I don't really care about Jan Is In Danger. Not painfully unfunny, but also didn't get close to laughing once. I'll probably read it for a few chapters before I forget one week and then drop it because I didn't even realize I stopped reading it.
===
I always appreciate an anime reference sneaked into the manga, thank you, Shinohara (the first OP is named Watch me!)
What a great wrap up for Witch Watch. I never really thought the "extended multi month epilogue" dream was ever really realistic, I can't think of many (if any) non pillar level Jump series that got more than one or two chapters for an ending, so I was wondering how this was going to actually go and I think it was a splendid reinforcement of the main idea of the series (
you get to define your life, not the world) while showing everyone grew from their experiences living under the same house. They were brought together by duty and obligation, but they grew to love each other and now they choose to stick together (though maybe to Moi's chagrin!).
As for the series as a whole? Man, what can you really say? Every single week it managed to not only be funny, but it succeeded at feeling fresh. The world is meant to be fun and completely unpredictable, and that was Witch Watch. One week we got a Minecraft parody, the next we get a heartfelt story about Kanshi being down on his luck but still having a big heart. Shinohara was a Sorachi assistant, and you can tell because he's also the master of being able to seamlessly shift genre and tone from chapter to chapter
and arguably is better at it since I still enjoyed Witch Watch when it got action serious at the end, unlike Gintama. It's really really
really hard to be able to say you released a good chapter almost every single week, but Witch Watch can hold its head high and say it did.
Shinohara obviously is a king when it comes to making lovable characters, but I think this series takes the cake. Back in Sket Dance (and what little I've read of Astra Lost in Space), there's obviously a lot of really strong supporting characters, but there was still a few that I didn't care all that much for. In Witch Watch, every single character felt worth introducing and enjoyable. Some people say every Pokemon is at least one person's favorite, and I think you can make that claim about Witch Watch too without it feeling ironic. You can't spend two chapters focusing on an in universe manga and their creators, and having a ton of readers hope that said in universe manga got even more spotlight, without those characters being very charming after all. Some people are definitely more one tropey than others, but everyone felt distinct and like they belonged in this world because the series, once again, is trying to show that you belong no matter how much of a weirdo or different you are. And the main core five (or six if we count Ban), are just extremely likeable and fleshed out. Anyone can relate to them: feeling as weighed down by duty as Moi, wanting to expect the best in people like Nico, being insecure in yourself like Keigo, constantly failing and having to get up like Kanshi, trying to find your place in the world like Miharu. They all show clear growth and acceptance in themselves that demonstrate that they're actual people with urgency. They all exist as people outside the main plot of the series, with their own stories and worlds to develop.
And to go back to the seamlessly shifting through genres part, I really want to highlight it because Shinohara is gifted. I'll admit the first time this happened, in the first year (pretty sure it's Dog and Raindrops), I felt it was fine but kind of lacking, but in hindsight I think it was solely because it was too soon. We needed time to get invested in the main cast's lives so that when their normal is challenged, we can actually care about it. Every other time, the action parts were a proper balance of emotional moving and being able to find proper humor to bring levity. Shinohara obviously isn't known as an action artist, but he made every fight feel so unique and easy to follow (which some newbie battle authors don't always try to do) that in another life, I think he could have been a hit battle author. There were times where I got close to crying or I said "damn" out loud. And being able to completely change the artstyle: from the flatten spell, to the Minecraft spell, even something like making the covers look very pop art like, all while never making it feel like a needless gimmick just to draw in readers. Shinohara truly showcased why he's a master class mangaka with Witch Watch and the true gap between a long lasting veteran and a newer author. He truly understands how to use manga as a piece of art and expression of an artist's heart.
Witch Watch isn't perfect, nothing is, but Witch Watch showed over these five years that it's one of a kind. Nothing can replace it, and Witch Watch itself doesn't want any other series to try. It shows that everyone and everything is unique and they deserve their own place in the world. Aim to be the first Roku. aim to be the first Animal Signal. Aim to be the first whatever, instead of the next whatever. Trying to give similar expectations to other series because they have surface level similarities makes things less fun and makes you less likely to find satisfaction in life because nobody can perfectly fit the box left behind by the previous generation.
I personally think this is Shinohara's last series probably, definitely his last long one, and I'm so grateful that he was allowed to show that he had that magic in him to produce greatness once again.
===
- Graykeith has an aesthetic it's aiming for, and it really knows how to capture it. That western fantasy horror vibe feels so distinct from everything else in the magazine right now.
- Sakamoto is no longer held together by strings and dreams, it just fell apart now. Shame too because I enjoyed the content of the chapter, but god damn the art was bad this week. I sincerely hope Suzuki isn't back for at least two years so that he can feel recharged for his next series.
- Ura great as always. Shun Numa knows how to write a compelling duo dynamic and it's working really well here. Someone Hertz too.
- Animal Signal is dumb every week and it's always so great. You can tell when the authors are having fun making a manga and Robinson and Tsutsui are definitely having fun right now, even if it probably ends with a flop.