I mean, if someone had a reason to think you weren't actually BP or verifiable proof (meaning someone saw that you targeted someone or a detective who knows their sanity). It would depend on game size too I guess.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I'm lost...Tbh, if Lulu, Gary and Ust would be on the same team I would be so unsurprised
Yes, I suspected you and I tried to make you crack in your lies as a mafia. As you said, you already spelled out your role in hints and what you said yet still refused to directly say it. It is very suspicious. That's a play asuming the mafia are dumb and won't understand that all the other people reading your posts are understanding. You are either mafia or same as Holt and very proud of yourself.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Just how it made me suspicious? Write me a list please.
Well, you're not the first. Plus, pets don't tell me what to do...they're pets!
---------- Post added at 12:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:18 AM ----------
idk dude, there are so many sparse people and nothing really concrete to go off of here from my pov, so I guess I'll probably be on the chopping block
---------- Post added at 02:30 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:19 AM ----------
I'd like to vote for Piplup, but on the offchance his hint is legit, I won't.
Votekill Hardy - has laid low a bit, only appearing here and there...more of a placeholder for now. I would have voted for others with even less recent contributions (Ust mainly), but that's not really indicative of anything perhaps.
Oooooh, really, Holt? I think this is a good idea. If we lynch Uste and he is bulletproof, then we can assume you're lying. I like this new development. And it goes along with my weird vibe about Uste and his mustache.
Votekill Ustegius (again)
Lmao could Santa gift himself? If so, he could have been the second anon vote
---------- Post added at 03:59 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:56 PM ----------
I'm very inclined to believe this rhetoric (since it's actually the most substantial thing we have right now).
About to travel a bit, so I'll try to read back some pages, maybe we'll find something.
For now,
votekill Ust
Yes, I did suspect you. I do not consider you a very good player. Any player who in his rhetorics mainly plays on humiliating and making fun of his discussion partner is a bad player. This is one of the reasons I do not consider myself a good player, because I can get a quite petty at my worst. Explain me in list how mafia cplaying an investigative role is bad? NOTE you did not claim your role. You played as if mortician, but never answered direct questions! Also you use the term of claiming a role, not revealing or telling a role. That's in my always a questionable choice of wording.
Because that's how your behaviour came across. But you've re-think your choice of play and respect for that. If you read my posts above, I've also trying to explain why I wouldn't play as I play now if I were mafia, it's not my only point anymore.
I see you are finally resorting to getting personal here yatta! Uh so you want me to actually spell it out on day 2 hey i am mortician? The reason why I didnt reveal my exact role right away is to weed out the pro-active mafia members such as yourself,who simply can't pass an opportunity to find out a detective, which I wasn't and then you put me on your clear list right away, meaning I am not worthy killing for now. Makes sense that you would rather lynch me in day than having to kill me during night I guess. And I hinted that I investigate dead players, not sure what else did you need.
I don't doubt him either really. He is very nice and calm.
Unlike you...
Well usually from my XP during the past games when somebody claimed something and then sbd else came and said the same role then the first one was more suspicious (ofc docs and detectives there are more but there wasnt a game with two BPs)
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
You dont have anything to do with the BP claim I never said you did
Use the violet theme makes the forums look decent
Exactly. You said you investigate dead players. The mafia read that too! So WHY do you need to still deny being a mortician at that point? Because you could have been a mafia, leaving the backdoor open to say that you never claimed Mortician. You've done that before too, if I recall correctly.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
What about that barkeeper play?
--- Double Post Merged, ---
And unlike you as well.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
The barkeeper play was different since there were no 2 barkeepers now there are 2 BPs and I believe that if it wasnt you but if somebody else did it you would suspect them just like we suspect you
