Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Shinuki no Reborn]

I'm really curious, who was the only user that voted in the top 5? must be really a fan.

 

[Franz]

Black Clover popularity poll

Spoiler

1st Asta 2971
2nd Yami 2213
3rd Noel 1864
4th Yuno 1628
5th Mereoleona 1231
6th Charlotte 1156
7th Charmy 986
8th Mimosa 885
9th Luck 842
10th Gauche 791

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Black Clover popularity poll

Spoiler

1st Asta 2971
2nd Yami 2213
3rd Noel 1864
4th Yuno 1628
5th Mereoleona 1231
6th Charlotte 1156
7th Charmy 986
8th Mimosa 885
9th Luck 842
10th Gauche 791

Wow that's some changes, it was from just Noelle and Mereoleona last time to half of the top 10 being girls now, that's something difficult to see on battle shounens, maybe it's a reflection on how good Tabata is in writing his girls, but after that Charmy reveal, it's totally fair, Mimosa is also being such a good character recently.

 

[Halloween]

Even if not ranking this week, being on the lower part of the magazine is worrisome and I don't remember if there has been a series to be in that spot a week before of its ranking just to be in a safe spot the next week.
If there is any, please correct me.

This doesn't sound correct, but I can't recall a specific example, so I'll concede on this point for now.

I'm really curious, who was the only user that voted in the top 5? must be really a fan.

It should be publicly viewable. At least, I allowed that option. Anyway, it was Gorilla.

 

[shoyoboyo]

yuno shouldnt even be top 10 but otherwise, i like the rest of them being there. I wish mereo was higher though, but 5th is actually much better than i expected.

 

[Tarot]

Black Clover popularity poll

Spoiler

1st Asta 2971
2nd Yami 2213
3rd Noel 1864
4th Yuno 1628
5th Mereoleona 1231
6th Charlotte 1156
7th Charmy 986
8th Mimosa 885
9th Luck 842
10th Gauche 791

Is this the first time half of the list is dominated by female characters in a battle shounen?

 

[Nemesis]

WSJ Issue 32 TOC

Black Clover (LCP)
Dr STONE
One Piece
Kimetsu no Yaiba
The Promised Neverland
Samurai 8 (CP)
We Never Learn
My Hero Academia
Hinomaru Sumo
Act Age
Spy x Family (CP)
Chainsaw Man (CP)
Tokyo Shinobi Squad
Haikyu!!
Jujutsu Kaisen
Yuuna
Double Taisei
Yui Kamio
Beast Children
Last Saiyuki

Issue 33:
Cover/LCP - My Hero Academia
CP - Haikyu!!, We Never Learn (poll), Mori King (one shot)
One Piece (absent)

Welp, Double Taisei was on bottom 5 as we all knew. Happy for WNL, Act-Age, Kimetsu and my series being there.

And guys, Jujutsu Kaisen is quite low on the last issues, isn't it? Or I'm remembering bad? lol

 

[TyVip]

No, Sket Dance 2nd poll had 4 male 6 females in the top 10.

Edit: oops misread the last statement (battle shounen).

 

[Nemesis]

Black Clover popularity poll

Spoiler

1st Asta 2971
2nd Yami 2213
3rd Noel 1864
4th Yuno 1628
5th Mereoleona 1231
6th Charlotte 1156
7th Charmy 986
8th Mimosa 885
9th Luck 842
10th Gauche 791

Good top 10 overall. Mereoleona being there is great, as well as Mimosa, Charlotte and Charmy but where the hell is Noelle? lol

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 4, 2019, Original Post Date: Jul 4, 2019 ---

No, Sket Dance 2nd poll had 4 male 6 females in the top 10.

Sket Dance isn't a battle shounen tho

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

No, Sket Dance 2nd poll had 4 male 6 females in the top 10.

Edit: oops misread the last statement (battle shounen).

Sket Dance isn't a battle shounen.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 4, 2019, Original Post Date: Jul 4, 2019 ---

Good top 10 overall. Mereoleona being there is great, as well as Mimosa, Charlotte and Charmy but where the hell is Noelle? lol

3rd lol

 

[TxxT]

My Hero Academia Movie 2 is called HEROES: RISING and its set to release Dec 20, 2019

 

[El Jacco]

Welp, Double Taisei was on bottom 5 as we all knew. Happy for WNL, Act-Age, Kimetsu and my series being there.

And guys, Jujutsu Kaisen is quite low on the last issues, isn't it? Or I'm remembering bad? lol

Jujutsu has been on the lower part for atleast 2 weeks but its usually in the middle part with Act-Age, Chainsaw, WNL and Haikyuu, so theres nothing to worry, these series seems more volatile to go up or down depending on the chapters.

 

[Halloween]

What are the chances Black Clover gets a movie?

 

[Nemesis]

Sket Dance isn't a battle shounen.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 4, 2019, Original Post Date: Jul 4, 2019 ---

3rd lol

It's written Noel. I thought it was an error for Nozel. lol

Jujutsu has been on the lower part for atleast 2 weeks but its usually in the middle part with Act-Age, Chainsaw, WNL and Haikyuu, so theres nothing to worry, these series seems more volatile to go up or down depending on the chapters.

Yeah, I'm not worried about it being axed or anything. It has good sales after all. It's more an observation about the perspective of promotion, even more when act-age is getting more compared to how they were before, which is interesting.

 

[BaNChiGay]

My Hero Academia Movie 2 is called HEROES: RISING and its set to release Dec 20, 2019

Dummer. I really want MHA Fantasy AU.

 

[Rain Spectre]

What are the chances Black Clover gets a movie?

None unless you have a method of fixing Perriot's staffing issues.

 

[BaNChiGay]

What are the chances Black Clover gets a movie?

BC anime production is barely passing by, having a movie is just recipe for a disaster. In case different Studio, I doubt Clown will accept that I also doubt BC movie can pull profit.

 

[revo68]

WSJ Issue 32 TOC

Black Clover (LCP)
Dr STONE
One Piece
Kimetsu no Yaiba
The Promised Neverland
Samurai 8 (CP)
We Never Learn
My Hero Academia
Hinomaru Sumo
Act Age
Spy x Family (CP)
Chainsaw Man (CP)
Tokyo Shinobi Squad
Haikyu!!
Jujutsu Kaisen
Yuuna
Double Taisei
Yui Kamio
Beast Children
Last Saiyuki

Issue 33:
Cover/LCP - My Hero Academia
CP - Haikyu!!, We Never Learn (poll), Mori King (one shot)
One Piece (absent)

Oneshot author is Hasegawa Tomohiro (Spring Weapon No.1)

 

[Rain Spectre]

Oneshot author is Hasegawa Tomohiro (Spring Weapon No. 1)

Huh, interesting...anyone here read Spring Weapon?

 

[El Jacco]

My Hero Academia Movie 2 is called HEROES: RISING and its set to release Dec 20, 2019

Against Star Wars.... Good luck.