Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Nakura]

RxL
Poro
Dr. Stone
Hungry Marie
U19
We Never Learn

 

[G_I_A]

I want Mammo, Leoat, Rica, Sharkbait and the vampire rankings...

 

[Kadir0]

Hungry Marie
RxL
Dr.Stone
We Never Learn
Poro
U19

 

[Swavey]

Poro
We Never Learn
Hungry Mary
Dr.Stone
U19
RxL

 

[Caiops]

RxL
Dr.Stone
Hungry Marie
We Never Learn
Poro

Didn't read U19, and that doesn't look good, so i will pass.

The first chapter of RxL was amazing, oh my god, i missed so much Fujimaki styles.

I can see the shipps already ;-;

 

[justsomeguy]

RxL
We Never Learn
Dr. Stone
Poro
Hungry Marie
U19

 

[Drmke]

I've only read the first chapters of Dr. Stone, U19, and Robot x Laserbeam.

Robot
U19-Dr. Stone (both could be something interesting but neither got me very excited)

 

[savethecat]

Confused because I haven't really been seeing a significant amount of hate or trashing on any of the anime communities(at least here in America). Is this true?

 

[Nakura]

The general reception seems to be good, so I suppose not. I guess in his mind, if a few complain about it, then the series is getting absolutely TRASHED. RxL has no hopes of being nearly as good as Cancel no Yaiba :/

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Why value this gelatinous slug's opinion so highly? It's what he wants...

 

[James Rye]

One Piece colors are very important. Not only because the color walks but because they are always used during the anime openings. All of them.

G-I-V-E M-E Y-O-U-R R-A-N-K-I-N-G-S

RxL (best first chapter outta the bunch)
Dr.Stone (second-best chapter outta the bunch, 2nd and 3rd chapter starts to make me worry though...)
We can't study (it's fine)
Hungry Maries (it's ok)
Poro (I dunno, I just can't get into it)
U19 (because its title means Under 19 other series :P)

 

[shoyoboyo]

Woah, pretty much everyone agrees that RxL is the best of this new batch so far. Have we finally reached a conclusion where we are all on the same page?! Also, that comment from Gotouge pretty much seals the deal that she is most likely a woman. I mean, c'mon, would you really give a flower to a man as a congratulations?

On another note, y-you think Isobe's mangaka is okay?

Yes, I know it's a typo.

 

[Koi Kage]

On another note, y-you think Isobe's mangaka is okay?

Yes, I know it's a typo.

Wow that's a pretty high fever to have to be joking about like that, as much I personally think the author should take at least a week off to recover from that, so long as it's not impeding the manga in anyway I don't see Shounen Jump asking the author to take time off.

 

[Kefka Palazzo]

One Piece colors are very important. Not only because the color walks but because they are always used during the anime openings. All of them.

G-I-V-E M-E Y-O-U-R R-A-N-K-I-N-G-S

Poro > Dr. Stone > RxL >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BokuBenkyou > U19 = Harapeko no Marie

 

[tirakai]

Kuroko guy doing golf has me curious, are there any wsj creators in the past who have had two successful series that are each about a different sport? The only one I can think of is Rokudenashi/Rookies guy and rokudenashi's more of a yankee manga than a sports one from what I've read.

 

[Avok]

RxL and Poro are the best of the bunch, by a mile.

 

[Leoat12]

I'm going to read Robot x Laserbeam Monday, so I cannot give any comment about it yet.
As for the rest of my ranking, anybody who knows English and interpretation knows already. XD
Put only the ranking is not enough, I would have to explain why and that way I would be repeating myself.

 

[SkerllyFC]

I would expect the 3 chapters of Robo to make a ranking of the 6 series instead of ranking it with only one chapter though. I´ll post a strawpoll on reddit fro you and anyone who has read the 6 series in a couple of weeks. I´m more of getting the whole picture before making rankings and things like that.

 

[Gikiseima]

Based of first chapter
Dr.Stone
U19/We never learn (tie)
Robot x laserbeam
Poro/Hungry Marie(tie)

Will update soon as robot reach 3 or 5 chapters

 

[Halloween]

Dr. Stone and Robot x Laserbeam are the best of the bunch. Don't care about the rest.