, I wouldn't start trying to seriously gauge how safe or unsafe anything is for at least another 3 or 4 weeks when We Can't Study finally hits chapter 8.

 

[G_I_A]

Neverland was ranked 3rd last week so not sure what the heck you're talking about. It's only ranked 7th this time which isn't exactly great but not really "it's doooomeeeed" material unless it stays low. Though given nearly half the magazine is comprised of unranked series right now, I wouldn't start trying to seriously gauge how safe or unsafe anything is for at least another 3 or 4 weeks when We Can't Study finally hits chapter 8.

I never said "its doomed" I don't want it to go down as well, I love the series. I merely said it's losing positions and it's the truth... What about it?

 

[Swavey]

Hahahaha MHA fans are DESPERATE right now... I hope it gets a one year hiatus...

Things not looking good for Neverland... Week after week it continues to go down... Souma bottom is wtv.

Are you bipolar or something? I am sure you said you love BnHA a lot last week. I know wave riding is really common here but you take it too far.

 

[ShenGao]

But we're missing the point here... I want comments about the possible (probable) HZ damnation. You guys know it's coming.

It went on for almost 3 years in the most ruthless manga magazine on this planet. It had a good run, good art, was fun to read and wasn't a typical "cute boys doing sports" sports manga so i enjoyed it.
I hope Kawada returns with a battle manga.

 

[G_I_A]

Are you bipolar or something? I am sure you said you love BnHA a lot last week. I know wave riding is really common here but you just took it too far.

I certainly don't dislike it, but "love"... this is too much... Don't get me wrong, I don't want it to go bad, I want it to go better... But I'll repeat it's too much alike HXH these days... With lots of unnecessary dialogues... There's also the comedy part that Horikoshi just suck.

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 1, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 1, 2017 ---

It's went of for almost 3 years in the most ruthless manga magazine on this planet. It had a good run, good art, was fun to read and wasn't a typical "cute boys doing sports" sports manga so i enjoyed it.
I hope Kawada returns with a battle manga.

I could not agree more. I want him with a battle manga and for that... HZ needs to die... As soon as possible for that matter.

But... You agree it is ending, though?

 

[Mammo]

something less cancerous

:3

a lot of people saying she's the next Togashi but in my opinion that title should go to Takuan and Batsu mangaka

his work reminded me a lot of Togashi's early work and oneshots

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 1, 2017, Original Post Date: Mar 1, 2017 ---

and speaking of promising rookies, I should mention Fukuda

the quality jump from Devilyman to Shinigiwa caught me by surprise, i didn't know he had it in him, since Devilyman was so boring and repetitive

If Shinigiwa was serialize in the main magazine there's no doubt in my mind it would have been a hit

but then again it might not worked as a long manga

 

[Scruffy8642]

But we're missing the point here... I want comments about the possible (probable) HZ damnation. You guys know it's coming.

Not happening. As I have said countless times (yes, I know it's bait), the latest chapter just began the first of 5 fights in the finals and is taking it's damn time. Not to mention the series will end in a completely different tournament to the current one. These last few chapters have been very slow paced and not much has happened. If it was ending even within the next 10 chapters it would skip the rest of this tournament in it's entirety. Give it 20-30 chapters and it will be over naturally.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Does anyone have the sketch work of Gotouge from her omake? Not a fan of her serialized art, and I heard this was different.

 

[Tamil]

I don't think KnY is that similar to HxH. I do appreciate the narrations in the manga; it's rare to see it used pretty frequently. I think the popular examples would be HxH, JoJo & especially Toriko that use narrations quite frequently.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Does anyone have the sketch work of Gotouge from her omake? Not a fan of her serialized art, and I heard this was different.

They're on Batoto.

 

[Mammo]

Does anyone have the sketch work of Gotouge from her omake? Not a fan of her serialized art, and I heard this was different.

v 1 omake
http://bato.to/reader#3c05746819f4de72

v 2 omake
http://bato.to/reader#945fccaef1369044

v 3 omake
http://bato.to/reader#d37fb2b5d922f833

v 4 omake
http://bato.to/reader#c7fc5954757c1c6d

 

[G_I_A]

We can all have our opinions, but when we state them, you laugh at us for being fans and talk shit about the series. No shit people are going to stand up for their favourite series. You don't let us have opinions. But when you have them, it's all good... huh?

Not happening. As I have said countless times (yes, I know it's bait), the latest chapter just began the first of 5 fights in the finals and is taking it's damn time. Not to mention the series will end in a completely different tournament to the current one. These last few chapters have been very slow paced and not much has happened. If it was ending even within the next 10 chapters it would skip the rest of this tournament in it's entirety. Give it 20-30 chapters and it will be over naturally.

I can't remind me bashing people because of their opinions. I bash/agree opinions and that's all. This is what makes a forum err... A forum.

The difference between me and other people here is that I do not attack the interlocutor, merely its ideas.

We can always have a timeskip. This happened with the dance manga. Why can't it happen with HZ? Also why HZ should be "over naturally" when bigger mangas did not have this luxury?

I don't think KnY is that similar to HxH. I do appreciate the narrations in the manga; it's rare to see it used pretty frequently. I think the popular examples would be HxH, JoJo & especially Toriko that use narrations quite frequently.

I fail to see any similarity as well.