Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Chuck_Atlas]

Has he done any other one shot since Red Sprite?

 

[savethecat]

Now we can finally do Studio bets for Dr.Stone

 

[Scruffy8642]

All in on Toei

 

[Tamil]

Toei most likely. They haven't touched any new WSJ titles since like WT?

I remember people thought HZ would've gotten animated by Toei and now seeing Gonzo's lousy job, I wouldn't have mind Toei doing HZ. At least it would've gotten a boost in Toei's hands and be safe from getting axed for a while.

 

[iceemperor]

Toei most likely. They haven't touched any new WSJ titles since like WT?

I remember people thought HZ would've gotten animated by Toei and now seeing Gonzo's lousy job, I wouldn't have mind Toei doing HZ. At least it would've gotten a boost in Toei's hands and be safe from getting axed for a while.

Gonzo's "lousy job" has nothing to do with whether it got a boost or not. Pierrot seemingly messed up TG way back with its first season and it blew up regardless. There have also been plenty of series that took off even with mediocre anime. Sumou, unfortunately, is simply past the window for growth. It doesn't help that its subject matter is with a niche sport. From what I've heard, they've picked up the pace with the anime, even rearranging stuff around to get to the tournaments quickly. That's not a bad strategy but its simply not working.

It honestly doesn't matter what studio gets the series in terms of a sales boost. Sure a good adaptation will help but a bad one won't suddenly hamper it outright though there will be an effect.

 

[Franz]

Remember what I said two or three weeks ago? I hope it's temporary, but my pessimism tells me it's not. ; _ ;

Where is the problem ?

No seriously....

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 8, 2018, Original Post Date: Nov 8, 2018 ---

I think I'm more worried that they still haven't revealed the character poll yet and the series won't have another lead cover before the last issue of the year. 15 pages is at least a sign he's getting back to normal.

Oda had more problem compared to Hori. Regardless he made color spread and lead

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 8, 2018 ---

I feel like Jujutsu Kaisen will surpass Black Clover near 5 volumes

5 volumes I don' think so. 10 or 15 volumes more likely.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 8, 2018 ---

This thread feels more and more like a BC thread.

Very funny...

 

[Cavaner]

MHA may not have the cover/pop poll results in #51, but unless I missed something, couldn’t it have it for #52? That’s still November, as was said, and will fall perfectly before the release of Volume 21. Again, unless something was already confirmed for #52 and I just missed it. Can anyone confirm or deny that #52 for MHA is a possibility?

 

[TxxT]

MHA may not have the cover/pop poll results in #51, but unless I missed something, couldn’t it have it for #52? That’s still November, as was said, and will fall perfectly before the release of Volume 21. Again, unless something was already confirmed for #52 and I just missed it. Can anyone confirm or deny that #52 for MHA is a possibility?

Alot of people are speculating that KnY will have the cover for #52

 

[Cavaner]

Alot of people are speculating that KnY will have the cover for #52

Ah, okay, but no confirmation yet then. Even if that is the case, couldn’t MHA just have CPs and it’s poll results, with no cover? It’d be a bit of a shame, but I guess it’d be less of a burden on Horikoshi, which might be for the best right now.

 

[iceemperor]

I wouldn't rule out a Heroaca cover/lead CP for Issue 52 to end out the 50th anniversary year. Either that or 2019 Issue 1.

 

[Cavaner]

I wouldn't rule out a Heroaca cover/lead CP for Issue 52 to end out the 50th anniversary year. Either that or 2019 Issue 1.

Agreed! Just wonder what they’ll end up doing, considering they promised the poll results in November... guess we’ll see soon enough :P

 

[Ninjaz]

Remember what I said two or three weeks ago? I hope it's temporary, but my pessimism tells me it's not. ; _ ;

Anyway, this is the first time that MHA takes the first place after more than a year. It's been so long that I wonder if it's not fake, especially because of Neverland's position.

It’s 120% temporary

 

[Heiji]

#51 :
One Piece Break

 

[Xzone]

I feel like a few years ago I would have been kind of hyped for a Yagi oneshot but now it's just meh.

Idk what happen to him, maybe his problem is because his editor?
Goblin knight was a good one shot, but his other works were meh to me.

 

[revo68]

 

[Mammo]

Soma on the cover and WT and Koroko are also there

is this 2013?

 

[Savi]

#51 :
One Piece Break

I think we can say it's already a pattern that mostly same for 3 years with Oda breaks, with a little change but same timing +-

 

[101nemesis]

Remember what I said two or three weeks ago? I hope it's temporary, but my pessimism tells me it's not. ; _ ;

Couldn't these chapters be ones he drew before he took his break?

Oda had more problem compared to Hori. Regardless he made color spread and lead

Can't compare. Oda has been doing this far longer and way more experienced so he'd be more efficient in how he manages his time and work. Plus, different people, different art styles, different work habit and ethics.

Very funny...

It is actually hilarious.

I think we can say it's already a pattern that mostly same for 3 years with Oda breaks, with a little change but same timing +-

As it should be. He deserves his breaks.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Will TPN become the new Sumo of begging for animation every week?

 

[MangAniMY]

we still haven't seen any actual animation yet,

that was literally just character designs

edit: at least the voice acting was impactful