Games Top Ten Game - Most Overrated Anime - They think it's all over...

[z.5]

Spoiler: What was before writ"

zimbardo what's the deadline, onegai ?

Try to get something to me by this weekend - I'd like to set the deadline for Saturday morning, but I am going to work on both Sat and Sun this weekend. I dunno how long I will be there, but my boss and I want to have a paper submitted before I offski on my Christmas holidays (so it's possible I might be super busy).

Spoiler: Most overrated manga and manhwa

Most overrated manga and manhwa
The lists and scores

1 and 2 points
3 points
4 points
5 points
6 points - round Nii
7 points
8 and 9 points

The Final 20
20th -> 17th
16th - World War Gry
13th -> 11th - taking Magi's purity

The BIG 10
10th - its flaws are deafening...
9th - #notyourtower
8th - the wrong kind of nudity
7th - should've died earlier...
6th - worse than the drink
5th - where's Bonnie Tyler when you need her?!?
4th - in pieces
3rd - I know it's not butter!
2nd - it's sheer existence is the biggest sin of all!
1st - ... and nobody lived happily ever after

Most Overrated Anime (TV series, Films, et cetera...)

The lists and scores

1 and 2 points
3 points
4 points
5 points
6 points
7 and 8 points
9 points
10 and 11 points
12, 13 and 14 points
16, 17 and 18 points

The inglorious 12

12th - Attack on the demonic brotherhood
9th - Watching two overlords drilling
5th - Forcing a semi deep into Stein's colon
4th - Rather be in a hospital bed, comatose, with some sick pervert pleasuring himself to my lifeless body
3rd - Hardly a bizarre choice for 3rd place...
2nd - A number best forgotten
1st - Short Arse O' Mine​

 

[Hardy]

I liked your lie in april but I would had listed had I even remembered it existed. I don't mind explaining any picks if anyone is curious.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 6, 2020 ---

Samurai X's anime is pretty boring afaik but I don't recall anyone speaking highly of it so I didn't list it.

 

[GrySun]

I don't mind explaining any picks if anyone is curious.

No game no life and FMA? The former I'm not a fan of, but also didn't think it to be very highly rated/known overall. As for FMA, you picked the 2003 version I think? Or did you mean FMA in general?

 

[Erinyes]

I liked your lie in april but I would had listed had I even remembered it existed. I don't mind explaining any picks if anyone is curious.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 6, 2020 ---

Samurai X's anime is pretty boring afaik but I don't recall anyone speaking highly of it so I didn't list it.

Agree Kenshin was pretty
average, ive tried to watch it but gave up, but the 4 "Trust and Betrayal" ova are amazing. and its soundtrack is pure gold ;zomg

this scene ! (its no spoiler its the 1st Ova scene)

 

[z.5]

As for FMA, you picked the 2003 version I think? Or did you mean FMA in general?

he meant the old series - he was pretty specific on that point

I don't mind explaining any picks if anyone is curious.

more explanation is always a good thing (and not only as it provides a nice buffer between my posts)

 

[revo]

I was going to put FMA 2003 too but thought I was going to get lynched from it, glad it isn't an unpopular opinion though

 

[GrySun]

I was going to put FMA 2003 too but thought I was going to get lynched from it, glad it isn't an unpopular opinion though

It's in the list of 1 person, wouldn't call it not unpopular. You can still get lynched for it if you want though

 

[Farfalla]

No Game No Life has a 8.3 score in MAL and imo it's indeed undeserving.

Poopie, you didn't watch 2003 FMA @_@ only Brotherhood.

I think one of the things that compromises the anime of RK A LOT is the amount of boring fillers...

 

[Hardy]

No game no life and FMA? The former I'm not a fan of, but also didn't think it to be very highly rated/known overall. As for FMA, you picked the 2003 version I think? Or did you mean FMA in general?

No game no life has a very high score everywhere and here it's nothing but praised. It's an anime that I watched and left me nothing, really, lol.

Same applies to Magus bride, tho that one I do like. The pace is pretty awful, and we watched the OVAs first which are the best of the series by far (imo, of course) so everything after was a disappointment.

Fma I explain later.

Naruto is because people usually say "IT'S GREAT BUT FILLERS" when from my experience it's... Pretty shit except for some very hype moments (usually involving Gaara or Kakashi). Granted, I do admit never watching it all in a sequence, more like catching random episodes on tv.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 6, 2020 ---

he ment the old series - he was pretty specific on that point

Was I not specific in other points and made you work?

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020 ---

Agree Kenshin was pretty
average, ive tried to watch it but gave up, but the 4 "Trust and Betrayal" ova are amazing. and its soundtrack is pure gold ;zomg

this scene ! (its no spoiler its the 1st Ova scene)

Watched OVAs with Farfs and definitely enjoyed it, yeah. Tried to watch the anime and just couldn't. Even as a kid I found it boring, which is funny because SWORDS AND SHIT.

 

[z.5]

10 points

Fairy Tail
Farfalla (congrats on having the last solo pick Farfy - ナイスジョブ！)

My Hero Academia
Farfalla (4) + FaustXIII (3) + Gajeel (3)

Violet Evergarden
Brandish (4) + revo (6)


11 points

Erased
Erinyes (10) + Nii (1)

Zankyou no Terror
Nii (3) + revo (8)​

 

[Farfalla]

Fairy Tail
@Farfalla (congrats on having the last solo pick Farfy - ナイスジョブ！)

I'm shocked xD

 

[z.5]

I'm shocked xD

considering all the love this series seems to receive, so am I

 

[Farfalla]

I guess many were like me and had overall different lists for manga and anime, since they don't follow the same series in both media

 

[Riku]

I think the soundtrack redeems Fairy Tail the anime in comparison to the manga a lot. Might make it even slightly better than the source material.

 

[Farfalla]

Not crazy about the ST either tbh

 

[z.5]

Naruto is because people usually say "IT'S GREAT BUT FILLERS" when from my experience it's... Pretty shit except for some very hype moments (usually involving Gaara or Kakashi).

Yeah, this.

Though, I chose Shippuden as people kept saying that

it has less fillers and is better than the original series

...

Granted, I do admit never watching it all in a sequence, more like catching random episodes on tv.

If only it was improved by watching it in order...

Was I not specific in other points and made you work?

Nah, but let's say that few people displayed such an overt hatred for that series, as you did

 

[Riku]

Not crazy about the ST either tbh

Well it isn't that good either, but better than the series deserves

 

[z.5]

12 points

Angel Beats!
Nii (5) + revo (7)


13 points

Clannad
Brandish (8) + Juviii (5)

That Time I got Reincarnated as a Slime
Farfalla (9) + Hardy (4)


14 points

Fate
Juviii (4) zimbardo (10)​

 

[GrySun]

Can‘t believe I forgot Slime. It started really good, but became really bad and disappointing.

Think me not using MAL for the lists is what confuses me about most picks, since many of you seem to have based popularity off of that, while I did a more personal approach.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 6, 2020 ---

@zimbardo what is „Fate“ exactly? Thought we couldn‘t list the whole series.

 

[Hardy]

I think Your Name is very cute. I can get why it can be seen as underrated as it isn't the best movie ever nor anything, but it stings a bit to see it here lol.

The same can be said about Violet Evergarden tho I like it much more and I don't think it's as highly praised as the former.

Gintama, kill la kill, soma, overlord, kagetuwtv those we couldn't watch more than two episodes before giving up.

Does anyone rate Berserk animated?

@Erinyes from reading its anime thread I understand where you come from when you voted for tpn, but as someone that hadn't read anything I really enjoyed it.

On a less mature note, you all can suck my all might for dissing on heroaca, thx.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 6, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 6, 2020 ---

I'd argue that up until Slime gets a "body" it's alright (still overrated, but not bad). After that it just drags on forever.

 

[z.5]

zimbardo what is „Fate“ exactly? Thought we couldn‘t list the whole series.

Nah, I said we could - except for a few minor exceptions (such as Naruto/Shippuden) - as it's just far easier that way

For Fate - I've only seen a bit of Fate/stay night (and know it not to be my thing) - I dunno how related it is to Fate/Zero (which Juviii chose), as I had absolutely no intention to continue to force myself to watch that series...