- Joined
- Feb 25, 2010
- Messages
- 3,380
- Reaction score
- 2,195
- Age
- 35
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!
What? I did vote DD!
On Banana!
What? I did vote DD!
On Banana!
I think that midoban also defended you... can't remember for sureI just sharted reading that post.
So I sharted twice - first time when I read it and second time when replying to it.
Sharting is not fun.
BECAUSE I SAW SOMEONE SAY "I change my vote to" SOMETHING ELSE! AND I REMEMBER THAT WITCH VOTING FOR ME.
WHICH WAS YOU.
Check back. But I'm being unfairly accused of being a goddamn mafia or lover because FFers here suck at reading. I asked how lovers came to be, not what they do. Why the hell wouldn't I PM the host that question?
Shut up fuglett-kun.
I just wanted to know how some of the roels came to be, not what they are. Jesus. -_-
Also, I do find it suspicious that you defended me. I think you're the only one who did.
sakura would freak out at the sight of cheese, though. IF she didn't freak out at least once, then we'd think something was up.
Just sayin'.

I'm CHANGING VOTE to KILL XADYU.
That sneaky bastard shall die today!
Ok, so jorped is a newbie.. I didn't know. I still find his behavior suspicious though.
I won't vote for him this round... What is bothering me is the post and leave guys, Kazu and Banana.
There's also Macaco, when I saw his first post it looked like he would contribute more... but now he's looking like Kazu for me
I will vote on Banana, his only post was a vote out of nowhere.
Vote kill Banana
I thought you'd think it's funny to mess with a bunch of newcomers, or take the opportunity to get yourself a new ban now that the mafia game is so colorful '-'
Ok, now seriously. Maybe you're being honest here, but after you were so random, claiming roles to tease, and insisting on them for a while after that or wtv... xD If you're trying to play seriously, then I don't get why you went throught that act, lol.
Vote Kill Xadyu
I'm still waiting for an answer from Milly, though @.@ And I don't mind to take the bullet, Gar. I don't think he's the bomb. I imagine that bombs would try to look dangerous to the mafia (so they'd try to eliminate it during the night phase), I don't see how someone would get that by playing safe o.o And if he wanted to look suspicious to blow off someone, I think he knows that's not a smart way to play with a townie role, during the day phase...
s Tommy ç.ç
What an interesting way to make it look like I'm suspecting you only because of some silly revenge. Sorry to disappoint you, but I totally forgot about that until you just mentioned it.
What I want you to say is quite easy: Discuss matters and suspects with the others, you were online for most of the day and still you didn't participate in a single discussion. All you ever commented about was some meaningless stuff like the lovers role or the state of the game.
That stuff about always being suspicious of guys like Imp or Gary is just a lame mafia excuse. I know it, because I've been mafia often enough and I know it's pretty tiring to come up with a plausible theory for who is mafia when you know that actually you're the mafia guy.
And I believe this is not your first time playing this game? Have you ever seen DD end a day early if not everyone made their vote? As far as I recall he always waited until everyone made a decision or until the time ran out. Saying you feared the game would end early is just another silly excuse to make a random vote.
---------- Post added at 02:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:27 AM ----------
Okay, I know I won't change my opinion. Frosty's answer made him even more suspicious so votekill Frostymouse
So, it looks like this is the end of the argument. Regardless of the roles, by an objective evaluation, niichan won it.
This makes the things a bit easier. At best case, a mafia is lynched. At worst, a townie with lesser observation skills demonstrated is lost and a strong mafia lives on. We won't be getting niichan even if he's a mafia in this turn, anyway. Faust and Xadyu are discussed mostly, but Faust's earlier excitement was justified by the theme of the game to a degree, while Xadyu's case is less proven than Frosty to go after him. In the end, I don't think Faust is a Mafia and we will probably be getting the head of a townie if we let niichan's proposed clue go. So, in the end, I'd say, following niichan's lead for now gives us the best result according to the game theory, since we have little chance to take down a mafia with other suspicions being mostly vague or just biased.
That's not a confirmation of niichan's side, though. But he played an impressive gambit and things aren't looking any better if we refuse.
Vote Kill FrostyMouse
I will be more active from now on, but honestly at this point of the game i don't really know what to say or to vote for. Anyway, i am gonna vote kill BBB, because Nero pisses me off.
I will likely have time to get on tomorrow morning (going out tonight like I said), but in case I don't have time/get laid/feel awful/whatever, to make a proper opinion about anyone (no one really stands that out to me at the moment, Faust is excited, but that's about it), I will cast a random vote on one of the single time posters at this moment. Using a random number generator it hit Mazino.
Thus vote kill Mazino.
faust this active reminds me of the first game where he was the bomb,2-3 he was quiet ...so maybe hes the bomb again
(i know u are asking imp)but...
niichan being mafia so often in the last games makes it unlikely that hes mafia again, but him repeating xio made him suspicious though its no real reason(or evidence) ..
frosty acted like that in the last game too,makes me think of him as townie
u also seem to be a townie,if i judge ur playstyle right,cuz u were like that the other times too,and always townie ...m3j well voting him cuz hes a noob is no reason for me,dont wanna do that
so im going with Votekill Niichan
ok I'll vote just so I don't end hostkilled. Vote Kill Ryuk
I haven't read the thread. I'll do so after I get back from work.
Interesting theory about Faust being mafia actually...I seen him in 2 games and he was barely active posting random OP(fml) gifs instead of any concrete ideas. But now he kind of said something that could be put into the senseful category and obvi dissapeared. Imo there is a good chance he could be mafio, atleast better chances than anyone here. Lawl is also a bit too jumpy imo. But he wouldn't play like that if he was mafia, he usually doesn't, or maybe he is using reverse psycology on me now...Well anyway Letss see where this gets us Vote kill faust
Vote: Evil3ye
He's being way too agressive here.
A game with that many players is not easy. I cannot decide whether it makes most sense to go after the active player, who talk a lot (Mej, Faust, Haku, xi0), the discreetly active, who make a constant appearance but don't contribute much (niichan, Imp, Midoban, Xadyu and Moa) or the rather very passive rest.
However, I will make some vote to get something started now. VOTEKILL FARFALLA
It not because of her saying she would be busy during the beginning period, except on weekends (if I remember correctly), it the unwillingness to read all posts, and limiting herself to those which received some thanks. This I thought is something really odd, especially for Farfalla. I can see her having a mafia role this time and that being the reason.
As for Imp, his playing style reminds me a lot of when he was the Serial Killer. I am having an eye on him, he could very well have the Mentor role, but I will not vote him out yet, before having something more to go by.
In other games you also had an important role (bomb and doctor) your reaction to the vote was not the same ... was more random and you did not care much for explaining things.
Let's look at the explanations
1) For what mafia would draw attention? So there is a chance of it being more Bomb than a Mafia and you still voted for him
2) Even though it may have a role you feel unsafe? A noob can be influenced by mafias, like the townies. He still has a chance to protect the city
3) Okay, in that I agree.
I dont know ... has something different here. By now, Vote kill Raito
Usually on Day 1 I go with the reasoning "vote for whoever will be the biggest liability whether they're mafia or not", unless there's someone really suspicious of course. This time there's no one very suspicious and no one who seems to be a nuisance to the game. Maybe it's because DD is hosting this time...
Thus, I'll cast a random vote upon someone who hasn't already gotten any. Vote kill Naomi. Sorry, darling.
VOTE KILL JORPED.
You know.. because.. he's Mello...
And I'm Matsuda..
10 fuckong pages xDDDD
sowwyw i gotta go to bed and i coudlnt rea\dt thing during the nightvote kill milly just cuause thise fucker wnt wear the fucking avy i made!!
---------- Post added at 12:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 AM ----------
new rule foir ,my nexrt posts: i'll onluy read the post that gets likes/thaksn !
they'll etiehr be funny or important, KOL
A lot members are playing safe here and the only two that are somewhat suspicious are only Imp and Faust.
Faust voting for someone simply due to the fact that m3j did not have an avatar and imp being annoyed by him.
Could this be an elaborate scheme by the mafia?
At this point - those two are the only ones that I am suspicious.
I'm a bit suprised that imp would loose his cool and vote for someone like that.
My vote goes for him.
Vote to kill Impy
I was facing the same problem. I probably won't be back online for like 16 hours and as the game began 22 hours ago, I should make it under the 48 hour cap that DD originally gave us, as that only only be 38 hours, but if by chance DD ends it early, I'd be left without having made a vote, which sort of forces me to vote now. I can always change it later.
Vote Kill Faust.
It's perhaps not the best vote I've ever made in the Mafia Game, but my reasoning is that Faust was oddly active with spam and posts about DN lore. It seemed out of character for him and he seemed overly excited. There's a chance that he's a Mafia member, you never know, but it would be a role that he could be more excited with.
Just fucking read the rules. It cant be that hard. Jezus. And when you vote make sure its in bold so dd can see it.
Votekill M3J
random vote for now might change it tomorrow or the following days
VOTE KILL M3J
My Stupid Reason of my vote:
He's the only player who doesn't have a death note avatar
Oh. Do we have to vote the first day? If so, then Votekill Gary. If not, then I shall wait another day if I still survive.
If you don't trust me, then not my problem. You will when I die later on.
Do not blame me. Blame Farfy.
Yeah!no... I don't even know who macaco is
He's probably mido's friend, but he never posted on the pt thread.
I don't have mido's cel number, only far's one.
it's 3:30 am here
Do you want me to send a txt to far asking her about macaco?
I'm CHANGING VOTE to KILL XADYU.Votekill FrostyMouse... I think that niichan was onto something, and yeah it looks like I'm bandwagoning, but I really don't feel strongly about any of the people who have the most votes. It's something way more concrete than Faust acting "differently" (he's unpredictable anyways, and is a little bit more well-known by us now compared to previous times he played, as well as being excited for this theme, so he might just be more comfortable being himself now...idk) or Milly just being Milly...though considering he has played Werewolf before, he's not a total noob like I thought. In either case, I think Frosty is the most suspicious of those three with two or more votes.
If niichan is wrong, well...we'll deal with that later, but it doesn't look good for him.
That sneaky bastard shall die today!
Ok, so jorped is a newbie.. I didn't know. I still find his behavior suspicious though.
I won't vote for him this round... What is bothering me is the post and leave guys, Kazu and Banana.
There's also Macaco, when I saw his first post it looked like he would contribute more... but now he's looking like Kazu for me
I will vote on Banana, his only post was a vote out of nowhere.
Vote kill Banana
I thought you'd think it's funny to mess with a bunch of newcomers, or take the opportunity to get yourself a new ban now that the mafia game is so colorful '-'
Ok, now seriously. Maybe you're being honest here, but after you were so random, claiming roles to tease, and insisting on them for a while after that or wtv... xD If you're trying to play seriously, then I don't get why you went throught that act, lol.
Vote Kill Xadyu
I'm still waiting for an answer from Milly, though @.@ And I don't mind to take the bullet, Gar. I don't think he's the bomb. I imagine that bombs would try to look dangerous to the mafia (so they'd try to eliminate it during the night phase), I don't see how someone would get that by playing safe o.o And if he wanted to look suspicious to blow off someone, I think he knows that's not a smart way to play with a townie role, during the day phase...
s Tommy ç.ç
What an interesting way to make it look like I'm suspecting you only because of some silly revenge. Sorry to disappoint you, but I totally forgot about that until you just mentioned it.
What I want you to say is quite easy: Discuss matters and suspects with the others, you were online for most of the day and still you didn't participate in a single discussion. All you ever commented about was some meaningless stuff like the lovers role or the state of the game.
That stuff about always being suspicious of guys like Imp or Gary is just a lame mafia excuse. I know it, because I've been mafia often enough and I know it's pretty tiring to come up with a plausible theory for who is mafia when you know that actually you're the mafia guy.
And I believe this is not your first time playing this game? Have you ever seen DD end a day early if not everyone made their vote? As far as I recall he always waited until everyone made a decision or until the time ran out. Saying you feared the game would end early is just another silly excuse to make a random vote.
---------- Post added at 02:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:27 AM ----------
Okay, I know I won't change my opinion. Frosty's answer made him even more suspicious so votekill Frostymouse
So, it looks like this is the end of the argument. Regardless of the roles, by an objective evaluation, niichan won it.
This makes the things a bit easier. At best case, a mafia is lynched. At worst, a townie with lesser observation skills demonstrated is lost and a strong mafia lives on. We won't be getting niichan even if he's a mafia in this turn, anyway. Faust and Xadyu are discussed mostly, but Faust's earlier excitement was justified by the theme of the game to a degree, while Xadyu's case is less proven than Frosty to go after him. In the end, I don't think Faust is a Mafia and we will probably be getting the head of a townie if we let niichan's proposed clue go. So, in the end, I'd say, following niichan's lead for now gives us the best result according to the game theory, since we have little chance to take down a mafia with other suspicions being mostly vague or just biased.
That's not a confirmation of niichan's side, though. But he played an impressive gambit and things aren't looking any better if we refuse.
Vote Kill FrostyMouse
I will be more active from now on, but honestly at this point of the game i don't really know what to say or to vote for. Anyway, i am gonna vote kill BBB, because Nero pisses me off.
I will likely have time to get on tomorrow morning (going out tonight like I said), but in case I don't have time/get laid/feel awful/whatever, to make a proper opinion about anyone (no one really stands that out to me at the moment, Faust is excited, but that's about it), I will cast a random vote on one of the single time posters at this moment. Using a random number generator it hit Mazino.
Thus vote kill Mazino.
faust this active reminds me of the first game where he was the bomb,2-3 he was quiet ...so maybe hes the bomb again
(i know u are asking imp)but...
niichan being mafia so often in the last games makes it unlikely that hes mafia again, but him repeating xio made him suspicious though its no real reason(or evidence) ..
frosty acted like that in the last game too,makes me think of him as townie
u also seem to be a townie,if i judge ur playstyle right,cuz u were like that the other times too,and always townie ...m3j well voting him cuz hes a noob is no reason for me,dont wanna do that
so im going with Votekill Niichan
ok I'll vote just so I don't end hostkilled. Vote Kill Ryuk
I haven't read the thread. I'll do so after I get back from work.
Interesting theory about Faust being mafia actually...I seen him in 2 games and he was barely active posting random OP(fml) gifs instead of any concrete ideas. But now he kind of said something that could be put into the senseful category and obvi dissapeared. Imo there is a good chance he could be mafio, atleast better chances than anyone here. Lawl is also a bit too jumpy imo. But he wouldn't play like that if he was mafia, he usually doesn't, or maybe he is using reverse psycology on me now...Well anyway Letss see where this gets us Vote kill faust
Vote: Evil3ye
He's being way too agressive here.
A game with that many players is not easy. I cannot decide whether it makes most sense to go after the active player, who talk a lot (Mej, Faust, Haku, xi0), the discreetly active, who make a constant appearance but don't contribute much (niichan, Imp, Midoban, Xadyu and Moa) or the rather very passive rest.
However, I will make some vote to get something started now. VOTEKILL FARFALLA
It not because of her saying she would be busy during the beginning period, except on weekends (if I remember correctly), it the unwillingness to read all posts, and limiting herself to those which received some thanks. This I thought is something really odd, especially for Farfalla. I can see her having a mafia role this time and that being the reason.
As for Imp, his playing style reminds me a lot of when he was the Serial Killer. I am having an eye on him, he could very well have the Mentor role, but I will not vote him out yet, before having something more to go by.
In other games you also had an important role (bomb and doctor) your reaction to the vote was not the same ... was more random and you did not care much for explaining things.
Let's look at the explanations
1) For what mafia would draw attention? So there is a chance of it being more Bomb than a Mafia and you still voted for him
2) Even though it may have a role you feel unsafe? A noob can be influenced by mafias, like the townies. He still has a chance to protect the city
3) Okay, in that I agree.
I dont know ... has something different here. By now, Vote kill Raito
Usually on Day 1 I go with the reasoning "vote for whoever will be the biggest liability whether they're mafia or not", unless there's someone really suspicious of course. This time there's no one very suspicious and no one who seems to be a nuisance to the game. Maybe it's because DD is hosting this time...
Thus, I'll cast a random vote upon someone who hasn't already gotten any. Vote kill Naomi. Sorry, darling.
VOTE KILL JORPED.
You know.. because.. he's Mello...
And I'm Matsuda..
10 fuckong pages xDDDD
sowwyw i gotta go to bed and i coudlnt rea\dt thing during the nightvote kill milly just cuause thise fucker wnt wear the fucking avy i made!!
---------- Post added at 12:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 AM ----------
new rule foir ,my nexrt posts: i'll onluy read the post that gets likes/thaksn !
they'll etiehr be funny or important, KOL
A lot members are playing safe here and the only two that are somewhat suspicious are only Imp and Faust.
Faust voting for someone simply due to the fact that m3j did not have an avatar and imp being annoyed by him.
Could this be an elaborate scheme by the mafia?
At this point - those two are the only ones that I am suspicious.
I'm a bit suprised that imp would loose his cool and vote for someone like that.
My vote goes for him.
Vote to kill Impy
I was facing the same problem. I probably won't be back online for like 16 hours and as the game began 22 hours ago, I should make it under the 48 hour cap that DD originally gave us, as that only only be 38 hours, but if by chance DD ends it early, I'd be left without having made a vote, which sort of forces me to vote now. I can always change it later.
Vote Kill Faust.
It's perhaps not the best vote I've ever made in the Mafia Game, but my reasoning is that Faust was oddly active with spam and posts about DN lore. It seemed out of character for him and he seemed overly excited. There's a chance that he's a Mafia member, you never know, but it would be a role that he could be more excited with.
Just fucking read the rules. It cant be that hard. Jezus. And when you vote make sure its in bold so dd can see it.
Votekill M3J
random vote for now might change it tomorrow or the following days
VOTE KILL M3J
My Stupid Reason of my vote:
He's the only player who doesn't have a death note avatar
Oh. Do we have to vote the first day? If so, then Votekill Gary. If not, then I shall wait another day if I still survive.
If you don't trust me, then not my problem. You will when I die later on.
Do not blame me. Blame Farfy.
Hmm, you should, but I dunno if #mangahelpers is active, but you can have a channel for FFers.I've always wanted, but never tried(IRC)
anyway, what's the point?
Are you claiming to be good at fooling people? suspicious!

Werewolf and Mafia are different though. In Werewolf, there were three basic roles, as far as I recall. Detective, werewolf, and townies. I assumed it'd be the same for Mafia. But no, there's at least 12 roles. -_-Votekill FrostyMouse... I think that niichan was onto something, and yeah it looks like I'm bandwagoning, but I really don't feel strongly about any of the people who have the most votes. It's something way more concrete than Faust acting "differently" (he's unpredictable anyways, and is a little bit more well-known by us now compared to previous times he played, as well as being excited for this theme, so he might just be more comfortable being himself now...idk) or Milly just being Milly...though considering he has played Werewolf before, he's not a total noob like I thought. In either case, I think Frosty is the most suspicious of those three with two or more votes.
If niichan is wrong, well...we'll deal with that later, but it won't look good for him.


it would be too obvious though. I am more inclined to think its a random ability use of a person who knows that xi0 can be very dangerous in some instancesHm, so, unless someone used his ability randomly, that person was pressured by Gary's presence. Could be someone Gary openly mentioned suspecting, then.
Tough call, either way.