Yakkun

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
4,418
Reaction score
4,334
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
I know noone gives a shit about it but I'm glad Gawain got that promised pudding after all.

Perci is kinda right tho, the way it's presented in that barrel looks absolutely vile lmao
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,828
Reaction score
61,579
Gender
Male
Country
France
Design B is really cool. Would like to see it used for another character.
 

Zerodx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2018
Messages
625
Reaction score
591
Age
29
Country
Indonesia
The first 4 page already leaked on twitter
 

Vortigern

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
786
Reaction score
1,818
Age
31
Country
Finland
As for Satan, the dragon of Chaos, the serpent, the monster from the sea, mark of the beast, etc. I can see how Nakaba can make use of an object he introduced in the first xhapter of NnT and make it the big bad of the collective universe, but since dragon handle being the Chaos fragment feels like an asspull by itself, I can't have high hope of this scenario. Not to mention that Satan is not a greater being than god in at least Abrahamic religions. Consequently, in the presence of Chaos as the creator of everything, FV being satan seems like a demotion of the antagonist.
The other problem is that Nakaba has always been more interested in Arthurian legends than anything else. I don't think he gets too much involved with religion in his epic retelling of Arthur's legend. Mordred has a higher chance of being the FV than Satan.
While I agree that it could have been established earlier, I'm not sure if I'd call it an asspull. When the Coffin was first introduced back in chapter 61 of NnT it was also immediately explained that all the major non-demon clans came together to create it. At the time I didn't think much of it, but in hindsight the fact that this random dragon seemingly unrelated to any of the clans was the prominent centerpiece of the whole thing should have raised some eyebrows. I wouldn't go so far as to claim that Nakaba must have already had a long term plan for the dragon handle, but there had to have been some reason behind that specific design decision. And yeah, I also think that Mordred is a more likely option than Satan.

Let's clear things out a bit. By main plot, I mean the one that involves the adventures of the antagonist as they face will various challenges and trials that are directly or indirectly created by the efforts or activities of the final villain or those who directly serve them. You see how everything in NnT was sidelined, overshadowed, or even neglected when Mel vs DK became the focus of the story? MnYK is supposed to have at least 4 main story lines and the most pivotal one of them is that of Percy vs (?) Followed by the other three knights vs their respective NEMESES.
The closer you are to the either MC or FV, you are more relevant to the main plot of the story. That's not an insult or a bad thing, just the reality of characters who are not part of either team. It also works for the antagonists as well. Jelamet, six knoghts of black, or Izraf were antagonist of branching story lines, so they never felt as crucial to the story as the likes of Hendy or the 10C. But they served their purpose and became an inseparable part of NnT verse.
I see what you mean and I agree with most of what you're saying, but I still don't think anything so far significantly limits the potential role of King&Diane's kid. The only thing we can be fairly certain of at this stage is that they're not part of the main 4, but for all we know they could be right behind at number 5, which would arguably still make them a bigger deal than what their mother was in NnT(despite debuting in chapter 4). It all depends on how their personal conflict interacts with the main story, which is likely not limited to this war against Camelot.

If the story begins in the realms of humans, get other races involved, and ends as they separate from each other leaving Britannia and the realm of humans as the final place of focus in let say it's final act, all the the main cast consists mostly humans and half humans (Tristan may still be the exception), it in fact means the main focus of story is on humans.

By the way, I seriously think you guys are giving that anime introduction too much credit. I know Nakaba can see that far ahead in the future, but the fact that he never addressed the same concept in manga is a bit suspicious.
I'd argue your view on the focus of the story might be a little too narrow. The focus of NnT was clearly on the demon clan and their effect on the world, despite the fact that there was only one actual demon in the main cast and that they never even visited the Demon Realm during the story. Most of the cast didn't have much of a connection to the demons except through their association with Meliodas, whose race wasn't actually that big of a deal. This might sound odd at first, but consider that the important thing about Meliodas was not just that he was a demon, but that he was the son of the DK and also the former leader of the TC. It was about his special status, not race, which is why his role would have been totally different had he instead been a random civilian demon like Derieri's sister.

The same thing applies King whose fairy heritage was relevant due to his position as the leader of his clan. Diane is a giant, but her involvement with her clan was never a big deal because it was almost entirely confined to her side story. And what about Ban? He's human, but I can't remember that ever being relevant to anything. He had more to do with the fairies than with other humans. Even when it comes to hybrids, there's no reason to assume that the human side is going to be the more important one. Elizabeth called herself a half-human, but her goddess side was always much more important to the story. What I'm trying to say is, it's ultimately not the races of the main characters that matter, but their personal goals and the nature of the greater conflict they're involved in. (As a side note, I just noticed that I'm basically making an argument against Arthur's race-based view of the world here. On a meta level, Nakaba can't call out Arthur for his human supremacy if he as the author also favors humans over the other clans.)

As for the separation of the realms, I can't remember Nakaba exploring the concept in the manga directly either, but he did bring it up in the Q&A corner of chapter 5 of the sequel. That chapter just so happened to be the same chapter where Sin introduced the Four Knights of the Apocalypse and said that they will destroy the world. Seems like Nakaba was trying to send a not-so-subtle message there.

It's amazing how LoL is seen as a very unimportant character by the majority of fandom. Among the three entities related to Chaos, she was the only one who actively planned for it's revival. Cath was spending time in a cave for an unknown reason, and only met Arthur by chance! Hawk mama was wandering the land randomly helpeing some people or clans when she felt like it! Helped the sky people seal demons for no reason only to become the walking base of operation for another demon for no reason.
I wouldn't call her unimportant, since she is one of the major Arthurian figures in the series and has already had an impact on things through Excalibur and more recently Lancelot's disappearance. I just don't believe there's anything pointing to her being an antagonist so far. She clearly has some kind of a goal that she tries to steer things towards, but that doesn't have to be malicious. Merlin played a very similar role and she wasn't really opposed to the Sins either. She is on the antagonist side now, but she didn't seem very happy the last time we saw her, so I wouldn't be so sure that she's even actually on board with any of this. That said, I don't think making the Lady of the Lake a villain would be a bad idea. Her connection to Lake Salisbury could lend itself to some interesting battles, like her moving the entire lake around as a giant blob of water and trying to drown people in its magical depths.
 

Mighty Escanor

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
757
Reaction score
2,225
Country
Winterfell
While I agree that it could have been established earlier, I'm not sure if I'd call it an asspull. When the Coffin was first introduced back in chapter 61 of NnT it was also immediately explained that all the major non-demon clans came together to create it. At the time I didn't think much of it, but in hindsight the fact that this random dragon seemingly unrelated to any of the clans was the prominent centerpiece of the whole thing should have raised some eyebrows. I wouldn't go so far as to claim that Nakaba must have already had a long term plan for the dragon handle, but there had to have been some reason behind that specific design decision. And yeah, I also think that Mordred is a more likely option than Satan.
I call it an asspull because it contradicts the lore itself. The way CoED was explained in MnYK was like it's common knowledge. As if everyone know the meaning of the dragon handle.

In NnT, other than a number of stories and myth about mother of chaos or Oshiro Sama, people knew nothing about the true nature of Choas and it's place in the universe.

Merlin didn't talk about Chaos to the seven deadly sins, and even if we believe Dabuzu should know about it to craft CoED, nothing implies he told other people about the connection between chaos and dragon handle.

Sure it became common knowledge after Chaos was unsealed, but it was better to be revealed in the current timeline. Like after they found Dabuzu or crossed path wuth Merlin, this kind of info was revealed to anyone. But whoever leaked the info, did it off screen, which means Nakaba didn't put much effort to make better use of this element. So he literally pulled it out of his ass only to shove it up into that of MnYK.

As for the lack of connection, it could easily be the symbol of the demon clan, who was sealed by the combined efforts of the other four clans. So four pieces representing the other four encircle the dragon handle which means the clan of demons. The dragon is surrounded by a goddess, a fairy, a giant, and a number of humans. Didn't it show the function of CoED more beautifully?

I see what you mean and I agree with most of what you're saying, but I still don't think anything so far significantly limits the potential role of King&Diane's kid. The only thing we can be fairly certain of at this stage is that they're not part of the main 4, but for all we know they could be right behind at number 5, which would arguably still make them a bigger deal than what their mother was in NnT(despite debuting in chapter 4). It all depends on how their personal conflict interacts with the main story, which is likely not limited to this war against Camelot.
Oh don't take me wrong. I won't be satisfied if Kiane kids don't have an important role in MnYK. As much as I hate King, I'm ready to accept the kids's importance whenever they show up. Nakaba himself knows about this necessity, so he's mentioned them in at least two different occasions iirc. Let's not different words lead us to disagreement. We both think high if them and expect them to play a big part in the story, let it be a main one or a parallel one.

By the way, those who could easily be the 8th in NnT were reduced to ash due to unknown reasons, the most obvious example being Mael in the final arcs.

I'd argue your view on the focus of the story might be a little too narrow. The focus of NnT was clearly on the demon clan and their effect on the world, despite the fact that there was only one actual demon in the main cast and that they never even visited the Demon Realm during the story. Most of the cast didn't have much of a connection to the demons except through their association with Meliodas, whose race wasn't actually that big of a deal. This might sound odd at first, but consider that the important thing about Meliodas was not just that he was a demon, but that he was the son of the DK and also the former leader of the TC. It was about his special status, not race, which is why his role would have been totally different had he instead been a random civilian demon like Derieri's sister.

The same thing applies King whose fairy heritage was relevant due to his position as the leader of his clan. Diane is a giant, but her involvement with her clan was never a big deal because it was almost entirely confined to her side story. And what about Ban? He's human, but I can't remember that ever being relevant to anything. He had more to do with the fairies than with other humans. Even when it comes to hybrids, there's no reason to assume that the human side is going to be the more important one. Elizabeth called herself a half-human, but her goddess side was always much more important to the story. What I'm trying to say is, it's ultimately not the races of the main characters that matter, but their personal goals and the nature of the greater conflict they're involved in. (As a side note, I just noticed that I'm basically making an argument against Arthur's race-based view of the world here. On a meta level, Nakaba can't call out Arthur for his human supremacy if he as the author also favors humans over the other clans.)
About this one, let's agree to disagree!

As for the separation of the realms, I can't remember Nakaba exploring the concept in the manga directly either, but he did bring it up in the Q&A corner of chapter 5 of the sequel. That chapter just so happened to be the same chapter where Sin introduced the Four Knights of the Apocalypse and said that they will destroy the world. Seems like Nakaba was trying to send a not-so-subtle message there.
That's convincing enough. Like I said, I don't have any objection if that's the case, but I couldn't take it seriously until it was mentioned by Nakaba himself. I might've missed that one or have completely forgotten about it. So I'd be glad if you can tell me where to find it.

As for our current argument, I don't insist you provide the reference. I already accept your point.

I wouldn't call her unimportant, since she is one of the major Arthurian figures in the series and has already had an impact on things through Excalibur and more recently Lancelot's disappearance. I just don't believe there's anything pointing to her being an antagonist so far. She clearly has some kind of a goal that she tries to steer things towards, but that doesn't have to be malicious. Merlin played a very similar role and she wasn't really opposed to the Sins either. She is on the antagonist side now, but she didn't seem very happy the last time we saw her, so I wouldn't be so sure that she's even actually on board with any of this. That said, I don't think making the Lady of the Lake a villain would be a bad idea. Her connection to Lake Salisbury could lend itself to some interesting battles, like her moving the entire lake around as a giant blob of water and trying to drown people in its magical depths.
Imo, she is either a key figure on the side of the protagonists when they need a final power up to oppose chaos, or she is the master mind behind everything that is happening from 3000 years ago. She might not be The FV in this case, but I see an antagonistic LoL two at least be the villain of a major arc.

That's only my gut feeling. I can't find any evidence to back or refute it for now.

A huge ball of water swallowing anyone on her way, while I got the mockery, I think it's exactly what she is doing. She has been doing it for several years by now, the details are a bit different btw.
 

Vortigern

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
786
Reaction score
1,818
Age
31
Country
Finland
I can't remember if someone else has already pointed this out before, but it occurred to me that the place where Lancelot and Jericho were trapped for 3 years may have actually been within Lake Salisbury. On the last page of the Lancelot one-shot it was stated that Lancelot later returned as the Prince of the Lake, which means that he was almost certainly taken somewhere by the Lady of the Lake, who is connected to Lancelot in the Arthurian legends. However, we've already seen the area around Lake Salisbury where the Lady of the Lake resides and it didn't look like it would have been particularly difficult to escape from there, but what about from inside the lake itself?

When Meliodas asked her to show herself, the Lady of the Lake said that she cannot part from the lake. All she could do was manifest as a silhouette on the surface, kind of like someone on the other side of an opaque glass window. Jericho said that her and Lancelot were trapped in "the world beyond" which suggests that it was something separate from the rest of Britannia. What if the 'beyond' there actually refers to some kind of a pocket dimension that exists beyond the surface of the lake, think something like how druid village of Istar could be entered by walking through a stone arch that served as a secret gate. In this case the gate isn't a stone arch, but a distortion in the rain. Nakaba even points out through Lancelot that it was raining both when the merchant disappeared as well as when Lance and Jericho spotted what Jericho called "some sort of an entrance" in the rain. It could be that the Lady of the Lake is using the water of Lake Salisbury to create rain that can transport people to her realm within the lake.

I call it an asspull because it contradicts the lore itself. The way CoED was explained in MnYK was like it's common knowledge. As if everyone know the meaning of the dragon handle.

In NnT, other than a number of stories and myth about mother of chaos or Oshiro Sama, people knew nothing about the true nature of Choas and it's place in the universe.

Merlin didn't talk about Chaos to the seven deadly sins, and even if we believe Dabuzu should know about it to craft CoED, nothing implies he told other people about the connection between chaos and dragon handle.

Sure it became common knowledge after Chaos was unsealed, but it was better to be revealed in the current timeline. Like after they found Dabuzu or crossed path wuth Merlin, this kind of info was revealed to anyone. But whoever leaked the info, did it off screen, which means Nakaba didn't put much effort to make better use of this element. So he literally pulled it out of his ass only to shove it up into that of MnYK.

As for the lack of connection, it could easily be the symbol of the demon clan, who was sealed by the combined efforts of the other four clans. So four pieces representing the other four encircle the dragon handle which means the clan of demons. The dragon is surrounded by a goddess, a fairy, a giant, and a number of humans. Didn't it show the function of CoED more beautifully?
Hmm, that's strange. I never got the impression that the Coffin is now common knowledge. I mean Ironside had to explain what it was to the people of Sistana, and the members of Team Percival didn't seem to have any idea either. Even Anne who was trying to hide the last piece actually didn't seem to know what it was, just that Ironside was evil and shouldn't be allowed to get his way. As far as I can remember, the only people who have understood the significance of the handle or the other pieces at a glance have been holy knights of either Camelot or Liones. Camelot has Merlin on their side who could have easily informed them about it and Liones has Meliodas who is very knowledgeable as well. It makes sense that the two would inform their troops about something they knew could be used to seal away Meliodas and change the course of the war.

As for the dragon representing the demon clan, that's a pretty good interpretation especially after the Dragon's Sin was revealed to be a demon, but I'm not sure how that would fit with how the gate to the goddess realm in the Stigma HQ was decorated with dragons.
This design choice seems to suggest that dragons may actually have a connection to the goddess clan. It could even be both at the same time, similar to how Chaos is supposed to be composed of both light and darkness. Thus, a Dragon of Chaos.

That's convincing enough. Like I said, I don't have any objection if that's the case, but I couldn't take it seriously until it was mentioned by Nakaba himself. I might've missed that one or have completely forgotten about it. So I'd be glad if you can tell me where to find it.

As for our current argument, I don't insist you provide the reference. I already accept your point.
No worries, I wanted to check the source myself anyway. The Q&A for that chapter was translated by FKS here:

A huge ball of water swallowing anyone on her way, while I got the mockery, I think it's exactly what she is doing. She has been doing it for several years by now, the details are a bit different btw.
I wasn't actually trying to mock anything and I'm not sure what you thought I was referring to. I just think a magical lake that can move or fly in the air sounds cool and fantastical enough to fit the rest of the setting. Even better if some of the things I mentioned above turn out to be true and the lake is actually its own realm.
 

FKS

Mangahelper
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Mangahelper
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
3,481
Reaction score
17,102
Gender
Male
Country
France
Oh, there's another important change in the volume. I somehow missed it.
How do you like it? For your reference, here's the original page:
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

While I'm at it, here's another.
 

Yakkun

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
4,418
Reaction score
4,334
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Redrawn panels imo look better. Second one gives a better shot at Jericho's titties too. :worship2
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,828
Reaction score
61,579
Gender
Male
Country
France
I prefer the volume version of Lancelot VS Jericho. For Tristan VS Meragalan I prefer Tristan's expressions in the magazine version and Meragalan's expression in the volume one.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

 
Last edited:

Yakkun

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
4,418
Reaction score
4,334
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
I prefer the volume version of Lancelot VS Jericho. For Tristan VS Meragalan I prefer Tristan's expressions in the magazine version and Meragalan's expression in the volume one.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Nakaba saying "thank you I love you" to everyone who enjoys SDS (and it's spin-off I'd assume) around the world warms my heart a little
 

Samael Morningstar

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
4,556
Reaction score
4,471
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
While what Nakaba does with the whole Jericho lance, or lance guine, and other many such sus things

He's actually kind of a sweet guy like that "Thank you and I love you" tells a lot.
 

Rey151203

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 29, 2022
Messages
3,162
Reaction score
1,407
Age
25
Country
Brazil
Você acha que os 4 cavaleiros mostrados no capítulo 1 são iguais aos 4 cavaleiros mostrados no capítulo 6?
Porque eu ouvi essa teoria selvagem naquela época de que haveria 2 grupos de 4 cavaleiros, como Arthur e Mel estão realmente certos em sua interpretação dos 4 cavaleiros do apocalipse no sentido de que Percy, Tristan, Lance e Gawain são os bons 4 cavaleiros do apocalipse que realmente salvaria o mundo (a interpretação de Mel e dos mocinhos está certa), mas há outro grupo de 4 cavaleiros do apocalipse que destruirá o mundo (versão de Arthur e dos cavaleiros do caos se a interpretação também estiver certa e se referir a este grupo) o o grupo do mal, na verdade, permanece bastante baixo e subterrâneo e há todo esse mal-entendido entre todos em relação a toda a coisa dos 4 cavaleiros
[/CITAR]


Seeing the new chapter, (84) specifally, this now make more sense, a evil 4kota and a good 4kota groups
 
Top