Jellal and Erza vs Laxus and Mira

  • Jerza

    Votes: 20 64.5%
  • Miraxus

    Votes: 8 25.8%
  • Draw

    Votes: 2 6.5%
  • Results

    Votes: 1 3.2%

  • Total voters
    31

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
The absence of proof is not proof. Gray did his best according to Juvia and given that DeS is a staple in his style now (and Mira's a demon though we don't know the extent to his advantage over her so I am putting this in brackets) so it's understood that he used his full power. The only reason people need Gray to hold back his devil slaying power is that so their headcanon that Gray > Mira stays intact. I mean people are already disappointed that Erza's still above him after everyone thought Gray surpassed everyone in the final arc. So someone like Mira added to the list of people above him is an issue.

Also, Occam's razor- the outcome that requires the least assumptions is likely the accurate scenario which in this case would be that Gray went all out and struggled to beat a beat up Mirajane.

Gray holding back his DeS power requires:
-Juvia to not be referring to his best even though she said best and failing to mention him not using DeS
-Gray struggling while holding back for no reason since the goal was to defeat Mirajane
-Cana to be mocking him about struggling even though she knows he held back and her not mentioning it for whatever reason.


Gray not holding back requires no assumptions of the unknown since Cana, Juvia and even Gray's statements from that chapter and even chapters before already support that along with Mira's feats: He did his best; he struggled against a beat up opponent; Mira was the opponent hence the struggle; Freezing her would be like freezing Skullion; Mirajane would be a pain/tough; BSS Mira = Skullion who easily handled Gray with his DeS powers so a beat up Mira still put up a difficult fight since she is on that level.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Gray probably had a couple minutes, lol. His mp isn't gonna magically fill back up. And it wasn't an extreme diff. @Axiomus already said that.

I guess by equals you think both fighters would be knocked out at the same time if they fought? So Jellal and Laxus would simultaneously knock each other out?
No by equals I think either they both get knocked out after starting fresh or one person loses extreme diff. Erza passing out first, failing to beat him with her new powers, him already using some of his power moments before on Kyria and Laxus getting up and holding a battered Erza right now, all after Erza said that she could probably beat him with Natsu or Gray with her all lead me to believe that Erza is not his equal.

And Jellal and Laxus being equals to me would mean that none of them would need to reveal a new power to still fight off the other only to fall first and not wake up while the opponent is up and carrying them. Jellal and Laxus being equals to me would also mean that after they both are at full health and power we see a fight that ends with a double K.O. or one person falling before the other falls or limps off and in the event that they both fall together they wake up around the same time with the same level of injuries.
 
Last edited:

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Erza said that she could probably beat him with Natsu or Gray with her all lead me to believe that Erza is not his equal.
She was referring to the orb.
 

Aurelius

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
3,154
Reaction score
8,864
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Alright I guess we all just have our own interpretations of equals. It's cool and I'll just leave it at that.
 
Last edited:

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Alright I guess we all just have our own interpretations of equals. I'll just leave it at that
Though I'd say there are no equals in the guild. It's complete hierarchy.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
She was referring to the orb.
Well either way we saw her use Natsu and Gray's powers in the form of her new power up and Laxus won when he just finished beating Kyria. She fell first and now he's awake carrying her and fighting off wood clones while she's still out.
 

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Well either way we saw her use Natsu and Gray's powers in the form of her new power up and Laxus won when he just finished beating Kyria. She fell first and now he's awake carrying her and fighting off wood clones while she's still out.
Yep/
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
The absence of proof is not proof. Gray did his best according to Juvia and given that DeS is a staple in his style now (and Mira's a demon though we don't know the extent to his advantage over her so I am putting this in brackets) so it's understood that he used his full power. The only reason people need Gray to hold back his devil slaying power is that so their headcanon that Gray > Mira stays intact. I mean people are already disappointed that Erza's still above him after everyone thought Gray surpassed everyone in the final arc. So someone like Mira added to the list of people above him is an issue.

Also, Occam's razor- the outcome that requires the least assumptions is likely the accurate scenario which in this case would be that Gray went all out and struggled to beat a beat up Mirajane.

Gray holding back his DeS power requires:
-Juvia to not be referring to his best even though she said best and failing to mention him not using DeS
-Gray struggling while holding back for no reason since the goal was to defeat Mirajane
-Cana to be mocking him about struggling even though she knows he held back and her not mentioning it for whatever reason.


Gray not holding back requires no assumptions of the unknown since Cana, Juvia and even Gray's statements from that chapter and even chapters before already support that along with Mira's feats: He did his best; he struggled against a beat up opponent; Mira was the opponent hence the struggle; Freezing her would be like freezing Skullion; Mirajane would be a pain/tough; BSS Mira = Skullion who easily handled Gray with his DeS powers so a beat up Mira still put up a difficult fight since she is on that level.
Not sure what you're arguing here. Most people agree that Mirajane is above Gray.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Leave it alone.
I hope you do the same.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Not sure what you're arguing here. Most people agree that Mirajane is above Gray.
In an earlier post that person had actually mentioned Gray and Mira and directed it at me so I said my thoughts on the Gray and Mira debacle again.
 
Last edited:

kian

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2020
Messages
630
Reaction score
1,384
Gender
Male
Country
Dragonstone
Nah what happened was that Mira in her weakest form, could barely breathe, fought a 100% fully healthy Gray that was under an extreme PoF boost and she gave him an extreme diff fight.More extreme than Laxus v Erza. So it's basically confirmed that Mira is a top character in FT because she has outdated curse.

@Axiomus Told me.
This whole exaggeration gag you constantly recycle stopped being funny a while ago. pretty cringe
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,582
Reaction score
10,159
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
It didn't affect him though. Whether he used it or not wouldn't have drastically changed the outcome. Also, she was holding back majority of the fight anyways.



Proof? Nothing suggests that.



No he wouldn't.
1. But in the end, she used up all her magic. So that becomes moot.
It's like this: initially Erza was using magic at a lower rate (because she was "holding back"), then she used it at a higher rate. In the end, she expended it all.......i.e she used up everything in her.
But Laxus would still have some magic power left.
Also, even after the gauntlet, it was Erza who fell on her knees and passed out. Laxus rested voluntarily after Erza was defeated, he still could've gone for a bit more. The fact that he got up soon after and is now carrying her ass is proof.

2. Logic? How else did she get them, other than enchanting it beforehand? Wtf?
Of course she needs to pre prep them, because that's not her own magic. Sure, she can enchant on her own, but TO enchant different magic than her own into her swords, of course she needs the source.

3. Yes he would. He took on Erza after dealing with Kiria. He would have the magic he used on Kiria afterwards, if the order was reversed.
 

Kiki

MIRAXUS FOREVER
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Mangahelper
Joined
Aug 23, 2015
Messages
9,678
Reaction score
32,123
Age
33
Gender
Male
Country
Fairy Tail
Moderator Notice:
No calling name please. No such "Plotsu", "Plotza", "Macrologia", "Gray/Mira fans/wanker" etc please. Please prove yourself as a decent debater. Anyone who violates forum rules and etiquette will be dealt with accordingly. This forum has no place for breakers. And if someone makes a thread just for ganging up on a user/character, the thread will be deleted immediately. Thanks~ Kiki
 
Last edited:

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
This whole exaggeration gag you constantly recycle stopped being funny a while ago. pretty cringe
Lmaoooo, funny enough for you to respond.

Pretty cringe when I hear that Macro might work on Mercphobia. Come up with decent arguments and I might stop.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

1. But in the end, she used up all her magic. So that becomes moot.
It's like this: initially Erza was using magic at a lower rate (because she was "holding back"), then she used it at a higher rate. In the end, she expended it all.......i.e she used up everything in her.
But Laxus would still have some magic power left.
Also, even after the gauntlet, it was Erza who fell on her knees and passed out. Laxus rested voluntarily after Erza was defeated, he still could've gone for a bit more. The fact that he got up soon after and is now carrying her ass is proof.

2. Logic? How else did she get them, other than enchanting it beforehand? Wtf?
Of course she needs to pre prep them, because that's not her own magic. Sure, she can enchant on her own, but TO enchant different magic than her own into her swords, of course she needs the source.

3. Yes he would. He took on Erza after dealing with Kiria. He would have the magic he used on Kiria afterwards, if the order was reversed.
1) Wrong. Laxus couldn't do anything after the fight.

2) Not really. She brought them out of nowhere. Plus, now that they've been used once, she can use them whenever just like anything else.

3) No he wouldn't.
 
Last edited:

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Laxus is above Erza, though only slightly. The argument here is simply that Laxus used a certain amount of magic power fighting Kyria. If he hadn't fought Kyria and saved that magic power, he wouldn't have been completely out of power at the end of their clash with heaven's wheel and red lightning. He'd have enough magic power to cast a secret art.

Erza's katanas are part of her arsenal now. Yes, it required some amount of prep to enchant them the first time around. But now they are items in her arsenal. Unless they break, then Erza should be able to whip them out at any time and use them. Just like she can use Belserion at any time now.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

This whole exaggeration gag you constantly recycle stopped being funny a while ago. pretty cringe
The thing is, MUI's not really even exaggerating. People were saying that Mirajane was weakened and almost defeated, and that Gray was at his absolute peak.

In an earlier post that person had actually mentioned Gray and Mira and directed it at me so I said my thoughts on the Gray and Mira debacle again.
But again, nobody is saying that Gray is stronger than Mirajane. Beno asked you why you would consider Gray at full power after usining up some magic fighting the Thunder Tribe, if you don't consider Laxus at full power. Just because Juvia said "you tried your best", it doesn't mean that Gray had a full tank of magic. I'm not sure how Gray's overall power level in comparison with characters like Erza ties into this.
 

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
The thing is, MUI's not really even exaggerating. People were saying that Mirajane was weakened and almost defeated, and that Gray was at his absolute peak.
Thank you. Someone that can read. Plus, when people say Macro might work on Merc then what do you want me to do?
 

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,075
Reaction score
1,130
Age
36
Country
United States
The absence of proof is not proof. Gray did his best according to Juvia and given that DeS is a staple in his style now (and Mira's a demon though we don't know the extent to his advantage over her so I am putting this in brackets) so it's understood that he used his full power. The only reason people need Gray to hold back his devil slaying power is that so their headcanon that Gray > Mira stays intact. I mean people are already disappointed that Erza's still above him after everyone thought Gray surpassed everyone in the final arc. So someone like Mira added to the list of people above him is an issue.

Also, Occam's razor- the outcome that requires the least assumptions is likely the accurate scenario which in this case would be that Gray went all out and struggled to beat a beat up Mirajane.

Gray holding back his DeS power requires:
-Juvia to not be referring to his best even though she said best and failing to mention him not using DeS
-Gray struggling while holding back for no reason since the goal was to defeat Mirajane
-Cana to be mocking him about struggling even though she knows he held back and her not mentioning it for whatever reason.


Gray not holding back requires no assumptions of the unknown since Cana, Juvia and even Gray's statements from that chapter and even chapters before already support that along with Mira's feats: He did his best; he struggled against a beat up opponent; Mira was the opponent hence the struggle; Freezing her would be like freezing Skullion; Mirajane would be a pain/tough; BSS Mira = Skullion who easily handled Gray with his DeS powers so a beat up Mira still put up a difficult fight since she is on that level.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---



No by equals I think either they both get knocked out after starting fresh or one person loses extreme diff. Erza passing out first, failing to beat him with her new powers, him already using some of his power moments before on Kyria and Laxus getting up and holding a battered Erza right now, all after Erza said that she could probably beat him with Natsu or Gray with her all lead me to believe that Erza is not his equal.

And Jellal and Laxus being equals to me would mean that none of them would need to reveal a new power to still fight off the other only to fall first and not wake up while the opponent is up and carrying them. Jellal and Laxus being equals to me would also mean that after they both are at full health and power we see a fight that ends with a double K.O. or one person falling before the other falls or limps off and in the event that they both fall together they wake up around the same time with the same level of injuries.
Well either way we saw her use Natsu and Gray's powers in the form of her new power up and Laxus won when he just finished beating Kyria. She fell first and now he's awake carrying her and fighting off wood clones while she's still out.
Didn't laxus also used a new power up
Didn't he say he can't put Erza down without it
The fun part here is we don't even know if jellal can give a mid diff fight to laxus, let alone a double ko

Also I like how people ignore laxus holding back statement
--- Double Post Merged, ---

2. Logic? How else did she get them, other than enchanting it beforehand? Wtf?
Of course she needs to pre prep them, because that's not her own magic. Sure, she can enchant on her own, but TO enchant different magic than her own into her swords, of course she needs the source.
Provided what you say is true, how much did prepping natsu and gray power boost Erza?
Meaning remove fire and ice sword, with what difficulty would laxus beat Erza in the exact same situation?
 

Ramen

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
8,002
Reaction score
8,498
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Provided what you say is true, how much did prepping natsu and gray power boost Erza?
Meaning remove fire and ice sword, with what difficulty would laxus beat Erza in the exact same situation?
IIRC she only used them for like two hits then switched to HW
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Laxus is above Erza, though only slightly. The argument here is simply that Laxus used a certain amount of magic power fighting Kyria. If he hadn't fought Kyria and saved that magic power, he wouldn't have been completely out of power at the end of their clash with heaven's wheel and red lightning. He'd have enough magic power to cast a secret art.

Erza's katanas are part of her arsenal now. Yes, it required some amount of prep to enchant them the first time around. But now they are items in her arsenal. Unless they break, then Erza should be able to whip them out at any time and use them. Just like she can use Belserion at any time now.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


The thing is, MUI's not really even exaggerating. People were saying that Mirajane was weakened and almost defeated, and that Gray was at his absolute peak.



But again, nobody is saying that Gray is stronger than Mirajane. Beno asked you why you would consider Gray at full power after usining up some magic fighting the Thunder Tribe, if you don't consider Laxus at full power. Just because Juvia said "you tried your best", it doesn't mean that Gray had a full tank of magic. I'm not sure how Gray's overall power level in comparison with characters like Erza ties into this.
I never considered Gray at full power but Mirajane was severely handicapped compared to him and even Laxus and Erza. He was closer to being a full power than she was which is why I brought up his previous statements etc regarding her which denoted that she is stronger and would even win in a fight despite what people on this forum think (Gray was as badly off as her, they are on the same level, he would beat her even if they are fresh;he didn't use his devil Slayer power etc.) .

The difference is that Laxus who used some power and immediately fought fresh Erza while Gray used some powern and then a while later was up against a heavily injured Mirajane.
 
Last edited:
Top