Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[savethecat]

Because Part 4 was 39 episodes with no break its production values suffered a lot and had more outsourced episodes than even Part 1 and 2 but they pulled through where in mattered which is what's importent. I'm not sure how they'll handled Part 5 though since unlike Part 4 everything about Part 5 hinges on how well the handle the fights which I don't think they have the manpower to pull off if its as long as Part 4.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 6, 2017 ---

I keep telling everyone its not the studio you should be asking for its the director because even a good studio can ruin an adaptation if its not handled with care despite that I don't think Shuiesha is going to slack off when it comes to selecting a studio for Neverland like they clearly did with World Trigger but we'll see I've seen some really bad studios produce some quality shit here and there mainly because of the director being passionate about it (A-1; From The New World)

I know that's true. But dont certain studios often have animators that pretty much stick to their studio.
Like how Nakamura works almost exclusively for Bones. So we probably wouldn't have gotten the epic

Spoiler

Todoroki and Deku clash

had MHA never gone to studio Bones.
I know for some studios like Madhouse and A1, the team working on the anime could be anime body. But it seems like some studios Pierrot, Toei, Bones, and Trigger tend to have teams that mainly stick with them

 

[Leoat12]

Is it time for another "Which Studio Should Get Neverland" discussion now that we're nearly 50 chapters in now :^)

No. It is too early for that if you want to have something with any quality.

 

[savethecat]

No. It is too early for that if you want to have something with any quality.

I could see an anime next year

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Is it time for another "Which Studio Should Get Neverland" discussion now that we're nearly 50 chapters in now :^)

Madhouse or MAPPA

 

[Leoat12]

I could see an anime next year

Next year means more 50 chapters which sums more than 100 chapters. You talk as if next year is just around the corner, but it is not how it works in the manga/anime market, it is a long run until there. IF they announce an anime by the end of the year, which I doubt will happen, it will not be aired until Spring 2018 at least, if not Summer 2018.

 

[G_I_A]

Is it time for another "Which Studio Should Get Neverland" discussion now that we're nearly 50 chapters in now :^)

Madhouse or Bones.

 

[Tamil]

I thought you guys wanted MAPPA for Kimetsu No Yaiba. (not that I don't want MAPPA to do KnY)

 

[savethecat]

Next year means more 50 chapters which sums more than 100 chapters. You talk as if next year is just around the corner, but it is not how it works in the manga/anime market, it is a long run until there. IF they announce an anime by the end of the year, which I doubt will happen, it will not be aired until Spring 2018 at least, if not Summer 2018.

All I'm saying is that now that we're 50 chapters in, the series gets consistent good rankings, and the volumes are selling extremely well, that we can reasonably discuss an anime without thinking "it's too soon to talk about an anime", or "it could get axed by then". At this point it seems like that anime will definitely happen in the near future. And 2018 isn't far away

 

[TyVip]

Mfw when Yuragi is theoretically the next in line to receive an anime adaption and no one talks about it.

 

[ChocoBar9]

It'll probably just be Xebec with the To Love Ru staff or at worst TNK

 

[Leoat12]

Mfw when Yuragi is theoretically the next in line to receive an anime adaption and no one talks about it.

A series full of ecchi like that will be aired late at night and will not have much success, so there isn't much we can talk about or expect.

The Promised Neverland doesn't look the mainstream series that is aired in the best timeslot either, so...

 

[Tanzo]

If it's going to be Xebec doing the Yuragi anime, I hope its the TLR staff at least in charge of it and not this guy doing the designs:
https://myanimelist.net/people/16585/Akio_Takami
Other than that hopefully the scheduling issues that affected several of their recent anime don't affect it when the time comes.

 

[Caiops]

A series full of ecchi like that will be aired late at night and will not have much success, so there isn't much we can talk about or expect.

The Promised Neverland doesn't look the mainstream series that is aired in the best timeslot either, so...

What?
All series like Madoka or Yuri on Ice who make a lot of money, aired late at night.

Don't forget that To Love Ru anime made the series sell 400k per volume, don't talk nonsense just because you dont like ecchi...

The most popular anime titles in Japan right now are series that aired late at night.

 

[HIGAN0]

Issue 32 Cover :

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 6, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 6, 2017 ---

Emergency Reprint for Dr. Stone Vol.01

 

[Newkerzy]

This is just my personal preference but for the most part I honestly thought the way SnS describes its food never quite jumped out at me. Possibly because the "foodgasms" didn't really do a good job conveying information about the food, not helping matters is that for the most part a lot of the food presented are completely alien to me. Not that it fails completely at providing information but it could overall do a better job at it.

Compared to a manga like Dungeon Meshi which pretty much uses fantasy creatures as ingredients. But despite the fantastical setting and ingredients, the recipes themselves are fairly down to earth and the author does a better job conveying information that goes beyond making the characters orgasm through the mouth.

As for me: I really like the way food is presented in Nobunaga's Chef. The author does an excellent job of fitting in cooking as a narrative that really drives the plot forward, and honestly I think Tsukuda pales in comparison and I still don't see how he's a great author like people claim he is.

Another really good one is Bambino! and its sequel, Secondo! It's a very realistic depiction of the restaurant business and I think even Gordon Ramsay would put in a comment to promote it.

 

[HIGAN0]

Gintama Color spread :

 

[vampire killer]

The movie didnt boos the backlog sale of gintama. I would say the movie is failure. It look like a youtube project by a bunch a nerds shot at some con. At least I did not expect much and got non.

 

[Doughboy]

It would be the ultimate slap in the face if Neverland gets an anime before Yuragi, the ecchi gods would be so triggered

 

[Leoat12]

What?
All series like Madoka or Yuri on Ice who make a lot of money, aired late at night.

Don't forget that To Love Ru anime made the series sell 400k per volume, don't talk nonsense just because you dont like ecchi...

The most popular anime titles in Japan right now are series that aired late at night.

Nonsensical is you guys inconsistency because last week you were saying that late at night animes is not as popular as the ones that are aired in better timeslots. Was that true or are you guys just saying that to bait Shokugeki no Soma fans? You have to decide, otherwise it is difficult to have any proper discussion with you changing of opinion from day to night.

 

[Pietro]

Do you know if Gintama is reaching its climax ? And in how much time it will be reached in your opinion?