Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Roacher]

That's also fair! Speaking of Aniplex, what's your hopes and realistic expectations for how they handle distributing the Kimetsu movie in the West?

A LOT of people are gonna want to see it, if MAL is of any reasonable indication, no matter how small. More than even Heroes Rising, probably because Kimetsu's movie is actually fully canon that must be watched before viewing any future material. So, uh, they're gonna have to really make sure the film gets out there.

I don't think mal is good indicator.

 

[Koni]

Mmmmm since Ufotable has been tweeting in all languages and thanking the west audience while anime was airing, I think this can go worldwide. Do you remember that the first 5 episodes were in a movie format and it premiered in France, Australia, United states, (I don't remember the last one, but I think it was south Korea)? . But this time it can premiere in more countries.

They're definitely gonna do a theatrical release, that's for sure. Otherwise they'd leave way too much money on the table. Though I hope they have a theatrical run for two weeks even though I'm only expecting it to run for only one week.

 

[Thores]

They're definitely gonna do a theatrical release, that's for sure. Otherwise they'd leave way too much money on the table. Though I hope they have a theatrical run for two weeks even though I'm only expecting it to run for only one week.

As long as there's an option to watch the subbed version in theaters!

I'm usually not a "subs over dubs" purist, and there's actually a lot of recent dubs I think are pretty good, but.... Inosuke's dub voice....

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Bleach fans and Dragon Ball Super fans being in despair and fighting for a spot in Jump Festa has already became a yearly event

 

[Unok]

Toei/Pierrot was every manga readers worst nightmare when we got the news of Kimetsu being adapted.

I now worry about Jujutsu being adapted by Pierrot. The secret festa stage, the double volume release, manga getting to overall good amount of chapters for anime announcement. And in the same time, Black Clover getting closer to the manga, means Pierrot can just end it and take in for April/July a new show...

 

[Koni]

Ya know, barely anybody ever talks about We Never Learn, despite its anime airing this season. How has that been doing? I wonder what the sales and backlogs for the series are.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

I now worry about Jujutsu being adapted by Pierrot. The secret festa stage, the double volume release, manga getting to overall good amount of chapters for anime announcement. And in the same time, Black Clover getting closer to the manga, means Pierrot can just end it and take in for April/July a new show...

Black Clover will be produced at least until October 2020

 

[Unok]

Black Clover will be at least produced until October 2020.

Is that confirmed?

 

[savethecat]

Interesting reading about possible Dragon Ball endings the manga could have had:

https://www.kanzenshuu.com/intended-end/

If this is those articles that go “Toriyama originally planned on ending at Picolo

It's because you upvote literally every comment that praises MHA. Anyway the point isn't about you, the point is that MHA's choreography is bottom tier.

Jezuz Christ, what’s your issue

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Is that confirmed?

By the director, it will be produced for another whole year:

 

[Unok]

By the director, it will be produced for another whole year:

Nice, so hopefully Jujutsu anime starts before October

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Wouldn't be surprised if Jujutsu Kaisen gets a anime announced already for Spring, seems like Jump will have nothing for Spring and a good part of their biggest seasonal animes are/were released in April, seems like the perfect time Jujutsu Kaisen as a battle shounen.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Ya know, barely anybody ever talks about We Never Learn, despite its anime airing this season. How has that been doing? I wonder what the sales and backlogs for the series are.

Anime didn't make much for the manga but is doing good for a romcom, is selling basically what Dr. Stone do but a bit more, i really like the anime (in fact i'm watching at this moment)

 

[savethecat]

I’m personally guessing that Bones will either adapt Jujutsu Kaisen or Chainsaw Man. One or the other

 

[supercow297]

Which goes to show that this is a bandwagon effect in the likes of AoT with the only difference being that AoT was catapulted into the mainstream and was a topic of discussion from the very first episode while it took 19 for people to realize that Kimetsu wasn't atypical seasonal shounen affair so now they're getting caught up because its a topic of discussion now whether or not it'll hold is up in the air since Haikyuu was showing similar numbers when it got its boost and went down a lot since then. If its fans are actually loyalist like Kingdom and MHA then this is a big deal but it could all just be a fad in the end.

Found this on the JJK sub. Looks like there's a slot at Jump Festa under "Secret" (I think, my Japanese sucks). Can anyone tell what the smaller black writing underneath says? Also, would an anime announcement possibly give a reason to publish 2 volumes together in January?

whoops, didn't realise this was already posted. mb.

P sure black writing says something along the lines of "as to what kind of stage it will be, please look forward to it!"

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 27, 2019, Original Post Date: Oct 27, 2019 ---

If this is those articles that go “Toriyama originally planned on ending at Picolo


Jezuz Christ, what’s your issue

I just found it interesting that after I said something bad about MHA recently to Choco he has upvoted literally every single top-5 post where MHA is in there, etc. etc. So I assumed that he was a very stalwart fan. I also think only someone who is such a strong fan that they can't compare series "somewhat more neutrally" (to the extent that that is possible) could think MHA has top-1 or top-2 of Jump choreography.

The point isn't me singling out individual people, although I did. But I believe you have to be a huge fan of BNHA to possibly believe it has good choreography, and those two facts both apply to him, which is why I mentioned him.

That's the explanation.

 

[savethecat]

P sure black writing says something along the lines of "as to what kind of stage it will be, please look forward to it!"

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 27, 2019, Original Post Date: Oct 27, 2019 ---

I just found it interesting that after I said something bad about MHA recently to Choco he has upvoted literally every single top-5 post where MHA is in there, etc. etc. So I assumed that he was a very stalwart fan. I also think only someone who is such a strong fan that they can't compare series "somewhat more neutrally" (to the extent that that is possible) could think MHA has top-1 or top-2 of Jump choreography.

The point isn't me singling out individual people, although I did. But I believe you have to be a huge fan of BNHA to possibly believe it has good choreography, and those two facts both apply to him, which is why I mentioned him.

That's the explanation.

Even if he’s a huge fan, it appears like that personally bothers you for whatever reason, and you seem to be genuinely bothered by other people’s opinions on something that is completely subjective.

 

[evielynn]

Wouldn't be surprised if Jujutsu Kaisen gets a anime announced already for Spring, seems like Jump will have nothing for Spring and a good part of their biggest seasonal animes are/were released in April, seems like the perfect time Jujutsu Kaisen as a battle shounen.

I think 2020 will look like this for Jump anime:
Winter: Haikyuu S4
Spring: Promised Neverland S2 (cant be winter since Noitamina slot is filled)
Summer: JJK
Fall: HeroAca S5

If Stone gets a second season then maybe that comes around next fall too.

 

[Koni]

I think 2020 will look like this for Jump anime:
Winter: Haikyuu S4
Spring: Promised Neverland S2 (cant be winter since Noitamina slot is filled)
Summer: JJK
Fall: HeroAca S5

If Stone gets a second season then maybe that comes around next fall too.

I think Dr. Stone would be more of a summer show than a Fall show. I can also see Act-Age, Chainsaw Man, and Yaiba Season 2 for 2021.

 

[TxxT]

Wouldn't be surprised if Jujutsu Kaisen gets a anime announced already for Spring, seems like Jump will have nothing for Spring and a good part of their biggest seasonal animes are/were released in April, seems like the perfect time Jujutsu Kaisen as a battle shounen.

They'll have Haikyu!! S4, One Piece, Black Clover, Boruto, and potentially TPN S2 all airing during April so Im sure they'll be fine, Im expecting a JJK anime to air Fall 2020 or Winter 2021

 

[Aeneas]

But I believe you have to be a huge fan of BNHA to possibly believe it has good choreography

The easy (yet time-consuming) solution is to ask said fan why they like the choreography so much, and then to go from there. If the justification is full of holes and hasn't been thought through very much, address that, and maybe the person will reply with more detail or eventually reconsider their position.