Hangout Fairy Tail Hangout Thread

[Takuan]

Rating the current review by 1.24/10 due to inaccurate/wrong content not to mention that member rating of the chapter isn't precise too.
I'm here to say that review doesn't represent my opinion at all.

I actually think you're trolling a bit, but just in case you're not, i'll answer to you correctly.
In all honesty i disagree with you. This review was excellent.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not saying this because i agree with everything @MLG Bradman wrote (which is the case anyway), or because i love the dude (which is also the case). I genuinely think this review was very well made, and that every review should follow this example.
It seems like you're really having trouble with opinions given in reviews huh. I can actually understand your point of view to a certain extent, but imo a review should still contain the writer's opinion, as long as it is not ridiculously biased ad disrespectful towards other people's opinions. Which clearly wasn't the case here.
But let's not start the debate again. We're all entitled to our opinions. While you're giving this review a 1.24/10, i'd give it a 9.73/10.

@MLG Bradman great work dude. I'm looking forward to reading your future reviews, i hope that'll happen anyway.

 

[Ebony Maw]

Rating the current review by 1.24/10 due to inaccurate/wrong content not to mention that member rating of the chapter isn't precise too.
I'm here to say that review doesn't represent my opinion at all.

May I ask what it is that you don't like about how it works? Two weeks ago@Belserion (who wrote a fantastic review) praised the chapter and you disagreed, but then I panned the chapter this week and you still disagree, I'm just confused as to what you want in the reviews. After all, a review has to contain some opinion, otherwise it would just be a summary.

And with the above being said, there is actually an easy solution to your problems: ask Brandish if you could do the review next week.

I actually think you're trolling a bit, but just in case you're not, i'll answer to you correctly.
In all honesty i disagree with you. This review was excellent.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not saying this because i agree with everything @MLG Bradman wrote (which is the case anyway), or because i love the dude (which is also the case). I genuinely think this review was very well made, and that every review should follow this example.
It seems like you're really having trouble with opinions given in reviews huh. I can actually understand your point of view to a certain extent, but imo a review should still contain the writer's opinion, as long as it is not ridiculously biased ad disrespectful towards other people's opinions. Which clearly wasn't the case here.
But let's not start the debate again. We're all entitled to our opinions. While you're giving this review a 1.24/10, i'd give it a 9.73/10.

@MLG Bradman great work dude. I'm looking forward to reading your future reviews, i hope that'll happen anyway.

Thanks a lot man, I'm glad you liked it!

The love is returned.

 

[Mononoke]

Rating the current review by 1.24/10 due to inaccurate/wrong content not to mention that member rating of the chapter isn't precise too.
I'm here to say that review doesn't represent my opinion at all.

I'm sorry to say but it is impossible to please everyone with a review because they add in their own opinion, you have a very different judgement of what it should say and so if you did the review some other people will say it does not represent their opinion but thats just what happens when you write what you think so dont like it? Cool move on and write what you think in the thread.
Also precise rating? There is no such thing as people will enjoy the chapter differently.

If you disagree so much why do you not write the review or step forward to do so other than complaining at how bad the reviews are which you have done to both Bel and Saber.
Saying they are crap (giving it a 1) wont change anything as the reviews are already written so why not just write what you think in the thread and leave it at that or next time write the review yourself if you think these do not represent your views.

 

[Hermit]

While we're on the matter of Saber's review, there is one part I have to point out

sting twice as bad

>Sees avvi
>Name is SaberTooth fan (I mean its not his name on here but you get the drift of it)
That quote just might be the best part of your review you Sting fan

 

[BluePegasus]

Are we SERIOUSLY going to do this over again. How childish.

@MLG Bradman Your review was amazing man.

@Debonair Raven Yours was.. Where is yours?

 

[GamerSkull]

I'll say that while I disagreed with certain aspects, I did enjoy all the reviews up until this point. A lot of thought seemed to have went into writing them.

Anyway, I looked over the first post and I'm still unsure how the process of being picked to do a review works. (Probably because I'm stupid.)
I'd love to do one sometime.

 

[Raven]

May I ask what it is that you don't like about how it works? Two weeks ago@Belserion (who wrote a fantastic review) praised the chapter and you disagreed, but then I panned the chapter this week and you still disagree, I'm just confused as to what you want in the reviews. After all, a review has to contain some opinion, otherwise it would just be a summary.

And with the above being said, there is actually an easy solution to your problems: ask Brandish if you could do the review next week.

Thanks a lot man, I'm glad you liked it!

The love is returned.

First review i disagreed because of the reasons i said before but again bashing 2 panels in 4.5 lines isn't healthy and doesn't represent my opinion regarding this part but He/she praised another moment worth criticizing more. This review wasn't any fantastic and i didn't enjoy it.
***

Your review regarding Natsu's heart part was extremely bad you made the demon seed inside Natsu look like forced device to make him stronger because of wrong reasoning moreover you said that only demon slayer should have a demon seed, You ignored that Natsu has a body of human not a complete Etherious like the rest of the demons hence a demon seed must be developed inside him to convert him to such a thing. It's not like Natsu is just a demon.

I have more to say but i will stop here.

I actually think you're trolling a bit, but just in case you're not, i'll answer to you correctly.
In all honesty i disagree with you. This review was excellent.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not saying this because i agree with everything @MLG Bradman wrote (which is the case anyway), or because i love the dude (which is also the case). I genuinely think this review was very well made, and that every review should follow this example.
It seems like you're really having trouble with opinions given in reviews huh. I can actually understand your point of view to a certain extent, but imo a review should still contain the writer's opinion, as long as it is not ridiculously biased ad disrespectful towards other people's opinions. Which clearly wasn't the case here.
But let's not start the debate again. We're all entitled to our opinions. While you're giving this review a 1.24/10, i'd give it a 9.73/10.

@MLG Bradman great work dude. I'm looking forward to reading your future reviews, i hope that'll happen anyway.

It's a good thing to support a friend i actually love that. Tbh i laughed when i put the rating the review deserve more points but it won't exceed 6. But hey!! he rated the chapter 3/10 even when it took from Mashima much time to draw/write the chapter i didn't say he trolled. Because you have the same thought like him you have no problem. The case is reversed here.

I'm sorry to say but it is impossible to please everyone with a review because they add in their own opinion, you have a very different judgement of what it should say and so if you did the review some other people will say it does not represent their opinion but thats just what happens when you write what you think so dont like it? Cool move on and write what you think in the thread.
Also precise rating? There is no such thing as people will enjoy the chapter differently.

If you disagree so much why do you not write the review or step forward to do so other than complaining at how bad the reviews are which you have done to both Bel and Saber.
Saying they are crap (giving it a 1) wont change anything as the reviews are already written so why not just write what you think in the thread and leave it at that or next time write the review yourself if you think these do not represent your views.

I'm not racing to do reviews even if i did a review my grammar would suck. I'd like to give a flawless unbiased review but my English is limited and doesn't help me much and sometimes i fail to express what i feel/want. Thanks to Mr google i can reply and discuss but with poor grammar and vocabs tho i can form a nice paragraphs but it would be time consuming.

Yes it is impossible to please everyone. As a MH member i've to say what i like/disliked regarding this review i will not swallow anything since they don't allow any arguments in the review thread section as i said many times before this ain't a chapter discussion thread.
******

Btw, The second reviewer has a special layers of protection some of them are damaged but it's still enough to prevent me from touching his review thanks to Jinx.

 

[Spirit]

This bait is even lower quality than this chapter
I can't tell if you're trolling or not, because some of the things you say are of Stool proportions.

 

[Raven]

I'll say that while I disagreed with certain aspects, I did enjoy all the reviews up until this point. A lot of thought seemed to have went into writing them.

Anyway, I looked over the first post and I'm still unsure how the process of being picked to do a review works. (Probably because I'm stupid.)
I'd love to do one sometime.

You're no stupid, Actually you're smart because you didn't rush and rereading it many times.
looking forward to see your review, You're a decent member here. You even go against me sometimes but i like your posts because it's healthy/

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 29, 2016, Original Post Date: Dec 29, 2016 ---

This bait is even lower quality than this chapter
I can't tell if you're trolling or not, because some of the things you say are of Stool proportions.

Said the stool itself.

 

[Spirit]

Everyone has already told you this but i'm pretty sure Bel, Ian and Saber didn't write their reviews for you. They wrote down their observations and thoughts... You don't have to post these kinds of things, but you do anyway and trigger all of us sensible people

 

[BluePegasus]

Your review regarding Natsu's heart part was extremely bad you made the demon seed inside Natsu look like forced device to make him stronger because of wrong reasoning moreover you said that only demon slayer should have a demon seed, You ignored that Natsu has a body of human not a complete Etherious like the rest of the demons hence a demon seed must be developed inside him to convert him to such a thing. It's not like Natsu is just a demon./write the chapter i didn't say he trolled. Because you have the same thought like him you have no problem. The case is reversed here.

How coincidental! You downplayed someone else's review for the EXACT SAME reason as last time; only because he/she said something "negative" (in your point of view) about your favourite character in the series. You know, this is a fucking forum and we're all free to say whatever we want about released chapters whether you like it or not. People are free to express their opinion in own made reviews and they don't need to take disagreements into account. Deal with it, start learning the definition behind a review or just shut your complaining mouth about write-ups where people put a lot of time in.

 

[Raven]

Everyone has already told you this but i'm pretty sure Bel, Ian and Saber didn't write their reviews for you. They wrote down their observations and thoughts... You don't have to post these kinds of things, but you do anyway and trigger all of us unsensible people

I will say some good stuff to good stuff
Bad stuff to bad stuff.
Don't worry.

Also fixed the part in your flawed post.

How coincidental! You downplayed someone else's review for the EXACT SAME reason as last time; only because he/she said something "negative" (in your point of view) about your favourite character in the series. You know, this is a fucking forum and we're all free to say whatever we want about released chapters whether you like it or not. People are free to express their opinion in own made reviews and they don't need to take disagreements into account. Deal with it, start learning the definition behind a review or just shut your complaining mouth about write-ups where people put a lot of time in.

 

[Doughboy]

This can't be a weekly occurrence... it's too childish imo. Although it's actually pretty entertaining. Raven just remember that the review is in MLG's view, not mine, not yours. Also don't forget the review isn't a consensus of everyone's thoughts at all and never will be, it's literally the reviewer's. Not a big deal to criticize the points in his review if you feel that way cause I can say I didn't agree with everything either so what you're saying isn't wrong... doesn't mean it wasn't properly done, expressed, and explained which is why your comment is wild off base and triggering people. You're more undermining MLG's review as a whole which is lame. Your English is perfectly understandable honestly so if you really wanted to do one you would.

Also being a "decent" member shouldn't factor in how to feel about someone's review. It's a great review when every requirement is fulfilled and expressed in the reviewer's pov.

 

[Spirit]

I will say some good stuff to good stuff
Bad stuff to bad stuff.
Don't worry.

Also fixed the part in your flawed post.

Oh come now that kind of behavior isn't necessary at all. Why don't you just PM a Mod with your complaints about a review each week and let them tell you that no they aren't going to take the review down or something so that this can be solved much quicker if you plan on doing this on a weekly basis. As Dough has said this is a Community Forum where people are free to share their own opinions. And yes that is what you are doing but instead of bashing on other people's reviews and opinions, why not just post your own review of the chapter? It gets linked from the first review anyway. Or better yet, stop preaching about how everyone's reviews should align with your own opinions otherwise they're trash...

And aslo, rating someone's review? Really?

 

[Brandish μ]

Well I don't think Raven is trolling with her comments, but the score is definitely suspicious. How did you get 1.24? That's a very specific number

If possible, can we stay on point (the review itself, or FT manga). We already did the whole thing about opinions and stuff. Discussing the review is okay (for now). But if it turns into a comment-fest every week about bias etc, then we probably have to work something else out, like no review discussion for example.

I'm here to say that review doesn't represent my opinion at all.

Once more, the review is not the consensus of the forum. It's the view of whoever writes it. It's like a user review from IMDB.com, but with our minimum standards applied.

 

[Ebony Maw]

First review i disagreed because of the reasons i said before but again bashing 2 panels in 4.5 lines isn't healthy and doesn't represent my opinion regarding this part but He/she praised another moment worth criticizing more. This review wasn't any fantastic and i didn't enjoy it.

Just because you didn't agree with her opinions doesn't mean it's a bad review though, had the positions been flipped and she effectively called your review crap just because she didn't agree on most points, would you say it's fair then?

Your review regarding Natsu's heart part was extremely bad

From an objective sense or a subjective one? My view was subjective and I made that clear, your view on this review is no more objective than my view on the chapter.

you made the demon seed inside Natsu look like forced device to make him stronger because of wrong reasoning moreover you said that only demon slayer should have a demon seed,

Well first, I didn't pass that off as fact, I stated that it was my opinion that it feels forced. Second, it does seem incredibly forced, we already had the Book of E.N.D, so why was there a need for another E.N.D related plot device? Thirdly, going by what we've been told, Dragon Seeds are only found inside the Dragon Slayers, so why would it differ in the case of Demon Seeds and Demon Slayers?

You ignored that Natsu has a body of human not a complete Etherious like the rest of the demons hence a demon seed must be developed inside him to convert him to such a thing. It's not like Natsu is just a demon.

Zeref revived him as a demon though, he put Ether into Natsu's body and guess what else is made of Ether? The Etherious.

 

[Raven]

Just because you didn't agree with her opinions doesn't mean it's a bad review though, had the positions been flipped and she effectively called your review crap just because she didn't agree on most points, would you say it's fair then?

From an objective sense or a subjective one? My view was subjective and I made that clear, your view on this review is no more objective than my view on the chapter.

Well first, I didn't pass that off as fact, I stated that it was my opinion that it feels forced. Second, it does seem incredibly forced, we already had the Book of E.N.D, so why was there a need for another E.N.D related plot device? Thirdly, going by what we've been told, Dragon Seeds are only found inside the Dragon Slayers, so why would it differ in the case of Demon Seeds and Demon Slayers?

Zeref revived him as a demon though, he put Ether into Natsu's body and guess what else is made of Ether? The Etherious.

I won't be bothered, I guarantee that


You wasn't objective you didn't represent any fact. I can say easily that i'm more objective. Don't bring objectivity when your review lacks it regarding this part

It wasn't forced because we know how he get the seeds, If you want something forced look at Gray/Silver or Erza/Irene.
The demon seed inside Natsu wasn't a device, It was an explanation about his case and why he is a demon. The device is the fusion of Demon and Dragon seed fusion because it would make him very strong. Zeref revived Natsu as a demon in a human body not like Mard or other demons from complete Etherious so the demon seed is the reason of his transformation to a demon because he has demon powers. Not rocket science you know.

********
1.24/10 triggered ppl over 500 words?



Pretty funny ppl show hating regarding some parts under the word criticizing and they can't handle it.. Hope you feel now how the Mangaka feel when someone downplay his/her manga.

 

[Spirit]

I won't be bothered, I guarantee that


You wasn't objective you didn't represent any fact. I can say easily that i'm more objective. Don't bring objectivity when your review lacks it regarding this part

The demon seed inside Natsu wasn't a device, It was an explanation about his case and why he is a demon. The device is the fusion of Demon and Dragon seed fusion because it would make him very strong. Zeref revived Natsu as a demon in a human body not like Mard or other demons from complete Etherious so the demon seed is the reason of his transformation to a demon because he has demon powers. Not rocket science you know

********
1.24/10 triggered ppl over 500 words?



Pretty funny ppl show hating regarding some parts under the word criticizing and they can't handle it.. Hope you feel now how the Mangaka feel when someone downplay his/her manga.

I don't think it's fair that you're trying to shift the blame here. You're trying to justify your own hastily thrown out reaction to someone who doesn't think the same way you do. I think it'd be best if you just didn't post this kind of thing each week since you know that it's going to elicit this kind of response. If you do continue though I'd be forced to assume you're just trying to cause drama.

 

[Raven]

I don't think it's fair that you're trying to shift the blame here. You're trying to justify your own hastily thrown out reaction to someone who doesn't think the same way you do. I think it'd be best if you just didn't post this kind of thing each week since you know that it's going to elicit this kind of response. If you do continue though I'd be forced to assume you're just trying to cause drama.

I will post them weekly

You can call it drama, trolling or anything, Simply i don't care about what you think

 

[Spirit]

Ugh, I've had enough of this. I've made it known how I feel about this fiasco. Others can agree or disagree at whim.