- Joined
- Nov 5, 2017
- Messages
- 1,929
- Reaction score
- 877
- Country
-
Golden Kamuy seems to be one of the fortunate cases where a YJ title gets an anime that isn't complete shit, I really hope that ends up being the case because I really love the manga. For the most part, they haven't learned from their mistakes and in general the adaptations from YJ have all been pretty horrible, I guess they might've believed that the anime doesn't matter that much anyway since it's a seinen mag, but come on... Umaru is probably the first exception to the botched anime rule, funny enough, it really is baffling how pretty much even the biggest series from the magazine didn't escape the shit anime treatment and these series are some of the best selling manga in history, it's so weird. Maybe with a little bit of luck Kaguya ends up at Dogakobo, I'd trust them, maybe Shaft and JC Staff and even Lerche would be fine. Even in a lesser studio, if they get the kind of director that knows how to really adapt this kind of a series properly, that would be fine too.I thought that both seasons of Umaru were good adaptations, but those may be a bit easier to do due to the whole cute-girls-doing-cute-things premise of the series. While I've never read it, it looks like Golden Kamuy is one of WYJ's bigger series currently running and the provided images for the upcoming anime look well-drawn at the very least. I don't really know the history of Young Jump anime adaptations, but hopefully they've learned from their past mistakes if that's the case.