Fantasy Battle of the Queens

[BluePegasus]

Battle of the Queens

The queens of Ishgar fight it out in a battle royale.

Erza Scarlet

Magic
Requip: The Knight

Mirajane Strauss

Magic
Take-Over: Satan Soul, Take-Over: Sitri Soul, Take-Over: Seilah Soul, Take-Over: Alegria Soul

Lucy Heartfillia

Magic
Celestial Spirit Magic, Star Dress

Kagura Mikazuchi

Magic
Gravity Magic

Requipment
Archenemy

Minerva Orland

Magic
Territory, Yakuma Eighteen God War Magic

Which woman takes the crown? It what order will the others go down?

 

[Hermit]

Queen Erza
If I was to rank them in Power rankings it would be something like:
Erza>Kagura>Mirajane=Minerva>Lucy

 

[The President]

Power wise:
1) Erza
2) Kagura
3) Mirajane
4) Minerva
5) Lucy

The ones who are most likely to win:
1) Minerva
2) Erza
3) Kagura
4) Mirajane
5) Lucy

Erza is a head above the rest but Minerva takes the cake for a free-for-all for the simple fact that she can avoid most of the battle via teleportation and given the numbers of contestants here its unlikely that they will notice her absence until at least two girls are down. At which point everyone should already be decently worn out. Erza and Kagura are also at the disadvantage in the fact that they can only do single unit combat, whereas the other three can hit all their targets at once. Lucy is actually probably the worst one off here by a lot since in a free-for-all with 5 participants she will inevitably have to engage in CQC herself and her spirits get downed extremely quickly. Miras Algeria is virtually unusable here so her trump card is a non-factor. Kaguras speed should keep her in the game longer then Mirajane and Lucy.

 

[Belserion]

Queen Erza
If I was to rank them in Power rankings it would be something like:
Erza>Kagura>Mirajane=Minerva>Lucy

You think Kagura is stronger than Mira? I would switch them around tbh. But basically yeah I agree.

 

[Brandish μ]

Queen of Fairies wins it.

Minerva down first or last depending on her territory (runs away). Then Lucy, then Mira or Kagura.

Belserion blood too strong.

 

[Static]

Tbh I agree with @Dr. Monty Minerva wins because of how the situation is but power wise Erza is the strongest.

 

[Summer]

Sadly, Mira macro all of them. Easy win for her

 

[xMage]

While Erza does not receive a new power up, Mirajane is still the strongest of these, but will always be underestimated, so who will win in this vote is Erza ....
Kagura and Minerva tie third for me.
And Lucy at last.

Translator

 

[Asorx]

Lucy CSK ONE SHOT THEM ! Or MIra with Macro. XDD

 

[Hermit]

You think Kagura is stronger than Mira? I would switch them around tbh. But basically yeah I agree.

Sorta, but not by a large margin.
Kagura has some pretty decent feats against Spriggan 12 level opponents (cutting down Wahl's missiles, reacting to Dimaria's point blank attack and recently, being able to put up a decent fight against one of the top 3 and not immediately being taken down by his pleasure magic)
I'd say those are better than Mirajane's feats this arc so Kagura is stronger than her.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Mirajane wins.


she just Macro's them all to kill themselves.

 

[Takuan]

I completely lost faith in hacks after Natsu walked freely during Age Seal, in Base. Hence i'm not giving too much credit to Mirajane's Macro, especially added to the fact that she never used it against a worthy opponent.
My vote goes for Erza, as i don't believe Minerva has a chance even after hiding. She might have defeated a Historia but i definitely don't think she's Erza level anymore. Realistically she could only defeat Lucy by stealing her keys, that's about it at this point.
I'd say Erza > Kagura > Mirajane > Minerva > Lucy.

Wait, this is exactly @Emperor Spriggan 's order, what a coincidence

 

[Hermit]

I completely lost faith in hacks after Natsu walked freely during Age Seal, in Base. Hence i'm not giving too much credit to Mirajane's Macro, especially added to the fact that she never used it against a worthy opponent.

Pretty much this, I think the reason people think Macro is powerful is because in Tartaros a half dead Sayla used it on 2 S-class Wizards who were still at full power, but that's Sayla's Macro.
Mirajane's Macro imo is less superior than hers, so I don't exactly see how she can maintain it on 5 strong opponents enough to get her the win here.

 

[The President]

Saylas macro didnt decrease with her state of injury. She either controls her opponents or she doesnt and it just so happened that she was powerful enough to do so in the Tartarus arc. I also doubt that Mira is worse then Sayla at macro given that she literally has her body, but I also doubt she is any better so her cap macro off at being able to affect Tartarus Erza characters and below, a level even Lucy has surpassed at this point (and Lucy is the weakest here). Plus going Sayla holds a disadvantage........her shitty ass durability.

 

[Laxus chan-yo]

Erza >> Kagura > Mirajane > Lucy = Minerva

Lucy has made tremendous gains so she is on par with Minerva imo especially since Minerva couldn't even beat Wahl's Historia which is canonically only a fraction of his power. Erza though is miles ahead of the rest.

 

[Arjuna]

Erza wins this.She is the strongest here.In GMG she defeated Minerva.And in Alvarez arc the difference between Fairytail characters and other Guilds increased.

 

[Cosmicstar]

Erza has the highest chance of winning but however Lucy has tricks that can counter Erza and Minerva and easily take them out of battle.

Gemini has already copied Marin who can stop both Erza and Minerva from using their powers and even send them to another dimension taking them out of the battle. Also Minerva isn't going to be able to easily take away Lucy's keys given Lucy has went from been naked to pulling keys out of nowhere. The only issue here for Lucy here is Kagura, I would argue that Lucy and Erza at this point have a similar level of magical power. Lucy uses her Gemini stardress to turn into Erza and low diff Kagura. Mirajane is a none factor. Mirajane's nukes wouldn't even get past Lucy's Aquarius water shield or Horologium.

Either way though overall power:

Erza
Kagura/Minerva/Lucy
Mirajane

Mirajane hands down is the weakest given she has the worst stamina, durability and attack power of this group. Erza/Lucy/Minerva/Kagura have all held their own against a Spriggan 12 member without the BS of oh look boobies. Which is the only reason Jacob has of yet take out Mirajane.

Attack Power:
1. Nakagami Slash/Crimson Sword
2. Urano Metria
3. Kagura Unsheathed Sword/Minerva's God nuke
4,Soul Extinction/Algeria punch

Magical power:
1. Lucy/Erza: Summoned Nakagami a powerful armor that consumes alot of magical power. Summoned the CSK which requires alot of magical power.
2. Mirajane/Kagura/Minerva: The only reason Mirajane is on this level is the hype Hyien and Juilete gave her about her magical power drying up the sea.


Defense:
1. Lucy: Horologium which can protect against a Spriggan level attack. Aquarius water shield which protected her against Jackal's nukes.
2. Erza: Her armors give her certain resistance towards certain attacks.
3. Minerva: Was able to teleport a LDF punch from Natsu with ease. Probably has the best defensive capability actually.

Mirajane/Kagura don't have any defensive powers.

 

[LighteningLord]

Power wise:
Erza
Mira = Kagura
Minerva
Lucy

Beauty wise
Mirajane
Erza
Lucy
Kagura
Minerva

On whole somehow Erza tops though

 

[Kouichi]

Lmfao, 'Mira's durability is worse and attack power'. Sounds ridiculous since Mira is still up and fighting Jacob given that she was pierced by August's Laser, Brandish only made the wound smaller, not completely healed her. Stop downplaying mate.

Anyways Erza will win this. Erza>>Kagura>Mira>Minerva>=Lucy

 

[Boomburst]

Lmfao, 'Mira's durability is worse and attack power'. Sounds ridiculous since Mira is still up and fighting Jacob given that she was pierced by August's Laser, Brandish only made the wound smaller, not completely healed her. Stop downplaying mate.

Anyways Erza will win this. Erza>>Kagura>Mira>Minerva>=Lucy

She's still up and fighting against an opponent who not only isn't using any magic but who is literally fighting with his eyes closed. Not exactly impressive.